Among financial institutions: Which ICMs do you use most?

Full results Methodology Euromoney polled cash managers, treasurers and financial officers worldwide. We received in total 6,238 valid replies to questions relating to international cash management services (2007: 3,801 replies) from 109 countries (2007:89 countries). Respondents were asked to indicate: — Which three banks they currently used most for their cash management services— Their rating […]

Full results
Methodology

Euromoney polled cash managers, treasurers and financial officers worldwide. We received in total 6,238 valid replies to questions relating to international cash management services (2007: 3,801 replies) from 109 countries (2007:89 countries). Respondents were asked to indicate:

— Which three banks they currently used most for their cash management services
— Their rating of services provided by their lead cash manager on a sliding scale of 1=excellent; 2=very good; 3=good; 4=fair; 5=poor. Banks’ scores in each category are the percentage of ratings they received for that category that were very good or excellent.

In the lead categories, each voter’s top bank was awarded four points, second place three points, and third place two points. Each voter’s score was then weighted depending on the annual gross sales of the part of the business for which the voter was responsible, as follows:

1. Greater than $100 billion – a factor of 10 was applied
2. $25 billion to $99.99 billion – a factor of 9 was applied
3. $10 billion to $24.99 billion – a factor of 8 was applied
4. $5 billion to $9.99 billion – a factor of 7 was applied
5. $2.5 billion to $4.99 billion – a factor of 6 was applied
6. $1 billion to $2.49 billion – a factor of 5 was applied
7. $500 million to $999.9million – a factor of 4 was applied
8. $ 100 million to $ 499.9 million – a factor of 3 was applied
9. $ 50 million to $ 99.9 million – a factor of 2 was applied
10. Less than $50 million – a factor of unity was applied
Treasurers’ votes were aggregated to include subsidiaries and regions where appropriate.

Geographical breakdown of annual gross sales of respondent companies (figures for 2007 in brackets):
Asia 63.24% (59.74%), Europe 16.63% (24.91%), Middle East & Africa 13.02% (5.41%), North America 4.74% (9.45%), Latin America 2.37% (0.49%)

Geographical breakdown of all votes received (figures for 2007 in brackets):
Asia 67.29% (70.10%), Middle East & Africa 15.14% (13.90%), Europe 11.95% (11.17%), North America 3.15% (2.91%), Latin America 2.47% (1.91%).

Please direct all comments and questions to Tim Moxon, head of research, at tmoxon@euromoneyplc.com

