Best-managed LATAM companies 2007: A Latin leap forward
| MOST CONVINCING AND COHERENT STRATEGY | ||||
| No. of companies cited: 75 | ||||
| 2007 | Firm | Score | Country | Sector |
| 1 | América Móvil | 7.30% |
Mexico |
T |
| 2 | Cemex |
6.69% |
Mexico |
C |
| 3 | Companhia Vale do Rio Doce |
4.46% |
Brazil |
M |
| 4 | Telmex |
3.85% |
Mexico |
T |
| 5 | Petrobras |
3.45% |
Brazil |
O |
| 6 | Banco Itaú |
3.25% |
Brazil |
B |
| 7 | LAN Airlines |
2.84% |
Chile |
A |
| 8= | Femsa |
2.64% |
Mexico |
F |
| 8= | Southern Copper |
2.64% |
Peru |
M |
| 10= | Cencosud |
2.43% |
Chile |
R |
| 10= | Credicorp |
2.43% |
Peru |
B |
| 10= | Empresas Copec |
2.43% |
Chile |
O |
| Most improved | ||||
| No. of companies cited: 81 | ||||
2007 |
Firm |
Score |
Country |
Sector |
| 1 | América Móvil |
6.41% |
Mexico |
T |
| 2 | La Polar |
4.51% |
Chile |
R |
| 3 | Petrobras |
4.28% |
Brazil |
O |
| 4= | Companhia Vale do Rio Doce |
3.80% |
Brazil |
M |
| 4= | Wal-Mart de México |
3.80% |
Mexico |
R |
| Most transparent accounts | ||||
| No. of companies cited: 68 | ||||
2007 |
Firm |
Score |
Country |
Sector |
| 1 | Companhia Vale do Rio Doce |
4.92% |
Brazil |
M |
| 2 | Aracruz Celulose |
4.10% |
Brazil |
P |
| 3 | Cemex |
3.83% |
Mexico |
C |
| 4= | Banco Itaú |
3.28% |
Brazil |
B |
| 4= | Petrobras |
3.28% |
Brazil |
O |
| 4= | Wal-Mart de México |
3.28% |
Mexico |
R |
| Most accessible senior management | ||||
| No. of companies cited: 76 | ||||
2007 |
Firm |
Score |
Country |
Sector |
| 1 | Cemex |
5.87% |
Mexico |
C |
| 2 | Companhia Vale do Rio Doce |
4.08% |
Brazil |
M |
| 3 | Enersis |
3.57% |
Chile |
U |
| 4 | Telmex |
3.32% |
Mexico |
T |
| 5= | Consorcio ARA |
2.81% |
Mexico |
C/Re |
| 5= | Credicorp |
2.81% |
Peru |
B |
| Most useful and informative website | ||||
| No. of companies cited: 63 | ||||
2007 |
Firm |
Score |
Country |
Sector |
| 1 | Cemex |
8.82% |
Mexico |
C |
| 2 | Corporación GEO |
5.79% |
Mexico |
C/Re |
| 3 | Companhia Vale do Rio Doce |
5.23% |
Brazil |
M |
| 4 | Femsa |
4.68% |
Mexico |
F |
| 5 | Banco Itaú |
3.58% |
Brazil |
B |
| Best newly listed | ||||
| No. of companies cited: 30 | ||||
2007 |
Firm |
Score |
Country |
Sector |
| 1 | GAP – Grupo Aeroportuario del Pacífico |
12.15% |
Mexico |
A |
| 2 | Cencosud |
8.29% |
Chile |
R |
| 3 | Natura Cosmeticos |
6.63% |
Brazil |
Cg |
| 4= | GOL Linhas Aéreas Inteligentes |
5.52% |
Brazil |
A |
| 4= | OMA – Grupo Aeroportuario del Centro Norte |
5.52% |
Mexico |
Ts |
| Best small company | ||||
| No. of companies cited: 28 | ||||
2007 |
Firm |
Score |
Country |
Sector |
| 1 | La Polar |
12.70% |
Chile |
R |
| 2 | SalfaCorp |
6.35% |
Chile |
C |
