Brazil’s belief in terraforming interest rates

Could lower interest rates give lift-off to Brazil’s economy? And how might they be achieved?

When talking to financial professionals in Brazil these days, the conversation often turns to the economy taking the next step in its progress and development. Brazil wants/expects/needs lower interest rates (the verb changes but the basic thrust is consistent) to kick-start a 10-year cycle of sustainable growth.

This faith in the terraforming effect of lowering the base interest rate from its present 10.75% is reminiscent, for connoisseurs of trashy science fiction films, of Total Recall. This 1990 film is set in a mining colony on planet Mars, the commodity being extracted from beneath the surface of the red planet in 2084 is turbinium ore, not iron ore, and there is nothing to suggest that the primary destination is China. A few plot twists aside, the hero (Arnold Schwarzenegger) manages to release oxygen into the Martian atmosphere, kick-starting virtuous oxygen, hydrogen and water cycles that create an earth-like environment able to sustain vegetative growth and human life.

It feels as if Brazil’s financial community believes that if the government was able to release lower interest rates the macro-environment landscape would be radically changed, becoming less febrile and more fertile. With investors’ high interest rate ventilators switched off, springs of long-term financing will appear and infrastructure projects will pop up throughout the country. The Bovespa blooms with IPOs. As equity markets grow, companies, whose growth is buoyed up by lower debt costs, return money to investors, who in turn demand more goods from companies, who employ more Brazilians and lift even more out of poverty. They in turn become consumers – purchasers of mortgages, holidays, and services – and the cycle builds up, virtuously and mutually reinforcing, all the time cooled by a refreshing low-inflationary breeze. The great hot dollar-clouds that once created a dangerous greenhouse effect are no longer drawn into the Brazilian atmosphere.

But even assuming this is approximately correct, there is still the question of how to get to the catalyst: lower interest rates. Much of the data points the other way. The yield difference between the government’s inflation-linked and fixed-rate notes rose to 6.68% on November 22 – showing that investors expect inflation for the next two years to be above the central bank’s target of 4.5% (plus or minus two percentage points). And, largely driven by commodity price increases, inflation will be difficult to control. Government spending has risen 27% in the first nine months of this year and Guido Mantega has been confirmed as president Dilma Rousseff’s finance minister. Although political labels are often misleading in Brazil, Mantega is widely viewed as a proponent of tax-and-spend policies – not the signal to the markets that fiscal tightening is on the cards. Data from Bloomberg show that yields on interest rate futures due in January 2012 leapt 51 basis points since the start of November, signalling that traders expected the central bank to raise the benchmark Selic rate to about 13% by the end of next year.

It is not often that president Rousseff has been compared to the governor of California, but for many in Brazil the key challenge and opportunity for her presidency is to be able to release a lower interest rate into the macroeconomic environment. Some argue that if she cannot do so, not only will the economy miss a decade of virtuous growth but with growth expectations factored into current Brazilian valuations there could be a danger of the reverse: the vicious downward cycle.

A downward spiral is definitely an outlying prediction at present; not many financiers believe that this is real risk. For now, Brazilians are still far more optimistic that they are starring in their own version of Total Recall complete with its happy ending. Very few entertain the possibility that they are, in fact, players in another science-fiction film: Back to the future.