As South Africa struggles to agree the details of a new economic policy document with job creation at its core, an appreciating rand is doing nothing to help. Dealing with the currency question is vital to the job creation strategy. South Africa has lost roughly one million jobs since the collapse of Lehman Brothers.
The New Growth Plan unveiled late last year aims to create five million jobs by 2020 and bring down the unemployment rate from the present 25% to 15%. But business, labour unions, civil society and the competing factions in the ruling ANC must all buy in to the methods of reaching these employment goals. Currency policy will be a key sticking point.
According to Nomura, the rand is overvalued to the tune of 25%, making it the world’s most overvalued currency. Only the Australian dollar has appreciated more over the past two years.
In reaction, the authorities have done not much. One view is that a stronger rand will at least cheapen imports for a much-needed infrastructure development programme, with better infrastructure eventually being an alternative facilitator of higher growth. Similarly, it could mean lower inflation.
Brazil’s method of tackling currency appreciation by taxing portfolio inflows is not as well suited to South Africa. Such a move would risk pushing away investors in good times too.
Notwithstanding a $4.6 billion bid by US company Wal-Mart for South African retailer Massmart, Brazil habitually attracts much more foreign direct investment. In any case, since Brazil implemented the taxes in late 2009, the real has maintained its upward trajectory.
The Reserve Bank of South Africa has been slightly less standoffish in its currency policy, adding reserves to the tune of some $2 billion last year. But the bank remains wary of more aggressive intervention. Perhaps the biggest measure, announced late last year, has been to permit a loosening of limits on foreign investment by South African institutional investors, including retirement funds.
Institutions will now be able to invest 25% or 35% abroad (depending on the fund type) compared with 20% or 30% previously.
But Absa Capital says many managers have not used the existing limits, and the rand has continued to rise: raising the question why South Africa bothers with such moves if all they do is underline to the markets the country’s impotence (or lack of resolve) in dealing with the rand’s appreciation.
Because dollar yields are so much lower than rand yields, the Treasury ultimately finances more aggressive intervention by the central bank. The Treasury has enough on its plate in terms of social programmes. But more aggressive intervention might come.
Local elections this spring might provide the political drive for more action (including more relaxation of outflow limits). The Chilean central bank’s decision to step up its interventions might be crucial. The South Africa Reserve Bank will be observing Chile’s experience with avid interest.