At a time when the advanced economies are seemingly teetering between inflation and deflation, it is worth recalling Sir Isaiah Berlin’s essay, “The hedgehog and the fox”. It begins with a quote from the Greek poet Archilochus: “The fox knows many things; the hedgehog knows one big thing.” Berlin believed that we are all either foxes or hedgehogs. We are impressed and distracted by the subtlety and cleverness in many foxy things, but today we need the single-minded certainty of the hedgehog and his deep knowledge of the one important thing.
I have some experience with porcupines, hedgehogs’ even pricklier American cousins. In the small farming town of Middlefield in the Berkshire Hills of Massachusetts where I grew up, nature was encroaching. The population had peaked in the early 1800s at more than 2,000 but was down to 300 by the time I was born. By then, the town was mostly forested as the woods encroached on abandoned farmland.
We always had dogs. At one time there were three: Peter, a boxer; Prince, a pointer; and Boy, a biggish brown mongrel who arrived one day and stayed. From time to time they would disappear for a day or two to hunt in the woods, only to come crawling back with their snouts and mouths full of porcupine quills. When this happened, my brother and I would coat the wounds with motor oil and pull the quills out with pliers. This operation involved the tearing of flesh, which the dogs bore with surprising stoicism. They never learnt, at least not for long, but the hedgehogs always knew what to do with dogs, and foxes.
|
If we were going to have any serious deflation, it would probably already have happened |
In the good old days of the gold standard, prices rose during periods of expansion and fell during recessions, so remaining unchanged over the long term. But the foxes of the world, and I would include among them president Barack Obama and prime minister Gordon Brown, rather like inflation because they believe they can use it to achieve their policy goals while reducing the value of their fixed obligations. They think they are clever enough to tweak the system and keep the good times rolling. By contrast, hedgehogs, such as Germany’s Angela Merkel and Singapore’s Lee Hsien Loong, take a longer view. They know only one big thing: stability is good, even at the risk of deflation. In fact, neither inflation nor deflation is pleasant. As Woody Allen put it in a famous speech to graduates: “More than at any other time in history, mankind faces a crossroads. One path leads to despair and utter hopelessness, the other, to total extinction. Let us pray we have the wisdom to choose correctly.”
The worlds of inflation and deflation are as different as night and day. Inflation depresses the value of fixed-income instruments and equities generally, as we saw in the 1970s, when we thought a reasonable price for a stock was around book value with a yield of 6%. Only those equities that were linked to commodity prices and real assets did well. Inflation also depresses the value of the affected currencies. When I came to Singapore in 2006, one US dollar bought 1.70 Singapore dollars; now it buys only 1.45. (The Great Depreciation has been going on for years.) Deflation, on the other hand, depresses the value of everything except high-quality cash and fixed-income instruments.
In the future, we will know which way we tipped during this contraction. In retrospect there is little doubt that deflation occurred during the Great Depression, although there is still some debate about the causes. In the present, however, things are not so clear. We make our investment policy, to paraphrase Clausewitz, in the fog of investing.
The fog, however, is gradually lifting and this time it seems as if the foxes have had their way. The IMF’s July World economic update has raised its forecasts of growth and inflation for the advanced economies for 2009 and 2010 from a slight decrease in consumer prices in 2009 to a slight increase. Currently, we don’t see actual deflation anywhere, save perhaps in Japan, where they make a habit of it. Although we had a little deflation in previous months, June US core inflation at 2.1% was just above the Federal Reserve’s target. UK inflation was 1.8%, just a shade below the Bank of England’s target. If we were going to have any serious deflation, it would probably already have happened.
So the foxes have won the argument for now. Eventually, though, they will be found to have been too clever by half. They will return to monetary orthodoxy but not before their mouths are full of porcupine quills and their tails are between their legs.
Extracting the quills will be painful for all of us.
Lincoln Rathnam, PhD, CFA, is an investment professional based in Singapore and Boston. In a career spanning almost 30 years he has managed equity, debt and venture capital portfolios and was a pioneer investor in emerging markets in the late 1980s