Recently released data from CLS Bank suggest that the FX market did not experience any seasonal slowdown during December. CLS says it made an average of 218,700 payment instructions a day throughout the month. The average daily value of transactions passing through the system was $2.6 trillion, which CLS says was an increase of 3.7% on November.
CLS adds that it made a record value day on December 21, settling $4.6 trillion-worth of transactions. The level of activity has subsequently continued to grow in the New Year and CLS reports that on January 17 it made a total of 502,384 payment instructions. These had a gross value of $3.9 trillion. CLS is now handling a daily average of 220,000 payment instructions, with a gross value of $2.6 trillion.
Jonathan Butterfield, executive vice-president, sales and communications, at CLS, believes that the recent increase in volume is possibly being driven by an uptake in algorithmic trading.
“The December downturn didn’t materialize. People kept trading at a pretty consistent level. We reckon it’s partly driven by an increase in algorithmic trading. There was quite an uptick in sub-$1 million activity,” he says. “We don’t know definitely if these were hedge fund trades, but we believe they probably were,” he adds.
Butterfield says that because of the use of prime brokers, it is not currently possible for CLS to identify for sure whether either hedge funds or their use of algorithms is behind the increase in volumes. But the expansion in the number of relatively small trades makes both premises reasonable assumptions.
Ostensibly, CLS’s figures point to a substantial expansion in the FX market’s size, especially as it only settles about 45% of the total volume. However, some care needs to be given to how the data is interpreted. CLS calculates its turnover figures in a different manner to the way the Bank for International Settlements does in its authoritative triennial market survey. In the most recent survey covering April 2004, BIS reported that daily FX volume averaged a net $1.9 trillion.
Double counting
In contrast, CLS reports on a gross basis. Every spot and forward transaction is effectively double counted, as two payment instructions are processed. For swaps, four payment instructions are sent. Butterfield estimates that if BIS calculated its figures in the same manner, it would have reported gross volumes in April 2004 as being $5.4 trillion. But even this would not allow a like-for-like comparison, as the BIS data also includes intra-company financing swaps, which are not regarded by market participants as FX trades.
CLS says that spot accounted for 51% of the value of the transactions it processed in December, with short-dates and forwards making up a further 45%. This suggests that CLS processed spot, short-date and forward deals with a net daily value of $1.25 trillion in the month. Accepting that CLS settles 45% of daily FX transactions, this more than supports the anecdotal evidence that the FX market has grown by about a third since the April 2004 BIS Triennial Survey. In fact it would suggest even stronger growth, and estimates that the net daily volume transacted in the FX market is in excess of $2.5 trillion look slightly modest.
“This December was more active than in previous years and we saw activity coming from a wide variety of different types of customer,” says Steve Kemp, global head of FX at Merrill Lynch. “Much has been made of FX being recognized as an asset class in its own right. There is no doubt that this is the case and the fact that FX is continuing to attract new participants strongly supports the view that the market remains in a strong growth phase,” he adds.