| 3 | Sare Holding |
5.56% |
Mexico |
Re |
| 4= | Axtel |
4.76% |
Mexico |
T |
| 4= | Corporativo Fragua |
4.76% |
Mexico |
Cg |
| 4= | Ripley Corp |
4.76% |
Chile |
R |
| Most convincing and coherent strategy by country | ||||
| Argentina | ||||
No. of companies cited: 12 |
|
|
||
| 2007 | Firm |
Score |
|
Sector |
| 1 | Tenaris |
21.74% |
|
Is |
| 2 | Banco Macro |
14.49% |
|
B |
| 3 | Telecom Argentina |
10.14% |
|
T |
| 4= | Banco Galicia |
8.70% |
|
B |
| 4= | Quilmes Industrial |
8.70% |
|
F |
| 4= | Telefónica de Argentina |
8.70% |
|
T |
| Brazil | |||
No. of companies cited: 28 |
|
||
| 2007 | Firm |
Score |
Sector |
| 1 | Companhia Vale do Rio Doce |
14.69% |
M |
| 2 | Banco Itaú |
9.04% |
B |
| 3 | Petrobras |
8.47% |
O |
| 4 | Natura Cosmeticos |
6.21% |
Cg |
| 5 | Grupo Gerdau |
5.65% |
Is |
| Chile | |||
No. of companies cited: 24 |
|||
| 2007 | Firm |
Score |
Sector |
| 1 | LAN Airlines |
14.57% |
A |
| 2 | Cencosud |
9.05% |
R |
| 3 | Empresas Copec |
8.04% |
O |
| 4 | Entel |
7.54% |
T |
| 5 | La Polar |
6.53% |
R |
| Colombia | |||
No. of companies cited: 11 |
|
||
| 2007 | Firm |
Score |
Sector |
| 1 | Bancolombia |
29.23% |
B |
| 2 | Bavaria |
15.38% |
F |
| 3 | Argos |
13.85% |
C |
| 4 | ISA – Interconexión Eléctrica |
10.77% |
U |
| 5= | COMCEL/América Móvil |
6.15% |
T |
| 5= | Corficolombiana |
6.15% |
B |
| Costa Rica | |||
No. of companies cited: 5 |
|
||
| 2007 | Firm |
Score |
Sector |
| 1 | Scotiabank |
28.57% |
B |
| 2= | Banco de Costa Rica |
21.43% |
B |
| 2= | ICE – Instituto Costarricense de Electricidad |
21.43% |
U |
| 4= | Café Britt |
14.29% |
F |
| 4= | Internet and Networking Security Solutions |
14.29% |
IT |
| No. of companies cited: 6 | ||||
2007 |
Firm |
Score |
Sector |
|
1 |
Banco Cuscatlán |
33.33% |
B |
|
2 |
Banco Agrícola |
29.17% |
B |
|
3 |
TACA |
12.50% |
A |
|
Guatemala |
|
|
|
No. of companies cited: 4 |
|
||
2007 |
Firm |
Score |
Sector |
1= |
Banrural |
30.77% |
B |
1= |
Grupo Gutierrez |
30.77% |
C/Re |
3 |
Grupo Pantaleón |
23.08% |
Ag |
4 |
Banco Industrial |
15.38% |
B |
| Mexico | |||
No. of companies cited: 25 |
|
||
2007 |
Firm |
Score |
Sector |
1 |
América Móvil |
18.69% |
T |
2 |
Cemex |
14.49% |
C |
3 |
Wal-Mart de México |
7.94% |
R |
4 |
Femsa |
7.48% |
F |
5 |
Grupo Financiero Banorte |
4.67% |
B |
| Panama | |||
| No. of companies cited: 4 | |||
2007 |
Firm |
Score |
Sector |
1 |
Banistmo |
44.44% |
B |
2 |
Banco Continental |
33.33% |
B |
3 |
Banco General |
14.81% |
B |
4 |
Grupo ASSA |
7.41% |
IT |
Peru |
|
|
|
No. of companies cited: 14 |
|
||
2007 |
Firm |
Score |
Sector |
1 |
Credicorp |
25.71% |
B |
2 |
Southern Copper |
23.81% |
M |
3 |
