The Brazilian government is concerned about the real appreciating against the dollar but the tax measures it has taken so far offer little respite for the climbing currency.
On November 18 the Brazilian government announced plans to place a 1.5% tax on those issuing depositary receipts in international markets in a bid to prevent companies from selling shares abroad rather than locally. This new measure aims to balance out distortions caused by the 2% IOF tax on foreign investors when they buy stocks and fixed-income securities. This IOF tax was introduced on October 19 to curb a rally during which the real appreciated 43% against the dollar in the previous 12-month period.
It seems unlikely that either of these measures will curb real appreciation if macro conditions continue to improve. On November 23, the real strengthened 0.4% to R$1.725 to the dollar.
Commodity prices continue to tick upwards. With the Brazilian economy strongly tied to them, Brazilian assets stay attractive despite the new taxes.
Further real pressure is coming from investors that aren’t willing to sell. While Brazil stays relatively attractive and continues to benefit from a risk-positive environment investors already holding Brazilian assets are staying put. If they sell and then want to re-enter the market again with another company, they will have to pay the IOF tax.
With the government eager to keep its exporters competitive, new measures to curb real appreciation are likely despite a growing backlash from international investors.
It isn’t clear what new measures will come in. The government could allow foreign investors to buy Brazilian assets without exchanging currency. The central bank might allow domestic depositors to open dollar-denominated accounts with local banks. Reportedly, the central bank is looking into how ‘artificial impediments’ to outflows can be removed. There is a chance the IOF tax will be expanded to other transactions. The government is also expected to issue real-denominated bonds into the international markets shortly.
International investors will suggest the government helps exporters’ competitiveness, and curb real appreciation, by cutting tariffs on capital goods and paring back on bloated public spending.