UBS can manage Esteves blow

The departure of Andre Esteves from UBS need not be a big setback for the Swiss bank’s fortunes in Brazil.

The news that Andre Esteves has left UBS, where he was chief executive of Latin America, to set up his own investment fund did not come as a shock. Esteves is an entrepreneur who had become a billionaire before his 40th birthday. He and a handful of others built a successful boutique, Banco Pactual, which they then sold for a fortune to the Swiss bank. And although at one point he was even seen as a potential head of UBS, he is leaving after only 18 months.

The only surprise to his departure was the timing. Just one month earlier, in May, UBS announced that Esteves had relinquished his other role as global head of fixed income, currencies and commodities to concentrate on the bank’s Latin business, specifically Brazil, full time.

It seems strange that Esteves did not resign from the bank then. Resolving complicated contractual negotiations is the most probable reason, although there has been no official explanation from either party. What is clear is that Esteves still has big ambitions. It is thought that late last year and earlier this, he raised the possibility of buying a significant stake in the Swiss bank or even buying it out. Now he is turning his attention to building another Brazil business. Esteves is not leaving alone – 12 other bankers are joining him, with that total eventually expected to rise to about 30.

What does all this mean for UBS and its Brazil business? Ironically, it could be a boon. For months, rumours have circulated that Esteves and other Pactual partners, regretting the sale of the firm to the sub-prime stricken UBS, wanted to buy it back. Esteves’ departure puts paid to those mutterings and should allow the Swiss financial institution some breathing space.

In addition, the fact that Esteves’ new company cannot compete directly with UBS Pactual until 2011 because of contractual clauses means that it won’t have to worry about losing lucrative clients for a few years. Esteves is instead focusing his efforts on building a firm that will engage in private equity and hedge fund-related activity, although in the long term he has investment banking ambitions. In three years’ time relations between the two sides might not remain as amicable.

UBS will miss Esteves’ talent and to lose a clutch of senior bankers is a blow. Pactual could also become vulnerable to further raids from other investment banks seeking to build in Brazil. Even before the Esteves announcement, UBS had suffered at the hands of Merrill Lynch, which poached seven bankers, including the co-head of investment banking.

Still, there remain plenty of talented people at UBS Pactual, including Esteves’ replacement in Brazil, Rodrigo Xavier. He too is a former Pactual partner, having joined the firm in 1993. His challenge is to generate the success that UBS Pactual achieved in 2007, when it made a record profit of R$2.6 billion ($1.6 billion). That, of course, will depend on equity capital markets activity. UBS has had a poor first half of the year, even given the slowdown in issuance volumes. Last month, however, it was one of the co-leads on energy company OGX’s $3.6 billion IPO.

What could put the cat among the pigeons regarding Pactual is UBS’s overall health if further credit write-downs have to be made. UBS management has constantly stated that it is committed to Pactual but if it suddenly needed to raise capital, it might be forced into selling the business. For the time being, the Swiss bank is relatively well capitalized after a series of investments from strategic buyers. The credit crunch has shown, however, that circumstances can change very quickly.