![]() |
Hungarian bankers are understandably wary of intervention in their industry. Six years of punitive bank taxes, not to mention the prohibitively expensive conversion of all the country’s Swiss franc loans into forint in 2014, have left a legacy of mistrust between banks and policymakers.
So when central bank (MNB) officials said in February that they were planning measures to cut the cost of mortgages for Hungarian consumers, it caused consternation in the financial sector.
Many saw the announcement as a sign that the Hungarian authorities were unhappy with the recent recovery in bank profitability. Others fretted that the move could mark the start of a new wave of populist bank-bashing ahead of next year’s parliamentary elections.
Talk of capping mortgage spreads well below current market levels fanned the fears and prompted a succession of bankers to issue urgent warnings of the dangers of undermining their industry.
After all this, the MNB’s unveiling last month of the outcome of its deliberations came as something of an anti-climax, as well as a surprise. In place of the expected attack on bank profits, the central bank revealed plans to encourage lenders to make home loans more affordable through the introduction of government certification.
Taking out a mortgage in Hungary is a very opaque process at the moment. The final price borrowers will pay for their loans is usually only revealed after they have signed the contract – Aniko Szombati, MNB
From June 1, Hungarian banks will be able to apply to participate in the scheme if they can provide mortgages that meet the MNB’s guidelines. These include a minimum fixed-rate period of three years, reduced upfront charges and maximum repayment fees of 1%.
Spreads for certified mortgages will indeed be capped, but at 350 basis points rather than the 250bp mooted in March. According to the MNB, more than two-thirds of floating rate and one-third of fixed rate housing loans issued last year would have qualified on price.
Aniko Szombati, head of the MNB’s macroprudential directorate, says the idea of the scheme – which will be entirely voluntary – is to inject some much-needed competition and transparency into the mortgage segment.
“Taking out a mortgage in Hungary is a very opaque process at the moment,” she says. “The final price borrowers will pay for their loans is usually only revealed after they have signed the contract. We want to create a standardized product that will make it easy for consumers to compare offerings from different banks.”
To make the process even more transparentHu, the MNB plans to create its own mortgage calculator and comparison website. Szombati says this should be up and running by September, two months after the first certified mortgages are due to appear on the market.
Caps
As to the caps on fees and spreads, Szombati notes that these will only bring the Hungarian market – or at least the certified part of it – into line with the rest of central Europe. Mortgage rates in Hungary remain extremely high by regional standards despite historically low reference rates. Repayment fees are also double those charged in neighbouring markets.
This may of course be partly due to the banks’ need to plug the holes made in their balance sheets by the Hungarian government. The fact that they have been able to get away with charging such high rates, however, does speak to a lack of competition in the market.
This in turn is partly due to the inertia of Hungarian retail customers, according to Szombati. “Consumers tend to have one fixed banking relationship,” she says. “They are not really aware of other banks’ offerings. They don’t often change banks, and refinancing of loans is also fairly infrequent.”
The MNB is hoping that its ‘certified consumer-friendly housing loans’ will encourage home-buyers to become more discerning, as well as making mortgages more accessible for customers in rural areas and for lower-income borrowers.
On the industry side, the scheme has been greeted with mild to moderate enthusiasm – at least in public. The Hungarian Banking Association (HBA) described it as “the next step in the natural evolution process the regulatory authorities and banking sector jointly follow with a view to supporting sustainable lending practices”.
Levente Kovacs, the HBA’s chief secretary, says the association had supported the development of certified mortgages and expects them to be offered by “key retail banks”.
Sceptical
Off the record, some local bankers remained sceptical. “In itself, the MNB’s proposals are nothing to worry about, but the tone during the discussions was a bit alarming,” says one. “It seems as though the authorities have decided that we’re too profitable again and they want to regulate our profits away.”
Szombati is adamant that this is not the case. “We have a view on what level of bank profitability is more favourable from a long-term sustainability perspective, but overall, banks in Hungary are currently very close to that level,” she says.
“In any case, we have no intention to change this in either direction. We just want to ensure that future credit expansion will be founded on a prudent basis.”
It all seems entirely rational and even laudable. The question bankers will be asking is whether or not Hungary’s combative prime minister, Viktor Orban, agrees. Bank-bashing has been a source of great political capital for him in past elections, not to mention funding after them. Will he resist the temptation this time?
Hungary’s banks will have to hope so.