Buenaventura |
9.52% |
M |
4 |
GyM – Graña y Montero |
8.57% |
C |
5 |
BBVA Banco Continental |
5.71% |
B |
| Venezuela | |||
No. of companies cited: 3 |
|
||
2007 |
Firm |
Score |
Sector |
1 |
Cantv |
61.54% |
T |
2 |
Banesco |
23.08% |
B |
3 |
Seguros Caracas |
15.38% |
I |
| Most convincing and coherent strategy by sector | |||
Airlines and aviation |
|
|
|
No. of companies cited: 7 |
|
||
2007 |
Firm |
Score |
Country |
1 |
GOL Linhas Aéreas Inteligentes |
32.69% |
Brazil |
2 |
LAN Airlines |
25.00% |
Chile |
3 |
ASUR – Grupo Aeroportuario del Sureste |
15.38% |
Mexico |
4 |
Embraer |
13.46% |
Brazil |
5 |
GAP – Grupo Aeroportuario del Pacífico |
5.77% |
Mexico |
| Banking and financial | |||
No. of companies cited: 26 |
|
||
2007 |
Firm |
Score |
Country |
1 |
Banco Itaú |
13.51% |
Brazil |
2 |
Banco Santander-Chile |
11.89% |
Chile |
3 |
Credicorp |
7.57% |
Peru |
4 |
Bradesco |
7.03% |
Brazil |
5 |
Banco de Chile |
5.95% |
Chile |
| Conglomerates | |||
| No. of companies cited: 8 | |||
2007 |
Firm |
Score |
Country |
1 |
Alfa |
29.63% |
Mexico |
2 |
Votorantim |
22.22% |
Brazil |
3 |
Grupo Carso |
18.52% |
Mexico |
4 |
Grupo Desc |
9.26% |
Mexico |
5 |
Telmex |
7.41% |
Mexico |
| Construction | |||
| No. of companies cited: 12 | |||
2007 |
Firm |
Score |
Country |
1 |
Cemex |
26.39% |
Mexico |
2 |
Corporación GEO |
13.89% |
Mexico |
3 |
Empresas ICA Sociedad Controladora |
12.50% |
Mexico |
4 |
SalfaCorp |
9.72% |
Chile |
5 |
Urbi Desarrollos Urbanos |
8.33% |
Mexico |
| Consumer goods | |||
| No. of companies cited: 10 | |||
2007 |
Firm |
Score |
Country |
1 |
Kimberly-Clark de México |
21.62% |
Mexico |
2= |
AmBev |
10.81% |
Brazil |
2= |
La Polar |
10.81% |
Chile |
2= |
Natura Cosmeticos |
10.81% |
Brazil |
2= |
Sadia |
10.81% |
Brazil |
Food drink and tobacco |
|
||
No. of companies cited: 12 |
|
||
2007 |
Firm |
Score |
Country |
1 |
Femsa |
29.89% |
Mexico |
2 |
Grupo Modelo |
13.79% |
Mexico |
3 |
AmBev |
12.64% |
Brazil |
4 |
Coca-Cola Femsa |
10.34% |
Mexico |
5= |
Perdigão |
6.90% |
Brazil |
5= |
Sadia |
6.90% |
Brazil |
Gaming |
|
|
|
No. of companies cited: 3 |
|
||
2007 |
Firm |
Score |
Country |
1 |
Corp. Interamericana de Entretenimiento |
44.44% |
Mexico |
2 |
Caliente |
33.33% |
Mexico |
3 |
Grupo Televisa |
22.22% |
Mexico |
| Insurance | |||
| No. of companies cited: 4 | |||
| 2007 | Firm | Score | Country |
| 1= | Mapfre | 30.77% | |
| 1= | Rímac Internacional | 30.77% | Peru |
| 3 | Pacífico Grupo Asegurador | 23.08% | Peru |
| 4 | InVita | 15.38% | Peru |
| Iron and steel | |||
| No. of companies cited: 10 | |||
| 2007 | Firm | Score | Country |
| 1 | Grupo Gerdau | 27.78% | Brazil |
