It’s always a concern when bankers aren’t talking up their books. After all, in the midst of the mortgage blow-up, ABS bankers were still claiming that the securitization market was alive and kicking. But a tour of Wall Street executives this month (see After the crunch, THE BIG APPLE BITES BACK) revealed extremely muted enthusiasm about the amount of deals in equities and debt that have flooded the market this year. Conversely worrying was the lack of pessimism about the surprising amount of capital raises. Bankers without strong opinions are rare. So are they just exhausted? Or are they leaving us to read between the lines?
Positive earnings, increased deal flows, and equity market upticks might on the surface point to a recovery but beneath the façade there is a definite sense that banks are flying by the seat of their pants. Investment banking revenues are being driven predominantly by sales and trading in fixed income. And that trading is being driven primarily by the Federal Reserve’s programme of guaranteeing and buying mortgages.
To boot, the US economy is offering no positive signs to encourage treasurers that they should be raising capital for growth plans, and for the most part they’ve now repaired their balance sheets with the cheap financing that has been available. Why tap the markets more?
If bankers think this year is a signal that 2010 will be good, they might be deluding themselves. Investors seem dubious. The State Street Investor Confidence Index fell 12.8 points in October in North America. They have reason to be pessimistic. Jobless claims rose in October in the US, and the latest data show home prices to have fallen and new house sales to have dropped in September.
Although equity markets tend to move upwards six months in advance of a recovery, it still feels too soon. Six months puts us in the first quarter of 2010. Will the US have returned to sustained growth by then?
The Fed is going to have to stop buying mortgages at some point. When that happens, trading revenues will come down, probably at the same time as the demand for capital and, therefore, investment banking deals, eases up. The Fed might try to put off the reversal of its spending as far into 2010 as it can but it is simply delaying the inevitable. This would explain bankers’ nonchalant attitudes for sure. If they know this is purely a strange land in the middle of two crashes why feign enthusiasm? But also what’s the point of being negative when the good times could roll for another few quarters? But then again, maybe they really are just exhausted.