CMBS: Building blocks

DDR and Fortress provide a glimmer of hope for commercial real estate.

Good news in the commercial real estate market has been hard to come by of late. But there was a glimmer of hope in the US market last month with the launch of a new CMBS transaction – the first in the US market for nearly 18 months. The CMBS market has been among the worst affected by the crisis, and the outlook for the commercial property sector in the country remains unremittingly grim. It is hardly surprising, therefore, that when the first post-crisis deal, a $400 million three-tranche transaction from US Reit Developers Diversified Realty (DDR) closed, protagonists dared to hope that it could be the start of a turnaround. And when, just days later, Fortress Group announced plans to issue a $460 million trade backed by commercial properties in Florida via Bank of America, there was a real sense that the tide might be turning.

One real estate specialist told Euromoney in August: “There has been a whiff of activity and everyone’s hopes are pinned on CMBS.” Arranged by Goldman Sachs, the five-year DDR deal consists of a $323.5 million triple-A tranche, a $41.5 million double-A tranche and a $35 million single-A tranche. The triple-A notes (which account for 80% of the deal) are Talf-eligible – the first new CMBS issuance to be so since the programme was introduced a year ago. Investor reaction was enthusiastic, with triple-A spreads narrowing to 140 basis points from initial talk closer to 200bp.

There is no doubt that these deals are very good news. But, unsurprisingly, they are backed by top-quality collateral issued by single borrowers. In addition, the DDR deal was not tranched below single-A. The market still faces a daunting challenge in trying to dismantle or run off billions of legacy CMBS trades and from the $570 billion commercial real estate loans that are due to be refinanced between 2010 and 2011. The situation in Europe is equally bleak: Fitch has downgraded nearly 60% (€47.2 billion) of European CMBS so far this year. The two new trades are a drop in the ocean compared with the refinancing problems that this market faces, but they are better than nothing at all.