China announces that it will issue bonds worth $200 billion to capitalize its new investment fund. The Qatar and Dubai governments agree a deal to set up a new vehicle looking at international and regional investment opportunities. The Abu Dhabi authorities spin off a new investment arm, the Abu Dhabi Investment Council, from the Abu Dhabi Investment Authority (Adia).
Not a week goes by without a sovereign wealth fund grabbing the headlines. These vehicles, which are government run, are not new. Adia, for example, was set up more than 30 years ago. What is new is the number of these funds and their sheer size and influence. They have assets, built either through commodity exports or foreign exchange reserves, of between $1.5 trillion and $2.5 trillion, according to analysts. As such they are among the most important investors in the international financial markets.
The speed at which these funds are accumulating assets is providing much food for thought. Traditionally, they have invested in low risk assets: US treasuries, US agencies, European sovereign bonds. They continue to do so. But there is nowhere near enough new supply of these assets to satisfy their demand.
Last year, according to the US Treasury, net issuance of traditional reserve assets totalled $461 billion. At the same it reckons that official flows from sovereign wealth funds were about $1.2 trillion. That means that even if these funds bought the entire net issuance of reserve assets they would have about $740 billion left over. This money has to be put somewhere beyond new (and existing) traditional reserve assets.
Where is it going? The answer is everywhere: private equity, real estate, public equities, emerging markets, as well as government bonds. Recent high-profile transactions include Qatar Investment Authority, via its Delta Two fund, becoming the single biggest shareholder in UK retailer J Sainsbury. QIA now has a 25% stake in the company amid rumours of a complete buyout.
Another Middle East government fund, Dubai International Capital, part of the Dubai Holding group, bought a sizeable stake in HSBC in May. It did so for its Global Strategic Equities Fund, which is set to invest $10 billion in various Fortune 500 companies. The Chinese have also been active, spending $3 billion on a 10% stake in Blackstone before the private equity company’s IPO last month.
At a time when concerns of a liquidity crunch are all too apparent, these funds are guarantors of liquidity, especially in equity markets. Traditionally, that function has been fulfilled by pension funds, though they have migrated over the past few years towards bonds in an effort to better match their assets with their liabilities. Government funds have stepped into the breach.
Moreover, these funds tend to be long term in their outlook, not too highly levered, and well connected with the best brokers, consultants, custodians and third-party fund managers. The information well they draw on before they make an investment is second to none.
Yet these funds also bring risks. First and foremost is the level of secrecy they adopt. Many government funds are notorious for operating below the radar screen. And although the situation is improving, there is still much unknown, not least how much money they actually manage. QIA, Adia, Istithmar (another Dubai fund) among others have never revealed the size of their assets.
A second, related risk is that as government funds they can expect to encounter resentment and backlash in owning other countries’ assets. Will politicians and the public be happy if these funds build sizeable stakes in strategic or well-known assets? Will these funds accept a greater level of scrutiny? Greater transparency would help all sides to understand the important role sovereign wealth-funds play in the international financial system.