| Palocci: tightening the reins |
At the end of August, there was something of a showdown in Uruguay. Leftist president Tabare Vázquez wanted to revise the country’s multi-year budget plan so that it would guarantee expenditure on education of at least 4.5% of GDP. That was, after all, one of his campaign promises.
But Vázquez’s finance minister, Danilo Astori, had other ideas. Fiscal constraints, he said, meant that the government could guarantee education expenditure of only 3.5% of GDP. So he quit.
Soon, however, Astori was back in the finance ministry, and the budget plan had no explicit assurances with respect to education. “As expected, the Uruguayan government’s budget is austere and places strong emphasis on fiscal responsibility with a social twist,” says Franco Uccelli, an analyst at Bear Stearns.
The clash between a left-wing president and his fiscally conservative finance minister was rare only insofar as it was played out in public. For that combination, once thought impossible, is now very much the norm in Latin America: it’s not just tiny Uruguay preaching fiscal prudence in spite of the fact that the president is more conversant with communist guerrillas than Chicago School economics.
Next door, in Brazil, finance minister Antonio Palocci cut fiscal spending as soon as president Lula appointed him to his position. In Chile, president Ricardo Lagos – the first member of his party to rise to the presidency since the assassination of Salvador Allende in 1973 – kicked off his administration with harsh spending cuts delivered by finance minister Nicolas Eyzaguirre. In Argentina, finance minister Roberto Lavagna has regularly acted to restrain president Néstor Kirchner’s populist instincts. And in Peru, leftist president Alejandro Toledo appointed Pedro Pablo Kuczynski, a former chairman of First Boston International, to run the finance ministry.
| Astori: clashing with the president |
The combination seems to work well. Only Richard Nixon could go to China, and only leftists seem to be able to get away with fiscal austerity: they can’t lose votes to the left. Latin left-wingers know their recent history, and the importance of Robert Rubin to Bill Clinton and Gordon Brown to Tony Blair. They also know the importance of staying in the good books of the international capital markets.
“There has been a quantum leap in the economic literacy of the presidents we have in Latin America,” says Arturo Porzecanski, professor of international finance at American University in Washington, DC. “It tells you something about the education of this generation of presidents. There’s a level of recognition of reality that causes one to take one’s hat off.”
What’s more, notes José Cerritelli, an analyst at Exotix in New York and who has served as an informal economic adviser to Peruvian demagogue Alan García, presidents of yesteryear felt they had a choice. “In the past, alternatives were viable,” he says. “Countries looked inwards for financial markets and trade. Now they are exposed to the reaction of foreigners.”
Cerritelli notes that the one big exception to the rule of fiscal prudence, Venezuela, is also the most self-sufficient of all Latin American economies. In general, he says, “the divorce between policy and politics that has so surprised people in the past will only be improved in the future”.
That said, it’s pretty easy for any finance minister to be on the side of the angels in the present economic climate of strong growth and low interest rates. If the minister can raise spending and maintain a primary surplus at the same time, then everybody’s happy. Porzecanski notes: “In Mexico, there’s a big debate about running a tiny surplus, when they should be running a massive surplus. Behind the conservative [finance minister] Paco Gil Diaz is a substantial increase in spending.”
But the fact remains that it was leftists who finally brought government spending under control in most of Latin America. Even if they start spending again in the face of an economic downturn, that’s no more than their right-wing counterparts would probably do as well. And of course the most fiscally irresponsible government in all the Americas is also the most politically right-wing: that of the US.
Left-wing governments in Latin America, it seems, are leftist mainly in terms of such things as foreign policy, labour policy and food distribution programmes. When it comes to fiscal policy, they’re further to the right than any of their predecessors.