Inside investment: Save or speculate?

David Ricardo’s counsel of despair on the fate of the working man should also give investors food for thought, writes Lincoln Rathnam.

Will the working man always eat stale bread?

A couple of weeks ago I was surfing around the cable TV stations having grown tired of whatever I was watching (I think it was the Xena: Warrior Princess marathon on SciFi) and I chanced upon the Suze Orman Show on CNBC. Suze is a self-styled investment lifestyle guru with a successful call-in show. She believes that trying to outperform markets is fruitless and investors should focus on their level of savings and keeping them safe.

Suze is famous for yelling out “Denied! Denied!” when a caller asks if it would be wise to buy a car or new house or commit themselves to the expense of having children. She believes that the average Jane and Joe Sixpack should save a lot and make sure they keep money safe rather than speculate in markets where they would probably lose. She offers the same counsel to the chardonnay-quaffing crowd, by the way.

On this particular occasion Suze was advising that US investors buy only municipal bonds and pointing out that she recommends this simple policy both at market peaks and troughs. She has been ridiculed for it but she feels justified. She simply does not believe that individual investors can make money over time in equities or other risky assets.

For most investors the experience during the mega bull market between 1982 and 2003, the greatest in US history, backs up this viewpoint. John Bogle, the founder of Vanguard and a leading advocate of index funds, has pointed out that even though the market returned close to 12% annualized over the 20-year period, the average active mutual fund investor made minus 4% compounded because of high total expenses and timing mistakes.

Retail investors too often increased their allocation to equities at the peak and fell prey to buying hot mutual funds that were about to turn cold. Longer-term studies confirm this, and in this light Orman’s municipals look rather attractive. Indeed, simply buying 90-day US bills from 2000 to 2008 yielded a total return of 75%. How many of us did as well?

What should the investor do?
Is it right to have a normal
family as Ricardo assumed
and save little, or save a lot
and reduce your family size below that needed by society?

Suze made me think of this and of a speech that the English economist David Ricardo (1772–1823) made in parliament in the early 1800s when debating the Corn Laws. These were tariffs on imported grains introduced in the UK after the Napoleonic Wars in order to ensure that domestic grain production remained high. Ricardo argued that the price of grain did not matter to the working man as he and his family would be eating stale bread regardless. Ricardo’s point was that employers would have to increase wages enough for the worker to buy stale bread for his family if the prices rose and, conversely, would lower wages as stale bread got cheaper. Ricardo has been considered by some, including Karl Marx, to be the greatest of the classical economists. He is more famous for his advocacy of free trade and the theory of comparative advantage. However, Marx was more interested in Ricardo’s theory of labour value upon which he based his Corn Law argument.

Ricardo, a successful investor, the Warren Buffett of his day, basically believed that the average fellow would never be able to get ahead. The question is – who is right? Is it Orman, who believes that the average family can accumulate wealth, or Ricardo, who believed that labour would not generate surplus returns?

What Ricardo did was to divide the revenues from any economic activity into returns on labour, capital and land. Land can be thought of as ownership of any resource, including patents, brand names and suchlike to which capital and labour can be applied. Labour and capital are fungible, so neither can earn excess returns, only economic rents. Ricardo concluded from this that the working man cannot get ahead, which is true in the context of properly competitive labour markets.

However, standards of living for workers can rise as society becomes more complex because the cost of worker replacement increases when training in machinery is required, as opposed to prodding the ground with a pointy stick, and the working family must replace itself. I have often thought about this over the years when observing that the typical US citizen, whatever his income, has nothing left at the end of the year, with some exceptions due to randomness.

Maybe both are right.

Take the case of Singapore. The typical Singapore household has a forced savings rate of 40% and it goes into fixed income. This is an Ormanian paradise. But maybe there is a Ricardian trade-off: children have been the expense that has been cut in Singapore, where we find a fertility rate of just over 1%. Singaporeans are not replacing themselves, just as Ricardo suggested.

So what should the investor do? Is it right to have a normal family as Ricardo assumed and save little, or save a lot and reduce your family size below that needed by society? Given recent history, I think we should do as Suze Orman says for a while. Your expenses are “Denied! Denied! Denied!”

Lincoln Rathnam, PhD, CFA, is an investment professional based in Singapore and Boston. In a career spanning almost 30 years he has managed equity, debt and venture capital portfolios and was a pioneer investor in emerging markets in the late 1980s