What more can Abu Dhabi do?

Banks in the UAE are a long way from provisioning for Dubai’s debt and property crises.

Aabar, an Abu Dhabi state-linked investment vehicle, became the second-largest shareholder in UniCredit, Europe’s third-largest bank by market value, in late June. It paid $2.5 billion. Given the parlous state of Dubai’s economy and property market, Abu Dhabi’s interests might be better served by more investment in UAE banks.

The emirates’ corporate and banking sectors are closely intertwined. UAE banks received more than $19 billion in funding from the federal authorities in 2009. The sector’s total capital adequacy rose from 13.3% to 19.2% last year, with the tier 1 ratio rising from 11.7% to 15.5%.

According to a Fitch report in late June, average non-performing loans would now have to more than double before the average tier 1 ratio fell below the central bank’s minimum 8%.

But loans affected by the $23.5 billion restructuring of state investment agency Dubai World might still need to be classified as problematic, despite arrangements for creditors to receive 100% of their claims. According to Reuters, UAE banks have an estimated $15 billion exposure to Dubai World, with Abu Dhabi Commercial Bank and Dubai’s Emirates NBD thought to have the biggest position.

Dubai World’s problems alone could therefore cause the average problem-loan ratio to double to more than 9.5% by 2011, according to a recent Moody’s report. Meanwhile, worries about Dubai World are being replaced by expectations of a restructuring of all or part of Dubai Holding, the ruler’s personal investment vehicle, with an estimated minimum debt of about $10 billion.

As slower economic growth caused widespread retail and corporate defaults, UAE NPLs have already risen to 4.3% in 2009 from 1.7% a year earlier. This included exposure among UAE banks of almost $3 billion to Saudi Arabia’s Saad and Al Gosaibi groups, according to the central bank. Moody’s expects more impaired loans to seep from 1.3% of gross loans on average being renegotiated and restructured at the end of 2009.

Some expect that this year the central bank will tighten rules on when loans should be classed as non-performing. Indeed, the stricter criteria used by HSBC Middle East means its NPL ratio of 7.3% at the end of 2009 – the highest in the UAE – could be another indicator of what is to come. UAE banks’ average reserve ratio for NPLs fell from 148% in 2008 to 97% in 2009. Provisions have continued to rise in 2010.

So far in 2010 loan growth has been slow to non-existent. Average loan-to-deposit ratios hover just over 100%. Deposits growth is non-existent. National Bank of Abu Dhabi is the only UAE lender to have accessed the bond market since Dubai World’s debt standstill announcement in November.

If the global economy takes another tumble, Dubai will find it even harder to recover by exploiting its status as a trading hub. UAE banks will suffer even more, and without more help from Abu Dhabi, they will be even less able to support Dubai’s property market, economy and corporations.