EuromoneyFXNews.com

EuromoneyFXNews.com

Sign up to receive free alerts from our foreign exchange news service

Euromoney’s 2012 FX survey results

Euromoney’s 2012 FX survey results

Access the results now

September 2011

Email a Friend

  • All fields are compulsory


To include more than one recipient, please separate each email address with a semi-colon ';'





Add Your Comment


  • All fields are compulsory
  • All comments are subject to editorial review as we are subject to the same regulations adhered to in publishing our own content. For this reason, your comment may not be live immediately, or may not be published.






I have read and agree to the Terms and Conditions




  • Is this Euromoney's poor attempt to justify its blindingly obvious mis-judgement in awarding Swan finance minister of the year. Or perhaps the start of an apology by the magazine which most australians are expecting.

    21 Sep 2011 03:14

    Author: Fred

  • Swan is a joke, you must be kidding.
    Next you should award Gaddafi the global humanitarian award!


    21 Sep 2011 04:03

    Author: Milton

  • Swan is without doubt the worst treasurer Australia has ever had. The mismanagement has been absolutely astounding and your article and award agree that you no nothing of Australian affairs or the man who is about to be booted very, very hard by the Australian people who hate his incompetence!

    21 Sep 2011 05:00

    Author: Jonathan

  • Honestly , i have never heard of your mag but Eric Ellis , mate , this guy has no depth of Fiscal management whatso-ever , Dec 08 he advises Aussies to lock home loans in fixed rates as rates are on the up for sure - and 63,000 homeowners did .....and in Jan 09 interest rates started going down in fact they went down 5% and everyone started losing there homes based on this morons advice - you could not find a better example of waste in any socialist govt on the planet at the moment - they have turned a 30 billion surplus into a 150 billion deficit , i can asure you Eric there is no rose coloured glasses in australia - he is like a wart on the end of your nose - for more than 80% of aussies ...ps Keatings reply to your question fits him perfect....even he doesnt want to be assoc with this fool....

    21 Sep 2011 09:44

    Author: Barry

  • If Wayne Swan is Finance Minister of the year, then I am Bill Gates’ butler.

    Those at your magazine responsible for this joke of an award recipient have obviously done a course in how to disregard making sound, evidence-based decisions, and have graduated with first-class honours.

    History is littered with awards to mediocrity, and this is just another chapter that hard-working and fed-up Australians do not deserve to have anything to do with.


    21 Sep 2011 09:54

    Author: Nick

  • If Wayne Swan is Finance Minister of the year, then I am Bill Gates’ butler.

    Those at your magazine responsible for this joke of an award recipient have obviously done a course in how to disregard making sound, evidence-based decisions, and have graduated with first-class honours.

    History is littered with awards to mediocrity, and this is just another chapter that hard-working and fed-up Australians do not deserve to have anything to do with.


    21 Sep 2011 10:16

    Author: Nick

  • Obviously Euromoney hasn't got a clue about the Australian economy and the history of it over the last 4 years since Swan became the treasurer. If your idea of quality financial management is turning a surplus into the largest debt we've had since WW2, then gong away. To Australian's he is the most incompetent treasurer in our history. You wouldn't even trust him with your credit card.
    Oh and by the way, how are Lehman Brothers going......Bear Sterns??....Morgan Stanley maybe. Great track record Euromoney. Swan joins those other choice picks by your good selves. Dare I say it, it's nothing much to hang your hat on.


    21 Sep 2011 10:25

    Author: Goat

  • Given that Swannie the Goose is as Treasurer but a mere wart on the bottom of Costello's or Keating'sbig toe, who if he is lucky, manages to be a legend at his own breakfast table ( and then only if is eating alone), I can only assume that he won this rather dubious prize by default, especially as how you eurotrash are doing you best to take the rest of the world with you.

    You should have done yourselves a favor and have decided that no one deserved the award this year. Instead you have destroyed your credibility, and it will take a long time for it to be restored.


    21 Sep 2011 10:59

    Author: Vernon

  • Contrary Indicator?

