One has to feel some sympathy for hedge fund administrator Globe Op after Archeus Capital squarely blamed it for redemptions to the tune of $2.3 billion. The founders of Archeus, former Salomon Brothers bond traders Gary Kilberg and Peter Hirsch, wrote to their investors advising of the fund’s closure and blaming the failure of its administrator to maintain accurate records.
Archeus, a multi-strategy fund, had seen assets drop from $3 billion one year ago to less than $700 million. Some sources say Globe Op was late in its net asset value reporting, and administrative problems at Archeus undermined investor confidence. The resulting redemptions triggered the liquidation of assets that ultimately affected the fund’s performance, leading to yet further investor redemptions, say the founders.
It’s unclear exactly what Globe Op did, and whether the blame falls as squarely on the administrator as Archeus implies. It’s certainly hard, though, to find anyone in the industry who blames Globe Op and Globe Op alone for Archeus’s debacle.
Admittedly, Globe Op is paid to provide a quality service, and if it did not do this because of incompetence it could indeed be blamed for administrative failings. However, it might be expected that a $3 billion fund would have been cross-checking with its administrator and keeping its own set of records as a back-up – especially when the industry is under such scrutiny.
Of course, such considerations would have been irrelevant at Archeus’s founders’ former stomping ground, Salomon, but out in the wide world, traders must really pay attention to their reporting. It might seem extravagant to have an administrator and then back up reporting in house. However, it is no different to having an in-house accounts department and then being independently audited.
Interestingly, there has been no mention of the role of the prime brokers. One would think that they would have some opinion given that they have to reconcile reports with the fund and a third-party administrator.
Whether it will all come out in the wash remains to be seen. Some reports claim that Archeus is not ruling out legal action. That the firm would want to drag itself through court seems unlikely – particularly as we can assume that Messrs Kilberg and Hirsch will be popping up at a different hedge fund in the future.