In these febrile times, it doesn’t take much for a bank’s reputation to be questioned. So it has proved for ICICI, India’s biggest private bank.
Heralded not so long ago as a regional champion, its share price fell to a two-year low on September 29, before recovering the following day, amid rumours of poor liquidity, a weak capital base and a vulnerable investment portfolio. With speculation mounting over the bank’s health, some depositors started to withdraw money. ICICI’s chief executive was forced into a public statement dismissing rumours about its financial strength as “baseless and malicious”. Just for good measure, India’s central bank and finance minister weighed in too, defending the bank’s position.
Loss of confidence in ICICI appears to stem from a research report by Morgan Stanley, released on September 2, in which the US firm identified it as Asia’s most leveraged bank and, so, most vulnerable to a downturn. The second bank on the list was Bank of East Asia, the Hong Kong lender that suffered a run last month after announcing trading losses for the first half of the year.
Morgan Stanley’s criticisms of ICICI highlighted several all-too-familiar issues. The two most important claims it makes: that the bank ramped up its loan book too aggressively but with little capital discipline – its growth in earnings per share trailed its growth in risk-weighted assets – and this in a country lacking a properly functioning credit bureau; and that ICICI’s profits over the past three years were over-reliant on the capital markets – indeed, according to Morgan Stanley, it was more reliant on trading-related gains than any other bank in Asia. As if on cue, ICICI suffered treasury losses of Rs5.94 billion ($125 million) in the three months up to June 30, its most recent results.
The collapse of Lehman Brothers hit it hard. The Indian lender had an $82 million exposure to the US investment bank’s holding company’s debt through its UK business. It might have to set aside an additional $28 million for potential losses on the exposure.
Adding to the bank’s vulnerability is the fact that 70% of its stock is held by foreign institutional investors, which are more likely to sell than domestic funds. ICICI’s share price has fallen by nearly 60% over the past eight months, although at least the interventions by the chief executive and India’s leading public officials helped to turn the stock’s fortunes around. On September 30, it was Asia’s best-performing financial stock, suggesting that investors are now not sure which way to jump.
The bank’s fundamentals are still relatively strong. In the first quarter of the 2009 financial year, ending June 30, it stated that it had consolidated total assets of more than $105 billion and a net worth of $10 billion. It made a profit after tax of more than $155 million and claims to have enough cash to meet depositor demand. Its capital adequacy ratio is 13.4% and the bank has a tier 1 ratio of more than 11%.
Against that, some key financial indicators are clearly worsening and not just its heavy treasury losses, which included mark-to-market and realized losses. Profits after tax were down 6% year on year. On the assets side, the NPL ratio increased to 1.74%, compared with 1.33% one year earlier. As for the bank’s liabilities, financing its total borrowings, up 33.5% year on year to Rs938.23 billion ($19.8 billion), will also become tougher given market conditions.
With ICICI’s earnings momentum likely to continue to slow, it’s not just US and European financial institutions that are coming to terms with the fact that their golden years are over.