Credit crunch and Dick Fuld: Forget scapegoats

The witch-hunt of Dick Fuld is wrong. But that doesn’t mean it won’t continue.

It is hard to know what to feel about the public stringing-up of Dick Fuld. Watching his grilling by Henry Waxman and his grandstanding Congressional committee felt like sitting in a seat in the Coliseum watching the latest meeting of the Christians and the lions. While not sympathizing with someone who has clearly done wrong, publicly humiliating the man and blaming him for the state of the world doesn’t quite sit right either.

Fuld was a hard-nosed man who dragged himself up the Wall Street ranks by taking risks. Those risks turned Lehman Brothers from a loss-making firm in 1993 to one that made a profit of $4.2 billion. He made himself a very rich man in the process, but he made a lot of other people very rich as well.

As one former employee of Fuld confided, would it not have been great if Fuld had just said to Congress: “I was worth the money. I made some of you very rich. I made shareholders rich. And, by the way, don’t talk to me about financial affairs. I know more than all of you put together” ?

Fuld created an empire and then watched as his empire collapsed. He was loyal to colleagues and loyal to his firm. One has to empathise with Fuld when he says he will wonder until the day they put him in the ground why the Fed chose his firm as the only firm not to be bailed out.

Using Fuld as a punch bag will not solve anything, although it has succeeded in highlighting just how little regulators and Congress understand Wall Street.

Of course the witch-hunt will not stop here. And Fuld’s woes may only get worse. It seems likely that politicians, and maybe the people, will want a scapegoat for the crisis. Lawyers are warning that a spate of what the US calls “perp walks” – the law enforcement practice of having the accused appear in public in handcuffs – is inevitable. Fuld is in the firing line. But he is no Ken Lay of Enron infamy. Mismanagement is not yet a criminal offence.

Perhaps the reason Fuld has been selected as the villain of Wall Street, however, is that he knew more than most. Former employees of Fuld claim he knew exactly the risks his firm was taking on, but liked to sail close to the wind. If anyone knew when to say “enough” to mortgage deals it was he.

Having a witch-hunt on Wall Street, however, is ultimately worthless and a waste of taxpayers’ money. Better to spend that money paying for people to head up regulatory bodies who understand markets, and who have the balls to step in before a crisis and not after.