| 2 | Companhia Vale do Rio Doce | 22.22% | Brazil |
| 3 | Ternium Siderar | 9.72% | Argentina |
| 4= | ICH – Industrias CH | 8.33% | Mexico |
| 4= | Usiminas | 8.33% | Brazil |
| Media | |||
| No. of companies cited: 4 | |||
| 2007 | Firm | Score | Country |
| 1 | Grupo Televisa | 42.86% | Mexico |
| 2 | NET Serviços | 25.00% | Brazil |
| 3 | TV Azteca | 21.43% | Mexico |
| 4 | Vivax | 10.71% | Brazil |
| Metals and mining | |||
| No. of companies cited: 16 | |||
| 2007 | Firm | Score | Country |
| 1 | Southern Copper | 21.82% | Peru |
| 2 | Companhia Vale do Rio Doce | 17.27% | Brazil |
| 3 | Buenaventura | 13.64% | Peru |
| 4 | GMexico – Grupo México | 9.09% | Mexico |
| 5 | Antofagasta | 7.27% | Chile |
| Petrochemicals | |||
| No. of companies cited: 5 | |||
| 2007 | Firm | Score | Country |
| 1 | Braskem | 39.29% | Brazil |
| 2 | Suzano Petroquímica | 25.00% | Brazil |
| 3= | Solvay Indupa | 14.29% | Argentina |
| 3= | Ultrapar | 14.29% | Brazil |
| 5 | Unipar – União de Industrias Petroquimicas | 7.14% | Brazil |
| Retail | |||
| No. of companies cited: 12 | |||
| 2007 | Firm | Score | Country |
| 1 | Wal-Mart de México | 25.97% | Mexico |
| 2 | La Polar | 15.58% | Chile |
| 3 | Organización Soriana | 11.69% | Mexico |
| 4 | Falabella | 9.09% | Chile |
| 5 | Cencosud | 6.49% | Chile |
| Small caps | ||||
| No. of companies cited: 7 | ||||
| 2007 | Firm | Score | Country | Country |
| 1 | SalfaCorp | 25.00% | Chile | Chile |
| 2 | Andrómaco | 21.43% | Argentina | Argentina |
| 3 | CCR – Companhia de Concessões Rodoviárias | 14.29% | Brazil | Brazil |
| Telecoms cellular | |||
| No. of companies cited: 10 | |||
| 2007 | Firm | Score | Country |
| 1 | América Móvil | 53.13% | Mexico |
| 2 | TIM Brasil | 18.75% | Brazil |
| 3 | Entel | 6.25% | Chile |
| 4 | NII Holdings | 5.21% | Brazil |
| 5 | ETB – Empresa de Teléfonos de Bogotá | 4.17% | Colombia |
| Telecoms fixed | |||
| No. of companies cited: 8 | |||
| 2007 | Firm | Score | Country |
| 1 | Telmex | 38.24% | Mexico |
| 2 | Axtel | 20.59% | Mexico |
| 3 | Telecom Argentina | 11.76% | Argentina |
| 4 | Telecomunicações de São Paulo | 10.29% | Brazil |
| Transport and shipping | |||
| No. of companies cited: 3 | |||
| 2007 | Firm | Score | Country |
| 1 | ASUR – Grupo Aeroportuario del Sureste | 44.44% | Mexico |
| 2 | OMA – Grupo Aeroportuario del Centro Norte | 33.33% | Mexico |
| 3 | GAP – Grupo Aeroportuario del Pacífico | 22.22% | Mexico |
| Utilities | |||
| No. of companies cited: 9 | |||
| 2007 | Firm | Score | Country |
| 1 | EnerSur | 23.08% | Peru |
| 2 | Edegel | 17.31% | Peru |
| 3= | Endesa Chile | 13.46% | Chile |
| 3= | Enersis | 13.46% | Chile |