    Euromoney 2006 Best Investment Bank - Lehman Brothers (Busted 2007)

    Euromoney 2006 Best Equity House - Morgan Stanley (Bailed out 2007)

    Euromoney 2006 Best at Risk Management - Bear Stearns (Busted 2007)

    Euromoney 2006 Best at Investor Services - Citigroup (Bailed out 2007)


    21 Sep 2011 12:42

  • Honestly , i have never heard of your mag but Eric Ellis , mate , this guy has no depth of Fiscal management whatso-ever , Dec 08 he advises Aussies to lock home loans in fixed rates as rates are on the up for sure - and 63,000 homeowners did .....and in Jan 09 interest rates started going down in fact they went down 5% and everyone started losing there homes based on this morons advice - you could not find a better example of waste in any socialist govt on the planet at the moment - they have turned a 30 billion surplus into a 150 billion deficit , i can asure you Eric there is no rose coloured glasses in australia - he is like a wart on the end of your nose - for more than 80% of aussies ...ps Keatings reply to your question fits him perfect....even he doesnt want to be assoc with this fool....

    21 Sep 2011 12:55

    Author: Barry

  • Believe me, if you don't withdraw this award from the worst treasurer in Australia's history, EuroMoney will have about as much credibility as the twats who gave Obama a Nobel Prize.

    21 Sep 2011 12:57

  • So I am guessing Euromoney put up Greece as economy of the year as well? Haha.

    I think the legendary Mr Keating is being appropriately dismissive, once again :)


    21 Sep 2011 14:05

    Author: Mick

  • WOW. What a bunch of angry Liberals (Conservatives). I did like how the article had to make that clear. As for all the criticism...Swan handled the GFC amazingly well. You can't be angry with that. Thank you for providing some perspective Euromoney. Us Australians often get upset about small things like people in boats and awards...don't take it too personally.

    21 Sep 2011 18:56

    Author: Zachary


How Euromoney’s finance minister award became an Aussie political football


 

Australian treasurer, Wayne Swan 

see also:

Press release

Swan confounds his domestic sceptics 

More Asia coverage

Finance minister of the year Wayne Swan
Media coverage
 

Although it applauds sound stewardship of an important global economy, in jeering Australian hands Euromoney’s finance minister of the year award has become a political football punted around Canberra since Paul Keating was honoured in 1984, his first year in office, for floating the Australian dollar and rejuvenating a moribund banking sector with foreign competition, inspired reforms few expected of a union-dominated Labor government.

And it’s a football that’s never been more gleefully kicked than by Peter Costello, Keating and Swan’s ideological nemesis, whose 11 years as what Australians archaically call treasurer is Australia’s longest tenure in the office.

The unawarded Costello is long believed to be privately chagrined at this perceived snub. He seizes every opportunity to pan the award and Keating too, who had enthusiastically embraced it as the international imprimatur of a lustre that Australians, for whom it’s a national sport to spit contempt at their leaders, didn’t and wouldn’t. This might well be the fate that awaits Swan, for a prize perceived as a poisoned chalice in Canberra.

We asked Costello to critique the performance of Swan, the man who succeeded him as treasurer. When untouchable in government, Costello liked to waltz through parliamentary halls warbling an Al Jolson classic – "how I love you, how I love you, my dear old Swanee" – usually after he’d again savaged the colourless Queenslander on the floor of the House. But times change. Costello ignored our invitation.

And maybe those earlier long and painful years fielding Costello’s barbs did wound "The World’s Greatest Treasurer", as Costello still likes to mockingly label Paul Keating, because he wasn’t initially particularly forthcoming either. When Euromoney sought comment from the only other Australian ever to have received our award, the famously flinty Keating’s instinctive reaction was to tell us "to just fuck off" and "I couldn’t give a fuck", while curtly offering what appeared to be travel advice, suggesting we visit some place called "buggery".

Which is where voters might also soon dispatch Swan, a Keating-era backbencher, if he follows his former leader’s example in steering Australia into a policy-induced recession, as Keating did in 1991, the last time Australia experienced one, and a gift for the ever-taunting Costello.



Take a free trial to Euromoney now








Download the Free Euromoney iPad app today