Latin America’s best managed companies: Tables

Best-managed LATAM companies 2007: A Latin leap forward

Best-managed LATAM companies 2007: A Latin leap forward

Methodology

MOST CONVINCING AND COHERENT STRATEGY
No. of companies cited: 75
2007 Firm Score Country Sector
1 América Móvil

7.30%

Mexico

T

2

Cemex

6.69%

Mexico

C

3

Companhia Vale do Rio Doce

4.46%

Brazil

M

4

Telmex

3.85%

Mexico

T

5

Petrobras

3.45%

Brazil

O

6

Banco Itaú

3.25%

Brazil

B

7

LAN Airlines

2.84%

Chile

A

8=

Femsa

2.64%

Mexico

F

8=

Southern Copper

2.64%

Peru

M

10=

Cencosud

2.43%

Chile

R

10=

Credicorp

2.43%

Peru

B

10=

Empresas Copec

2.43%

Chile

O

Most improved
No. of companies cited: 81

2007

Firm

Score

Country

Sector

1

América Móvil

6.41%

Mexico

T

2

La Polar

4.51%

Chile

R

3

Petrobras

4.28%

Brazil

O

4=

Companhia Vale do Rio Doce

3.80%

Brazil

M

4=

Wal-Mart de México

3.80%

Mexico

R

Most transparent accounts
No. of companies cited: 68

2007

Firm

Score

Country

Sector

1

Companhia Vale do Rio Doce

4.92%

Brazil

M

2

Aracruz Celulose

4.10%

Brazil

P

3

Cemex

3.83%

Mexico

C

4=

Banco Itaú

3.28%

Brazil

B

4=

Petrobras

3.28%

Brazil

O

4=

Wal-Mart de México

3.28%

Mexico

R

Most accessible senior management
No. of companies cited: 76

2007

Firm

Score

Country

Sector

1

Cemex

5.87%

Mexico

C

2

Companhia Vale do Rio Doce

4.08%

Brazil

M

3

Enersis

3.57%

Chile

U

4

Telmex

3.32%

Mexico

T

5=

Consorcio ARA

2.81%

Mexico

C/Re

5=

Credicorp

2.81%

Peru

B

Most useful and informative website
No. of companies cited: 63

2007

Firm

Score

Country

Sector

1

Cemex

8.82%

Mexico

C

2

Corporación GEO

5.79%

Mexico

C/Re

3

Companhia Vale do Rio Doce

5.23%

Brazil

M

4

Femsa

4.68%

Mexico

F

5

Banco Itaú

3.58%

Brazil

B

Best newly listed
No. of companies cited: 30

2007

Firm

Score

Country

Sector

1

GAP – Grupo Aeroportuario del Pacífico

12.15%

Mexico

A

2

Cencosud

8.29%

Chile

R

3

Natura Cosmeticos

6.63%

Brazil

Cg

4=

GOL Linhas Aéreas Inteligentes

5.52%

Brazil

A

4=

OMA – Grupo Aeroportuario del Centro Norte

5.52%

Mexico

Ts

Best small company
No. of companies cited: 28

2007

Firm

Score

Country

Sector

1

La Polar

12.70%

Chile

R

2

SalfaCorp

6.35%

Chile

C

3

Sare Holding

5.56%

Mexico

Re

4=

Axtel

4.76%

Mexico

T

4=

Corporativo Fragua

4.76%

Mexico

Cg

4=

Ripley Corp

4.76%

Chile

R

Most convincing and coherent strategy by country
Argentina

No. of companies cited: 12

 

 

2007

Firm

Score

 

Sector

1

Tenaris

21.74%

 

Is

2

Banco Macro

14.49%

 

B

3

Telecom Argentina

10.14%

 

T

4=

Banco Galicia

8.70%

 

B

4=

Quilmes Industrial

8.70%

 

F

4=

Telefónica de Argentina

8.70%

 

T

Brazil

No. of companies cited: 28

 

