1MDB net widens to Deutsche and JPMorgan

With Goldman and AmBank behind it, Malaysia aims further afield with lawsuits.

Having settled its differences with Goldman Sachs, Malaysia has embarked upon a new round of litigation including suits against Deutsche Bank, JPMorgan and Coutts over failed state investment fund 1MDB.

A filing seen by Euromoney was light on detail – it says that the body of claims overall, including several against individuals, are based on “negligence, breach of contract, conspiracy to defraud/injure, and/or dishonest assistance” – but did show the amounts being claimed.

Malaysia wants $1.1 billion from Deutsche, $800 million from JPMorgan, and $1.03 billion from Coutts

Malaysia wants $1.1 billion from Deutsche, $800 million from JPMorgan, and $1.03 billion from Coutts.

For clues as to why these suits have been raised, our best source is the Department of Justice complaint that was filed back in 2016.

This goes into detail about a $1 billion-equivalent foreign exchange transfer from 1MDB into the bank account of a joint venture between 1MDB and PetroSaudi, handled by Deutsche, of which $700 million was eventually diverted to another account, called Good Star.

Beneficial owner

This was beneficially owned by Low Taek Jho, usually known as Jho Low and allegedly the main protagonist in the whole scandal.

This all happened in 2009, and the DoJ complaint suggested that Deutsche was deliberately misled by 1MDB.

It includes transcripts of conversations on September 30 that year between a supervisor and a 1MDB officer.

The 1MDB figure warns that “if they’re [Deutsche compliance team] going to overkill on the compliance thing, they have to be responsible,” while the Deutsche employee somewhat meekly attempts to find out why the transfer is going to PetroSaudi.

JPMorgan appears in the complaint because it was the correspondent bank for that transfer and another for AmBank that ended up in the Good Star account. It was also the correspondent bank for transfers from Good Star to the accounts of a Saudi prince who co-founded PetroSaudi, from which the money was allegedly transferred to then-prime minister Najib Razak, who has been sentenced to 12 years’ imprisonment and faces further charges.

And RBS Coutts appears in the complaint because it held the Good Star account; Jho Low apparently opened that account at an RBS Coutts branch in Singapore in June 2009.

All three appear considerably further removed from events than Goldman, or indeed Deloitte or AmBank, both of which have reached settlements with Malaysia.

Deutsche Bank said: “We do not believe there is any legitimate basis for, nor merit to, any claims by 1MDB and will be reviewing the matter accordingly.”

The bank also pointed to the DoJ complaint, which alleged that 1MDB made “material misrepresentations and omissions to Deutsche bank officials.”

JPMorgan declined to comment.

It is clear that the government has not finished trying to claw back funds related to one of the greatest reputational disasters in the history of financial services.