Among non-financial institutions, Which ICMs do you use most?
Among non-financial institutions, The Best domestic Cash Managers
Among non-financial institutions, How do customers rate their lead Global ICM’s services?
Among financial institutions, Which ICMs do you use most?
Europe
Euro transactions
2008 2007 Bank Score
1 2 Deutsche Bank 2375
2 1 Citi 1597
3 3 HSBC 826
4 5 Commerzbank 682
5 4 ABN Amro 421
6 13 Dresdner Bank 396
7 7 JPMorgan 334
8 11 BNP Paribas 225
9 UniCredit 221
10 14 RBS 210
Dollar transactions
2008 2007 Bank Score
1 1 Citi 2100
2 5 Deutsche Bank 1078
3 2 HSBC 917
4 3 JPMorgan 825
5 7 Bank of New York 390
6 6 Wachovia Bank 340
7 10 Standard Chartered 233
8 16 Commerzbank 163
9 13 Bank of America 160
10 4 ABN Amro 146
Yen transactions
2008 2007 Bank Score
1 1 Citi 775
2 4 Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFJ 674
3 3 Sumitomo Mitsui Banking Corp 406
4 2 HSBC 354
5 6 Deutsche Bank 233
6 8 JPMorgan 158
7 12 Wachovia Bank 155
8 7 Standard Chartered 139
9 Bank of America 100
10 14= UBS 59
North America
Euro transactions
2008 2007 Bank Score
1 3 Deutsche Bank 902
2 1 Citi 895
3 2 HSBC 394
4 10 Commerzbank 308
5 4 JPMorgan 253
6 14 Dresdner Bank 189
7 9 Bank of America 117
8= 11 Bank of New York 108
8= 5 ABN Amro 108
10 8 Standard Chartered 70
Dollar transactions
2008 2007 Bank Score
1 1 Citi 1737
2 3 JPMorgan 1180
3 7 Deutsche Bank 671
4 2 HSBC 663
5 5 Bank of New York 511
6 4 Wachovia Bank 433
7 6 Bank of America 430
8 10 Standard Chartered 185
9 9 Barclays 87
10 8 ABN Amro 84
Yen transactions
2008 2007 Bank Score
1 1 Citi 488
2 4 Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFJ 349
3 2 Sumitomo Mitsui Banking Corp 305
4 3 HSBC 210
5 6 Wachovia Bank 135
6 8 Deutsche Bank 125
7 7 JPMorgan 94
8 10 Bank of New York 91
9 9 Standard Chartered 89
10 Bank of America 56
Asia
Euro transactions
2008 2007 Bank Score
1 1 Citi 2887
2 2 HSBC 2467
3 3 Deutsche Bank 1560
4 Bank of Communications 772
5 4 Standard Chartered 446
6 11 Commerzbank 390
7 6 JPMorgan 386
8 5 ABN Amro 362
9 19 Dresdner Bank 242
10 14 BNP Paribas 163
Dollar transactions
2008 2007 Bank Score
1 1 Citi 4560
2 2 HSBC 3225
3 4 Deutsche Bank 1162
4 Bank of Communications 974
5 5 JPMorgan 687
6 3 Standard Chartered 654
7 7 Wachovia Bank 623
8 6 Bank of New York 367
9 8 ABN Amro 316
10 9 Bank of America 282
Yen transactions
2008 2007 Bank Score
1 1 Citi 2245
2 2 HSBC 1585
3 3 Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFJ 947
4 4 Sumitomo Mitsui Banking Corp 775
5 6 Deutsche Bank 389
6 5 Standard Chartered 305
7 7 JPMorgan 236
8 8 Wachovia Bank 208
9 Bank of Communications 144
10 11 ABN Amro 122
Latin America
Euro transactions
2008 2007 Bank Score
1 1 Citi 412
2 4 Deutsche Bank 211
3 2 HSBC 177
4 11= JPMorgan 110
5 Commerzbank 72
Dollar transactions
2008 2007 Bank Score
1 1 Citi 682
2 3 JPMorgan 291
3 5 Deutsche Bank 182
4 2 HSBC 180
5 6 Bank of New York 115
Yen transactions
2008 2007 Bank Score
1 2 Citi 254
2 4 Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFJ 133
3 10 Sumitomo Mitsui Banking Corp 124
4 1 HSBC 60
5 JPMorgan 58
Middle East
Euro transactions
2008 2007 Bank Score
1 2 Citi 862
2 1 HSBC 841
3 4 Deutsche Bank 499
4 6 Commerzbank 264
5 3 ABN Amro 165
6 5 Standard Chartered 145
7 7 BNP Paribas 103
8 8 Dresdner Bank 101
9 11 Calyon 50
10= 9= Barclays 40
10= Intesa San Paolo 40
Dollar transactions
2008 2007 Bank Score
1 2 Citi 1547
2 1 HSBC 869
3 6 JPMorgan 329
4 10= Deutsche Bank 304
5 5 Standard Chartered 212
6 3 Bank of New York 204
7 7 Wachovia Bank 83
8 13 Bank of America 77
9 4 ABN Amro 57
10 10= BNP Paribas 53
Yen transactions
2008 2007 Bank Score
1 2 Citi 512
2 1 HSBC 287
3 4 Sumitomo Mitsui Banking Corp 201
4 5 Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFJ 200
5 3 Standard Chartered 159
6= 6 ABN Amro 38
6= 12= JPMorgan 38
8 UBAF 28
9 7= Deutsche Bank 26
10 7= Wachovia Bank 23
Africa
Euro transactions
2008 2007 Bank Score
1 1 Citi 438
2 7 Deutsche Bank 203
3 2 HSBC 76
4 9= Commerzbank 70
5 12 BNP Paribas 68
Dollar transactions
2008 2007 Bank Score
1 1 Citi 682
2 Deutsche Bank 156
3 2 HSBC 139
4 6= JPMorgan 104
5 3 Bank of New York 101
Yen transactions
2008 2007 Bank Score
1 2 Citi 250
2 8= Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFJ 56
3= 7 Sumitomo Mitsui Banking Corp 32
3= 1 HSBC 32
5 4= Standard Chartered 30