Agency brokers offer new hope for bond market liquidity
The breach in liquidity is giving the agency brokers a once in a lifetime opportunity to develop meaningful business. They have the potential to be the conduit to dark pools of liquidity because they have no conflicts of interest and can offer investors trading anonymity. Agency brokers are able to go to both the buy and sell sides to find liquidity.
An ex-salesman tells Euromoney: “Dealers have no stick to beat investors with. They offer little or no liquidity, their research is somewhat discredited, they have or are about to sack the sales force, and new-issue dynamics have changed.”
What is liquidity? It’s a question that is being increasingly asked in the fixed income sector. The factors that are essential to the trading of bonds in secondary markets do not exist. Being able to get in and out of a position without dramatically moving the market or suffering a significant loss is all but impossible for investors right now – and the market has laboured under this state of affairs for well over a year.
Arguably, there needs to be at least a semblance of liquidity in fixed-income secondary markets for there to be a fully functioning debt capital market. The lack of liquidity has cast a pall over the whole sector, damaging investors’ confidence in taking a view and getting involved – despite the excellent opportunities that are reputedly available in the secondary credit market, where strong names pay wide spreads.
If you listen to investors, liquidity is now the pre-eminent unresolved issue facing the fixed-income markets. Financial institutions’ capital and solvency problems have been dealt with – either through bankruptcy, conservatorship, private and public market injections of equity, or direct governmental injections of capital. And governments’ actions to alleviate bank funding issues appear to have worked. But the market’s illiquidity is much harder to deal with. It is a thorny issue because for securities traded over the counter, which is most forms of debt, the functioning of the markets has hitherto required substantial capital and risk appetite among the investment banks. Unfortunately, both are in short supply.
Liquidity matters because without it secondary trading markets are less efficient. The cost of capital for firms is higher if bid-offer spreads are wider because of a liquidity premium for cash bonds. But the state cannot be expected to intervene to recreate the conditions that many investors used to take for granted.
“Right at this moment it seems that they don’t think giving liquidity to fund managers is the best use of that capital,” says Threadneedle Street’s Frewen. “That’s fine. That is their business decision. However, we need to find liquidity,” This is why the agency brokers believe they are part of the solution.