The pithiest answer to the question ‘Why is the market up?’ is often used to hide the fact that the person being asked does not really understand the price action at all. That there are more buyers than sellers is frequently all one needs to know. At the beginning of the year it was uncertain if the support to the financial system from cheap money, abundant central bank liquidity and fiscal easing would overcome the deflationary forces that started with credit losses in banks and accelerated with near-total collapse of the system last autumn. Sentiment turned, after a chilly January and February, on hopes that financial Armageddon had been averted.
In late July, credit and equity markets are more than firm. There are more buyers than sellers as indicated by the bellwether indicators. The S&P500 – up 44% since the March low – is fast approaching 1,000; some analysts are adding as much as another 100 points if it breaks through the big figure by the year-end. In the European credit market the big figure – this time 100 – has already been breached. The iTraxx Main’s fall to below 100 basis points signals just how well things are going – quite some way from the 200 handle quoted for the index in the early days of March. These are heady numbers.
And yet as the markets wind down for the traditional summer lull, the wary are casting their minds back to 12 months ago. Could it all go horribly wrong again this autumn? No doubt a serious shock to the financial system from situations such as California’s budget difficulties or US commercial real estate could burst the optimists’ bubble. But at present nothing appears likely to hold the financial markets back. Bond, equity and hedge funds continue to attract huge inflows. The bond flows have supported the feverish rate at which corporate treasurers have issued paper in the first seven months of the year, and look set to sustain credit markets in the final five. Equity markets have welcomed corporations accessing debt capital – not quite a self-perpetuating dynamic but close to it.
Further good news for credit bulls comes from the likelihood that most corporates that needed to issue have now done so. If non-financial supply is set to slow it should obviously support credit spreads. Even if M&A-linked bond financing does pick up, as some bankers are forecasting, it is unlikely to put pressure on the market. The technicals are too strong. Investment-grade credit is still in relatively short supply.
There is a danger of the market getting carried away. It is not hard to find a strategist predicting that credit will continue to rally. Should the iTraxx hit 75bp, as some are forecasting, sellers of protection at this level are vulnerable to the level of corporate defaults. They are betting on a V-shaped economic recovery to be compensated for the insurance they are writing. As stock prices continue to rise, despite second-quarter earnings growth for the S&P500 coming in at –32% and credit spreads fall below a level at which investors are compensated for the risk, do not ask the question why the market is still rising. More buyers than sellers? No: more fools than there are wise.