Brazilian government stuck with appreciation dilemma

Measures to boost the competitiveness of Brazil’s exporters might well be fruitless.

The Brazilian government is in a dilemma. In a last-ditch attempt to stop the appreciation of the Brazilian real undermining the competitiveness of its exporters, the government has imposed a new tax on foreigners buying local debt.

Brazil’s exporters are happy that the government has finally acted. But analysts are concerned that the authorities might suffer a rising risk premium from deterring foreign investors, without achieving the desired benefit of halting the real’s appreciation.

In mid-2007, the Brazilian real was trading at two to the dollar, and by the end of the year it had reached a new level of 1.77. The real closed 2007 17.15% higher against the dollar than 12 months earlier. At the end of February the real dipped below 1.70 to the dollar.

The government enacted the measures on March 17. Now exporters are allowed to keep all their foreign currency revenues from foreign sales, as opposed to having to repatriate 70%. Exporters are also now exempt from the 0.38% financial transactions tax. However, the most controversial new measure is a new, one-time up-front 1.5% tax on the initial FX transaction for all foreign investments in Brazilian fixed-income accounts.

Investors and analysts are split on whether this final measure is a good move. Some argue that the tax is a step backwards for the Brazilian market, fearing that investors will be uncomfortable about these sudden changes in the law, and so impose a new Brazil risk premium.

Other investors might be more sanguine. If they want to invest in one of the largest emerging markets, they might be willing to swallow the new, relatively small tax and carry on investing.

Soon after the government’s announcement, the real fell by 0.8% versus the dollar. But the positive fundamentals that have been driving the Brazilian currency for the past year are still present and this fall might be temporary.

The high interest rate differential, due to a Selic rate (benchmark lending rate) of 11.25%, is not likely to change soon. In mid-March, at the last central bank meeting, the board voted to hold rates for the fourth meeting in a row. Growing inflationary pressures prompt some analysts to predict rate increases in the second quarter of 2008.

The real is also buoyed up by ever growing FDI flows. In January 2008 alone there was $4.8 billion of investment recorded, according to a Dresdner Kleinwort research report. Estimates place FDI at 19% of GDP by the end of 2008, up from 17.5% at the end of 2007.

The final obstacle to the Brazilian authorities’ hopes is the weak US dollar. Despite the Brazilian government’s best efforts, with the US Federal Reserve dropping rates by another 75 basis points in the third week of March, the struggle against real appreciation is certainly not over.