2007

Firm

Score

Sector

1

Companhia Vale do Rio Doce

14.69%

M

2

Banco Itaú

9.04%

B

3

Petrobras

8.47%

O

4

Natura Cosmeticos

6.21%

Cg

5

Grupo Gerdau

5.65%

Is

Chile

No. of companies cited: 24

2007

Firm

Score

Sector
1

LAN Airlines

14.57%

A
2

Cencosud

9.05%

R
3

Empresas Copec

8.04%

O
4

Entel

7.54%

T
5

La Polar

6.53%

R
Colombia

No. of companies cited: 11

 

2007

Firm

Score

Sector

1

Bancolombia

29.23%

B

2

Bavaria

15.38%

F

3

Argos

13.85%

C

4

ISA – Interconexión Eléctrica

10.77%

U

5=

COMCEL/América Móvil

6.15%

T

5=

Corficolombiana

6.15%

B

Costa Rica

No. of companies cited: 5

 

2007

Firm

Score

Sector

1

Scotiabank

28.57%

B

2=

Banco de Costa Rica

21.43%

B

2=

ICE – Instituto Costarricense de Electricidad

21.43%

U

4=

Café Britt

14.29%

F

4=

Internet and Networking Security Solutions

14.29%

IT

No. of companies cited: 6

2007

Firm

Score

Sector

 

1

Banco Cuscatlán

33.33%

B

 

2

Banco Agrícola

29.17%

B

 

3

TACA

12.50%

A

 

Guatemala

 

 

No. of companies cited: 4

 

2007

Firm

Score

Sector

1=

Banrural

30.77%

B

1=

Grupo Gutierrez

30.77%

C/Re

3

Grupo Pantaleón

23.08%

Ag

4

Banco Industrial

15.38%

B

Mexico

No. of companies cited: 25

 

2007

Firm

Score

Sector

1

América Móvil

18.69%

T

2

Cemex

14.49%

C

3

Wal-Mart de México

7.94%

R

4

Femsa

7.48%

F

5

Grupo Financiero Banorte

4.67%

B

Panama
No. of companies cited: 4

2007

Firm

Score

Sector

1

Banistmo

44.44%

B

2

Banco Continental

33.33%

B

3

Banco General

14.81%

B

4

Grupo ASSA

7.41%

IT

Peru

 

 

 

No. of companies cited: 14

 

2007

Firm

Score

Sector

1

Credicorp

25.71%

B

2

Southern Copper

23.81%

M

3

Buenaventura

9.52%

M

4

GyM – Graña y Montero

8.57%

C

5

BBVA Banco Continental

5.71%

B

Venezuela

No. of companies cited: 3

 

2007

Firm

Score

Sector

1

Cantv

61.54%

T

2

Banesco

23.08%

B

3

Seguros Caracas

15.38%

I

Most convincing and coherent strategy by sector

Airlines and aviation

 

 

No. of companies cited: 7

 

2007

Firm

Score

Country

1

GOL Linhas Aéreas Inteligentes

32.69%

Brazil

2

LAN Airlines

25.00%

Chile

3

ASUR – Grupo Aeroportuario del Sureste

15.38%

Mexico

4

Embraer

13.46%

Brazil

5

GAP – Grupo Aeroportuario del Pacífico

5.77%

Mexico

Banking and financial

No. of companies cited: 26

 

2007

Firm

Score

Country

1

Banco Itaú

13.51%

Brazil

2

Banco Santander-Chile

11.89%

Chile

3

Credicorp

7.57%

Peru

4

Bradesco

7.03%

Brazil

5

Banco de Chile

5.95%

Chile

Conglomerates
No. of companies cited: 8

2007

Firm

Score

Country

1

Alfa

29.63%

Mexico

2

Votorantim

22.22%

Brazil

3

Grupo Carso

18.52%

Mexico

4

Grupo Desc

9.26%

Mexico

5

Telmex

7.41%

Mexico

Construction
No. of companies cited: 12

2007

Firm

Score

Country

1

Cemex

26.39%

Mexico

2

Corporación GEO

13.89%

Mexico

3

Empresas ICA Sociedad Controladora

12.50%

Mexico

4

SalfaCorp

9.72%

Chile

5

Urbi Desarrollos Urbanos

8.33%

Mexico

Consumer goods
No. of companies cited: 10

2007

Firm

Score

Country

1

Kimberly-Clark de México

21.62%

Mexico

2=

AmBev

10.81%

Brazil

2=

La Polar

10.81%

Chile

2=

Natura Cosmeticos

10.81%

Brazil

2=

Sadia

10.81%

Brazil

Food drink and tobacco

 

