From his office high above the streets in a new building in Makati, Manila’s business district, former president Fidel V Ramos looks out across the city and gestures expansively at the rust-roofed shanties that cling to every corner of the city. “I’m concerned for those people there,” he says.
By most calculations, a third of all Filipinos are constantly battling with poverty. And most of them are not winning. The Philippines is Asia’s seventh-most populous nation, and with annual population growth of 2.5%, it is forecast that there will be 100 million Filipinos within 10 years. Although the proportion of those living on or below the poverty line is not expected to change, the absolute number of those living in poverty will continue to climb.
And the country’s financial situation is suffering as a result of the continuing political crisis surrounding president Gloria Macapagal Arroyo (GMA). Ramos – in a reference to his personal campaign calling for, among other things, constitutional change – says: “I’m asking Gloria for a sacrifice, to shorten her term.”
He insists the campaign is not a precursor of another tilt at office. Barred by the existing constitution from running again after his single presidential term, Ramos has founded RPDEV, the Ramos Peace and Development Foundation, as a platform for his socio-political agenda [see Ramos aims to reinvent the republic, this issue]. This includes changing the Philippines’ constitution from a bicameral, presidential system to a parliamentary democracy, a notion that has gained momentum as a result of the political crisis.
That crisis entails serious allegations levelled at GMA of vote tampering in last year’s presidential elections as well as pay-offs to members of her immediate family from illegal lotteries known as jueteng.
So serious were the allegations and so ham-fisted the administration’s handling of the crisis that 10 members of GMA’s cabinet, including the finance secretary, resigned in protest at her leadership, amid calls from the business community for her to step down.
“What she’s done is completely unacceptable,” says Guillermo Luz, executive director of the influential Makati Business Club and one of the more vociferous voices to call on GMA to quit. “It’s not just her. Accepting what she did as alright says a lot about ourselves. Accepting what she did means it’s alright means it’s open season.”
Pantomime politics There is an awful lot of self-examination going on in Manila, with talk of sacrifices and the need for a higher consciousness for the greater good. The problem is, it is difficult to separate the rhetoric from reality. The Philippines is a nation that adores a bit of drama and glamour, especially in its politics. It is a dangerous combination that, coupled with a tendency to elect populist, colourful presidents, has resulted in the theatre of politics degenerating in recent years into little more than pantomime. Business leaders have had enough.
” We can’t have this self-flagellation in the press every day,” says Aurelio Montinola III, president of the Bank of the Philippine Islands, “but I hope there’s a bit of catharsis. Everyone’s disgusted. In the business community, we just want consistency of policy, whatever it is, and the freedom to do what we do best.”
A banking competitor agrees. “I’m exhausted by all of this,” says Nestor Tan, president of Banco De Oro. “I’d just like to see a peaceful and orderly resolution, whatever the outcome.”
There is little evidence that his hopes will be fulfilled. Having refused to step down, GMA is now under the threat of an impeachment process that could easily drag on for months. While congress concerns itself with internecine politicking, the country’s financial health is starting to look precarious. Indeed, amid all of the political hand-wringing and heroic talk of sacrifices, it is the country itself, especially the poor, that is making the biggest sacrifice as investment dries up, prices rise and unemployment increases.
|
Asian economies – GDP per capita |
||
| Rank | Country/territory | GDP per capita |
| 1 | Hong Kong | 34,200 |
| 2 | Japan | 29,400 |
| 3 | Singapore | 27,800 |
| 4 | Taiwan | 25,300 |
| 5 | South Korea | 19,200 |
| 6 | Malaysia | 9,700 |
| 7 | Thailand | 8,100 |
| 8 | China | 5,600 |
| 9 | Philippines | 5,000 |
| 10 | Indonesia | 3,500 |
| 11 | India | 3,100 |
Just a few months earlier, it all looked so different. Under then-finance secretary Cesar Purisima, the government introduced a series of fiscal and tax measures designed to tackle a government budget deficit that stands at P180 billion ($3.23 billion). An increase in electricity prices, fresh taxes on tobacco and alcohol, and an incentive package to increase tax collections all pointed to a fresh attitude of fiscal responsibility in government. The key tax-raising measure, the expanded value added tax (Evat), estimated to be worth some P60 billion in new revenues annually, was finally passed by congress in June. The markets responded to all this good news with predictable zeal, with strong increases in the peso rate and the stock market and a fall in government debt yields.
Then came the political crisis that has consumed the country ever since and now threatens to unravel the achievements made so far. Implementation of the Evat programme, essentially a two percentage point increase on the existing VAT rate as well as the abolition of a number of exemptions, has already been halted by the supreme court while it rules on whether or not the bill is unconstitutional. Meanwhile, despite new tax collection incentive schemes, recent data suggest the tax take has actually grown smaller.
