Rating agencies: An end to free speech?

Ratings agencies may not use the First Amendment to protect themselves but they still won’t be successfully sued over every structured credit opinion.

The fact that a US judge did not dismiss a case brought against two ratings agencies and a bank involved in the failed Cheyne SIV (which collapsed in October 2007) has raised the prospect of a wave of fraud allegations to come from the legion of disgruntled structured credit investors whose stakes in these deals have been wiped out over the past two years. The case was brought by two institutional investors, Abu Dhabi Commercial Bank and King County, which filed 32 claims of common-law fraud, negligent misrepresentation, negligence, breach of fiduciary duty, breach of contract, unjust enrichment and aiding and abetting against Moody’s and Standard & Poor’s together with Morgan Stanley and BoNY Mellon (the case against BoNY Mellon was thrown out in its entirety).

The judge ruled that the First Amendment (the right to free speech) could not provide a defence in this case because the ratings opinions were distributed privately to a select group of investors and not to the general public. But there are aspects of the ratings agencies’ and Morgan Stanley’s involvement in the deal that merit closer scrutiny.

The lawsuit claims that the role of the ratings agencies in the Cheyne SIV was more integral than is typically the case: they worked directly with Morgan Stanley to structure the notes in such a way that the required ratings were achievable and their compensation was contingent on receipt of the desired ratings. The agencies were paid fees of 10 or more basis points at the launch of the SIV ($6 million) and received annual remuneration of a flat fee of $1.2 million plus 0.055% of the market value of the collateral assets. The lawsuit contends that this amounts to payment in excess of three times their normal fees. The senior notes in the Cheyne SIV were rated triple-A and the capital notes received an investment-grade rating of A3/A from Moody’s and S&P respectively. These were the highest ratings ever given to capital notes in any SIV – even though the collateral quality in the Cheyne vehicle was not as high as that in earlier SIV deals.

Morgan Stanley received a fee that was 5bp of the market value of the assets held in the SIV and it also received a fee that was equal to a portion of its net distributable profits. The investors claim that because of Morgan Stanley’s awareness of and involvement in the default of New Century Mortgage Corp in March 2007 (it was the mortgage lender’s fourth-largest creditor) it would have received non-public information that would have directly contradicted the ratings in the Cheyne SIV – which had a large investment in New Century.

The agencies and Morgan Stanley now face a claim of common-law fraud. For it to succeed the investors need to prove that their involvement in (and compensation for) the structuring and continuing performance of the vehicle motivated them to knowingly mislead investors. This is by no means a foregone conclusion but the breaching of the First Amendment defence could encourage a slew of similar cases. Calpers sued all three ratings agencies for $1 billion in July this year over the ratings assigned in the SIV sector.