|
Why biggest isn’t always smartest | Methodology | Results tables |
||
| Equities | Fixed income | Non-bank fixed income |
| Foreign exchange | Non-bank foreign exchange | Derivatives |
| Corporate and investor services | ||
Best at money markets trading
Currenex
Currenex develops all its technology internally, so it was able to respond quickly to customer demand to have access to money markets on its platform. It introduced its money markets trading capability in 2002.
Currenex’s independent ownership structure has enabled it to develop a balanced suite of features for both sell-side and buy-side clients. For example, day traders can opt to install a tab displaying their profits and loss so that they can check it against the collateral that they have with their brokers.
When Currenex introduced streaming rates it included a number of important protections for liquidity-supplying banks. For example, if a buy-side client accepts a price then a message will automatically be sent to the bank that streamed the price to confirm it. Currenex introduced its streaming prices service in late 2002 and it has since seen tremendous growth.
Clients can receive executable quotes in response to price requests or orders, or can directly access streaming prices through Currenex ESP. Executable prices from all banks are presented simultaneously and refreshed in real time as the banks stream. The on-line service also offers instant access to all trade details and audit reports that display all competing quotes along with the savings against each.
Straight-through processing functions include pre-trade upload, post-trade amendments, forward rolls, allocations, confirm matching, settlement instructions and post-trade downloads.
Currenex attracts a varied set of customer types, including corporates, funds, brokers, buy-side and sell-side banks and, more recently, arcades of day traders. In response to continuing requests to enhance the service, Currenex produces four major software releases a year, an achievement that is unmatched in the industry. DK
Best at automated streaming prices
Hotspot FX
Hotspot FX celebrates its fifth anniversary this year, with good reason in view of its 150% annual volume growth. Multi-bank platforms have become increasingly popular – in 2004 alone the volume of currency traded through big on-line platforms more than doubled. Hotspot FX caters for both institutional and retail market participants by providing anonymous, instantaneous, direct-access trading on live, executable, streaming prices supplied by banks and financial institutions.
Automated streaming prices (ASP) have always been an important component of Hotspot’s business model and live streaming, executable prices were introduced back in 2001. “We were pioneers in streaming technology and we are continually improving it to make it more efficient,” says John Eley, president and CEO at Hotspot FX.
Its interface uses colours and shapes to help clients process information more efficiently. Users can click and deal on the streaming rates and an instant confirmation of deals will appear on both the banks’ and the clients’ screens. In addition to seeing the best bid and offer, FX trading clients can view all prices in the Hotspot FX marketplace as well as the available quantity at each bid-offer price. This feature enables clients to gauge market conditions. DK
Best at FX dealer-to-client trading
Saxo Bank
Saxo Bank continues to offer strong competition to the larger firms in the industry. In addition to FX, investors can trade contracts for difference, stocks, managed funds and options on SaxoTrader. Given the size of this Danish bank, the breadth and depth of its capabilities is impressive. Clients have access to over 120 currency pairs, including majors, minors and exotics and the bank can quote, for example, two pips on euro/dollar for up to e20 million.
FX spot prices can be dragged up on to the screen and the client can establish multiple trade templates with preferred currency pairs, trade types and trade sizes. A trade confirmation instantly appears on the screen after a trade is executed and an account summary of all trades can be displayed at any time. This is not only constantly updated but offers real-time margin calculations and other risk management tools, such as managing the boundaries of trading ranges.
There is also a chart function that enables multiple views and time periods against all the underlying FX crosses. “Our main focus is really being a facilitator,” says Kim Fournais, co-CEO of Saxo Bank. “We take the best liquidity and package it with technology and offer it on a platform that caters for all the needs of end-users.”
Saxo Bank differentiates itself from other multi-providers, as it actually takes on some of the market risk attached to the trades. “Out of the flows we see go through the platform, we hedge around 80% of it and the remaining 20% sits with us,” says Fournais. “We don’t just match prices but we offer our own liquidity too.”
All technology is developed in house, so enhancements to the platform can be produced quickly. In August 2004, TradeMaker was added to the platform. This offers trading advice from analysts within Saxo Bank and a client can trade directly on the predictions offered by the team. DK
Best at interdealer options
Saxo Bank
Saxo Bank introduced FX over-the-counter options to its platform as early as 2001. It currently offers forward outrights and options on a request-for-quote basis. However, Saxo would like to be able to quote streaming tradable prices on options. “We introduced streaming pricing to spot very early on and we would like our clients interested in trading options to be able to choose their strike, the expiry date and the currency pair they want to deal as the system continuously updates the price,” says Kim Fournais, co-CEO of Saxo Bank.
FX options are quoted alongside spot on the platform so that traders can manage their risk across the two markets. “In many cases, investors don’t have the ability to actually cross-margin their options and spot books,” says Fournais. “We have managed to build both systems on the same platform, so it is very easy for anyone to deal both these products.”
The platform can calculate the net margin that a trader has to put up for combined spot and options positions. “We see a lot of potential in the options market, as it gives another dimension for trading the FX markets,” adds Fournais. “We have a pretty significant IT project focusing on improving that side of our platform even more.” This year, Saxo Bank plans to expand its exotic options capability. DK