No. of companies cited: 12

 

2007

Firm

Score

Country

1

Femsa

29.89%

Mexico

2

Grupo Modelo

13.79%

Mexico

3

AmBev

12.64%

Brazil

4

Coca-Cola Femsa

10.34%

Mexico

5=

Perdigão

6.90%

Brazil

5=

Sadia

6.90%

Brazil

Gaming

 

 

 

No. of companies cited: 3

 

2007

Firm

Score

Country

1

Corp. Interamericana de Entretenimiento

44.44%

Mexico

2

Caliente

33.33%

Mexico

3

Grupo Televisa

22.22%

Mexico

Insurance
No. of companies cited: 4
2007 Firm Score Country
1= Mapfre 30.77%
1= Rímac Internacional 30.77% Peru
3 Pacífico Grupo Asegurador 23.08% Peru
4 InVita 15.38% Peru
Iron and steel
No. of companies cited: 10
2007 Firm Score Country
1 Grupo Gerdau 27.78% Brazil
2 Companhia Vale do Rio Doce 22.22% Brazil
3 Ternium Siderar 9.72% Argentina
4= ICH – Industrias CH 8.33% Mexico
4= Usiminas 8.33% Brazil
Media
No. of companies cited: 4
2007 Firm Score Country
1 Grupo Televisa 42.86% Mexico
2 NET Serviços 25.00% Brazil
3 TV Azteca 21.43% Mexico
4 Vivax 10.71% Brazil
Metals and mining
No. of companies cited: 16
2007 Firm Score Country
1 Southern Copper 21.82% Peru
2 Companhia Vale do Rio Doce 17.27% Brazil
3 Buenaventura 13.64% Peru
4 GMexico – Grupo México 9.09% Mexico
5 Antofagasta 7.27% Chile
Petrochemicals
No. of companies cited: 5
2007 Firm Score Country
1 Braskem 39.29% Brazil
2 Suzano Petroquímica 25.00% Brazil
3= Solvay Indupa 14.29% Argentina
3= Ultrapar 14.29% Brazil
5 Unipar – União de Industrias Petroquimicas 7.14% Brazil
Retail
No. of companies cited: 12
2007 Firm Score Country
1 Wal-Mart de México 25.97% Mexico
2 La Polar 15.58% Chile
3 Organización Soriana 11.69% Mexico
4 Falabella 9.09% Chile
5 Cencosud 6.49% Chile
Small caps
No. of companies cited: 7
2007 Firm Score Country Country
1 SalfaCorp 25.00% Chile Chile
2 Andrómaco 21.43% Argentina Argentina
3 CCR – Companhia de Concessões Rodoviárias 14.29% Brazil Brazil
Telecoms cellular
No. of companies cited: 10
2007 Firm Score Country
1 América Móvil 53.13% Mexico
2 TIM Brasil 18.75% Brazil
3 Entel 6.25% Chile
4 NII Holdings 5.21% Brazil
5 ETB – Empresa de Teléfonos de Bogotá 4.17% Colombia
Telecoms fixed
No. of companies cited: 8
2007 Firm Score Country
1 Telmex 38.24% Mexico
2 Axtel 20.59% Mexico
3 Telecom Argentina 11.76% Argentina
4 Telecomunicações de São Paulo  10.29% Brazil
Transport and shipping
No. of companies cited: 3
2007 Firm Score Country
1 ASUR – Grupo Aeroportuario del Sureste 44.44% Mexico
2 OMA – Grupo Aeroportuario del Centro Norte 33.33% Mexico
3 GAP – Grupo Aeroportuario del Pacífico 22.22% Mexico
Utilities
No. of companies cited: 9
2007 Firm Score Country
1 EnerSur 23.08% Peru
2 Edegel 17.31% Peru
3= Endesa Chile 13.46% Chile
3= Enersis 13.46% Chile