Will the credit rally stick?

When everyone agrees everything’s alright, we’ve a classic sign of a bubble.

Talk to credit market participants about the rally of 2009 and many make tongue-in-cheek references to a certain kind of primate, who, had it had access to funds under management and a telephone, could have reaped rich rewards this year as well. The potent combination of severe market dislocation in 2008 and heavy doses of central bank liquidity administered in its wake has conspired to crush credit spreads and revive positive market sentiment. As the year draws to a close what’s perhaps more surprising is that more money hasn’t been taken off the table. One would typically expect the rally to stall as trading desks and investors lock in profits. The evidence of that is scant.

At a credit conference hosted by Citigroup in London last month a straw poll of several hundred investors at one particular session revealed why. When the audience was asked if they thought credit spreads would be significantly wider in 2010, just two investors raised their hands. Whether or not this rally can be classified as a bubble is open to debate, but one of its classic traits is already prevalent: overriding consensus among market participants.

The two things fixed income investors fear the most in 2010 is the threat that central banks may withdraw their liquidity support from the market and an outbreak of inflation. Rising prices would force the Federal Reserve to tighten monetary policy, raising the prospect of a double dip recession and the wider credit spreads that would probably follow. There seems little fear of that out there. Goldman Sachs expects core CPI inflation to fall to around 0% by the end of 2010 year-on-year because of record high unemployment, low capacity utilisation and a wide output gap. This is not the wholesale view. Deutsche Bank for instance, believes the Fed will start raising rates in the second half of the year.

As for central banks withdrawing liquidity from the market, most investors seem to believe it will be a gradual withdrawal of cheap market funding over a period of years, rather than total, immediate cold turkey. The evidence seems to suggest that the slide is already happening. The European Central Bank’s balance sheet has fallen to €1.75 trillion from about €2 trillion in June, from pre-crisis levels of €1.2 trillion. As for the Federal Reserve, the size of its balance sheet is also being slowly whittled away, though much of the typical support, via repo transactions, is being replaced by more outright purchases of debt.

Central bank data watchers in Europe say the key inflection point is likely to be in June next year, when the ECB will decide whether or not to extend its one-year repo programme. In the meantime momentum is everything, and as more and more money pours into fixed income markets, investors fear that if they sell their bonds now, they may not be able to find anything to replace them. The rally might just continue.