Volumes have never been a particular favourite of mine, especially when they are presented in different formats, in percentage increases, in currencies other than USD. Even so, it came as something of a surprise this week when we were tipped off that Hotspot double count their volumes.
We receive Hotspot’s volumes every month in good faith. Perhaps if we had been a bit sharper, we might have noticed that when we receive volumes from other platforms they explicitly note that all volumes are single counted.
theweeklyFiX put this to Bill Goodbody, director and head of sales at Hotspot. He says: “The volume numbers we put out, we refer to as total client transaction volume on a platform. I imagine our competitors would call that double counting.
“We always focus on what our clients are doing and the volumes that they do. On any given trade, obviously, there are two sides. When I look at how much our clients did on any given day or hour, you come up with a number that is, to me, total volume.
“There’s really no plus or minus to whatever methodology you use as long as you’re upfront about it and the way that you calculate it.”
Maybe HotSpot needs to be a little more “upfront”, however. One senior FX banker says: “I deal with Hotspot and I just think it is misleading to double count your volumes when the rest of the market single counts them.”
The difficulties with deciphering volumes do not stop with Hotspot. Reuters’ single-counted volumes represent not just what goes through the platform but also through their internet chat application, Thomson Reuters Dealing.
Some banks present their volumes to include their prime brokerage transactions, while others treat prime brokerage as a separate category.
Perhaps in an ideal world there would be some kind of set standard of how volumes should be presented so that clients can get a clearer picture.
“A trend we’re interested in seeing, as an industry, is more disclosure not less,” says Goodbody.
“I would like to think, as an industry, we we’ll arrive at some common methodology that works for everyone. Whether it be single-count or double-count, that’s fine.”
So Hotspot wouldn’t mind us halving their volumes next time so we have a bit of consistency?
Just kidding.