Oh the irony of markets moving on a ratings action from Standard & Poor’s on the UK. Surely a lesson to be learnt from the credit crunch is that relying on ratings agencies for investment decisions is not the wisest course. Sterling fell, gilt yields rose and the sovereign CDS widened all as a result of S&P placing the UK’s triple A rating on negative.
This decision came on the back of no fresh information. The UK budget was presented in March, at which time it was clear that the deficit would grow rapidly in the coming years. Both Moody’s and Fitch have since affirmed the AAA rating, citing factors that put them at odds with S&P.
The puzzle of what took the agency so long to make this decision is compounded by its then saying it would not change the rating prior to the next UK general election (no later than June 2010). S&P’s assumptions and forecasts on the state of the UK’s finances are far more pessimistic than the consensus. Only the most apocalyptic strategist thinks that UK debt to GDP is going to hit 100% by 2013 – which is S&P’s fear. S&P assumes the measures taken to support the banks could cost the UK between £100 billion and £145 billion – much higher than most analysts predict.
But there are more important issues at play here. The first surrounds the lack of clear thinking about what deteriorating public finances mean for a country that prints its own currency. Furthermore, there are many (double-A rated) countries with debt to GDP ratios well in excess of 100% and still paying debts on time. That the UK is about to become one of them is still far from certain – but the statistical chances of default within a 10-year period from a sovereign with a double-A rating are zero.
One must therefore wonder what the difference between a double-A and triple-A rating is, and why any investor should notice it. It’s just one of the reasons why a UK House of Lords committee recommended in June that agency ratings be removed from capital regulations. The timing may make the announcement appear vitriolic, but the Lords are unlikely to be the last committee to reach such a conclusion.
In the meantime, investors ought to remember that an efficient market would ignore such sabre rattling – all the information was already in the public domain.