Paraguay’s future hangs in the balance

Freeing up markets would help the country lose its tag as the poor man of Latin America.

Fernando Lugo won Paraguay’s presidential election with 43% of the vote and in August he will be sworn in to lead the second-poorest nation in South America (annual per capita GDP of $4,000). Paraguay is yet to embrace the capital markets and is ranked as one of the most corrupt nations in Latin America, despite becoming a democracy more than 20 years ago.

Paraguay has been ranked as the fifth-worst place to do business in Latin America, and has one of the lowest rates of foreign direct investment in the region. Paraguay is also ranked as the second-worst country in the region for access to capital for entrepreneurs, according to the capital access index – only Haiti ranks worse.

If Lugo is finally going to lift the majority of the population out of poverty, as he claims he will do, then it is time to turn these statistics around.

One way for Lugo to start could be to free up the markets. In each of the past three years, remittances, which mostly come from the US, were about $300 million a year and were nearly double the country’s FDI flows. This statistic highlights Paraguay’s vulnerability to external shocks, especially in the light of the coming US recession.

In addition, 40% of Paraguay’s GDP comes from agriculture, making the nation highly vulnerable to weather patterns. It is time that Paraguay took steps to diversify its economy, and this will need external investment.

External debt has stayed at roughly $2.2 billion since 2005; as of March 31 this year Paraguay owed $2.23 billion. Compared with some of its neighbours, this is relatively low in absolute terms. However, it constitutes 25.5% of Paraguay’s GDP. Previous talks with the IMF to find a way to manage this debt burden collapsed when president Nicanor Duarte refused to privatize a telephone company.

A change in these privatization plans could be a relatively pain-free way to reduce external debts but, as of September 2007, Paraguay had accumulated $2.64 billion in international reserves – an achievement that reduced the presidents’ desire to follow a privatization programme.

In addition, Moody’s upgraded Paraguay to B3 this month to reflect the growing fiscal surplus and higher commodity export prices. This upgrade is another step towards bringing Paraguay onto the international stage, but now the president-elect needs to prove that this upgrade is deserved. According to Cesar Barreto Otazu, the country’s finance minister, Paraguay is planning to return to the international debt markets.

Lugo’s right-hand man, Federico Franco, is a free-market liberal and keen critic of Bolivia’s leftist president, Evo Morales. Lugo has also criticized Hugo Chávez for polarizing Venezuelan society and is a campaigner for Cuba to open its politics.

With these sparks of hope, many are optimistic that Lugo will take his inspiration from more centrist governments in the region and not from the likes of Venezuela and Bolivia, opening a new chapter in Paraguay’s history books.