Rising house prices within Israel’s pre-1967 borders are creating more incentives for poorer families to take up lower-cost housing funded by state-subsidized mortgages in the occupied and annexed territories.
Egged on by the central bank, the government says it has responded to lower affordability by selling more state land, and plans to use tax incentives to increase the supply of housing. The problem is that the international community disagrees with Israel’s definition of where housing expansion is legitimate.
Mortgage lenders in Tel Aviv speak for hours about Israel’s red-hot real estate market without once mentioning the West Bank or East Jerusalem. Ask about the link to the building of settlements and the embarrassed, more liberal, respondent will dismiss settlers as fringe right-wing zealots. But a study by Israeli pressure group Peace Now shows that settlers are motivated more by finance than by ideology, in this country of wide income disparities.
Out of a population of seven million, some 500,000 Israeli settlers live on the West Bank and in East Jerusalem. All four of Israel’s biggest banks maintain branches in post-1967 occupied or annexed territory.
According to an October report by Tel Aviv-based research project Who Profits from the Occupation, these banks or their subsidiaries all advance mortgages for settler housing. They also finance the construction of property developments and other businesses in the settlements, and apart from Leumi they all lend money to local authorities in the settlements.
Lower base interest rates over the past two years have meant that Israeli banks, which emerged relatively unscathed from the global crisis, are selling more and more mortgages – across Israel. Mortgages are important for banks’ growth, as housing finance accounts for a relatively low 21% of GDP.
Growth through mergers is not an option for banks in this already highly consolidated sector. International expansion is constrained by conservative regulation and diplomatic concerns. But Israeli banks all have private shareholders to serve (and soon the state will hold no bank shares).
It might be difficult for individual banks to take a stand and distance themselves from the settler movement, even if management wanted to do so. The banks remain – and the settlements have become – an integral part of the state establishment.
Israel’s politicians claim that lack of building is the main cause of higher house prices, and the cause of the accompanying lower standards of living among the less-well-off. In the short term, it might suit the Bank of Israel to see the blame for tight affordability shifted away from monetary policy.
Israeli mortgages have low average loan-to-value ratios and, so far, good repayment records. The country is not yet on the way to a US-style mortgage meltdown. But policymakers should remember that growth in Israeli mortgage books – if it involves building in occupied territory – could cause the country more instability.
see also: