Renumeration: The US pay-cuts fiasco

The US authorities’ approach to curbing bankers’ remuneration is ill-judged and inequitable.

Should bankers be paid less? President Barack Obama’s pay tsar, Kenneth Feinberg, can’t seem to make up his mind. After cutting total compensation at the seven largest recipients of US taxpayer money in October, he has now said he might reconsider that move if talent at the firms affected walks out the door. Well of course they will. There are only two banks on the list – Citi and Bank of America Merrill Lynch. Cutting the salaries there will, without any doubt, push staff into the hands of JPMorgan, Morgan Stanley and Goldman Sachs. As part of the pay assessment, Feinberg is cutting the total compensation for the top 25 executives at Citi and Bank of America Merrill Lynch, and is now reviewing the salaries of the other 75 top-paid executives at the two firms. Citi’s Vikram Pandit offered to take a $1 salary for 2009, while Ken Lewis of Bank of America has just been told by Feinberg that he won’t be receiving a salary at all this year. Compare that with JPMorgan’s Jamie Dimon, who has an annual base salary of $1 million. Goldman Sachs’s Lloyd Blankfein’s $600,000 and Morgan Stanley’s John Mack’s $800,000.

The playing field is completely uneven. Did the US government think that it might go unnoticed that only two banks are being targeted – one of which would not be on the list at all had it not been pressured by the authorities to acquire a collapsing rival bank? Just what are Obama and Feinberg trying to prove with these cuts if only two banks are being targeted?

Adding fuel to the fire, JPMorgan, Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley are estimated to be paying a combined $30 billion in bonuses this year. Dimon, Blankfein and Mack did not take bonuses last year. However, 2007 figures are indicative of what they can command in good times: Dimon got a $14.5 million bonus, and Blankfein almost $27 million, according to www.tracker.com.

Governments around the world are right to seethe. How can they enforce pay cuts at their domestic banks when the US is letting most of its own walk free? Lord Griffiths, vice-chairman of Goldman Sachs International, claims that “inequality is a way of achieving greater opportunity and prosperity for all”. Try telling that to Pandit and Lewis.