Brave face Despite the predicament, some are assuming a brave face. “It’s true that early on in the year the peso was strengthening,” says Amando Tetangco Jr, governor of Bangko Sentral Ng Pilipinas, the central bank. “Our fiscal position was improving and the stockmarket booming. Then we had the political crisis, but on the economic side these gains are still there. If the political issues don’t take too long to resolve, the gains will continue.”
The recently appointed new finance secretary, Margarito Teves, is clearly basing his sums on these gains. “We’re not taking any chances,” says Teves. “For every month that the Evat is suspended, the revenue forgone is P5 billion. We’re assuming that the supreme court will decide on suspension, latest by August, so that’s P10 billion [of revenue lost]. We’re looking at items like existing taxes, collecting a bit more. We think we can recover that, but our focus has been to get the supreme court to lift the suspension right away. We’re confident they will: it’s a major factor to help us reach a consolidated fiscal balance.”
Others are not so sure that the supreme court will reinstate the Evat promptly. “Now the Evat is up in the air, I’m not that optimistic that it’s going to come back that soon,” says Luz. “If the court doesn’t lift the ban on Evat, the government is going to have a major financial problem. And if it is lifted, the government’s going to have a political problem, it’s so unpopular.”
It is not just the issue of Evat that has become politicized, claims Luz, but also revenue generation in general. “Early this year, tax collections went up,” he says. “We didn’t change the system, we just went after the tax evaders in such a public way that it changed attitudes. Why have collections gone down again? Because they went back to the old system. The first statement from the new BIR [Bureau of Internal Revenue] commissioner was ‘I’m not here to put people in jail.’ Now the attitude is ‘catch me if you can’ and ‘everything’s negotiable’.”
Tetangco agrees. “One important programme started under former finance secretary Purisima was RATEs – Run After Tax Evaders,” he says. “It created a fear factor in the system. It showed that the government was serious about collecting – that you’d better pay up. That momentum has got to be sustained. If there’s an impression that the government is relaxing, you might see a reversal in the trend.”
Luz remains doubtful that the government will make ends meet as things stand. “They’ve figured they’re good to the end of September because they were ahead by P15 billion on collections,” he says. “They say they can raise tariffs on imports by 1%. But what they haven’t figured is that they won’t collect what they assume. The equation’s changed.”
If the government’s sums do not work, then it will have to go back cap in hand to congress, as Teves admits. “We’ll have to continue to work on contingency plans,” he says, “to ensure we can recover revenue forgone. Under the worst case, we’ll have to go back to congress and present an alternative bill. We look at contingency plans – as responsible executives we do that. But we also work on probabilities, so we’re spending more time on getting the supreme court to lift its suspension.”
Living on luck Luckily the government still has time to fix the fiscal hole, but not all that much, as Alfred Dy, head of research at broker CLSA Philippines in Manila explains. “The economy has some problems,” he says, “but it’s not going to blow up. Luckily for us, the debt is medium term. P15 billion is good for two years’ [debt] maturity. That explains why interest rates are low and the peso is stable. They have a window of two years to improve the structural issues. It’s a chronic deficit – internal and external debt is more than 100% of GDP, so we’re highly leveraged. Luckily the cashflows are there to service the debt for the next two years.”
It’s lucky also that the country has some 8 million citizens working abroad, the overseas foreign workers or OFWs, who each year send back up to $10 billion officially (and perhaps $2 billion unofficially) in cash to feed and clothe their extended families [see Manana money, this issue]. Without this, the Philippines might have defaulted already.
“Just add up the interest and debt payments the government has to pay each year,” says Montinola of Bank of the Philippines Islands. “Coincidentally, it’s close to the same sum as the OFW remittances.”
With a political system that engenders cronyism and corruption, and a chronic fiscal problem that denies the government the capital for desperately needed investment programmes to improve crumbling infrastructure and generate jobs, it is little wonder that as many as one Filipino family in four has learnt to rely on OFW remittances to make ends meet.
It is not just the families that have had to do without government help; business has also had to learn this lesson. Despite the government’s handling of the economy, rather than because of it, some businesses in the Philippines are actually performing well. Chief among these are the country’s banks.
As the political crisis drags on and the fiscal position worsens, the Philippine economy continues to lag those of most of its Asian neighbours. Whether changing the constitution is the solution for the country’s ills is debatable. Simply changing the political system will not eradicate the government deficit or increase investment and jobs. That will take much more political will and leadership than has been displayed hitherto.
And it will make no difference at all to the street urchins and slum dwellers in Manila.
‘Bayan ko, sagot ko’ reads the slogan painted on nearly every taxi in Manila. ‘My country, my responsibility’ is the rough translation. It is a harsh but instructive message for a people being so badly let down by their own government.