AFTER A COURTSHIP of the European Union lasting 40 years, Turkey was formally dubbed a candidate country by the European Commission in December. Now it is looking towards greatly expanded foreign investment and aid. But it is also awakening to the harsh realities of preparation for EU membership that will intensify when accession negotiations begin on October 3.
The good news includes hopes that long-expected foreign investment and tens of billions of euros in European development aid will be forthcoming. More worrisome are a host of new rules associated with membership ranging from costly environmental standards to safer school buses and concerns that many Turkish enterprises will be hard pressed to compete in a fully integrated Europe.
A wholesale restructuring
“Arriving at the finish line to begin negotiations with the European Union, even if those talks are destined to take years, is an accomplishment whose meaning is hard to exaggerate,” says Orhan Cakmak, an economist with the Turkish Union of Chambers of Commerce and Industry. “But it is also an event, when coupled with the end of high inflation and the opening of the economy to competition, that means a wholesale restructuring of the way of doing business and the way of thinking.”
The EC’s decision brought euphoria to the Istanbul Stock Exchange, which reached record levels, driven by foreign share buying on the day of the EU accord. The exchange closed 2004 with net share buying by foreigners up 112% on 2003. In the first 11 months of 2004, foreigners bought $21.2 billion in shares and sold 16.8 million for a net trading volume of $37.9 billion. Final tallies are expected to boost those numbers close to $40 billion for the year, compared with $20.5 billion in 2003.
As far as the wider economy is concerned, the December accord clears the way for harmonization funds designed to ease the pain of what will be at least a decade of negotiations over the reform of the economy and public institutions ranging from education to municipal administration. The deal to begin formal talks envisages a staggered timetable for Turkey to bring its institutions into line with European norms. But the deal on EU membership is also the most visible and symbolic of many changes long sought and earnestly pursued since the 2002 elections delivered Turkey’s first single-party majority in parliament in a generation.
Despite early concerns about its Islamic-lite outlook, the new centre-right government of the Justice and Development Party quickly indicated that it was keeping to the path prescribed by the IMF in exchange for support after the financial crisis of 2001. It also charted a path to full EU membership, propelling politically sensitive reforms on human rights, the rule of law, intellectual property, business transparency and national treatment for foreign capital through parliament and past a sometimes sceptical military.
Politically, the party gained credibility in Europe, first in 2003 when it shunned US requests to open a Turkish front in its invasion of Iraq. A year later, the government of prime minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan shepherded a UN-backed plan for the reunification of the divided island of Cyprus to a referendum held in both the ethnically Greek south and Turkish north. The island has been divided since the 1974 Turkish invasion following a Greece-inspired coup that sought to annex the island to Greece.
The goal of the referendum was reunification as a prelude to the island’s joining the EU in its 2004 expansion to include 10 new nations. To the surprise of many, the Greek side rejected the deal while the Turkish side approved it; the result was that only Greek Cyprus joined the EU. Nevertheless goodwill political dividends redeemable in Brussels flowed to Turkey.
Knocking off zeros
Turkey’s economic position has also continued to improve. Two- and three-digit annual inflation that has persisted for decades has kept falling, reaching a better-than-expected 9% last year despite high oil prices and increases in US interest rates. To cap the taming of inflation, as of midnight on December 31 Turkey scrapped its old currency, whose zeros were uncontrollably proliferating. A million Turkish lira (TL) became one new YTL, the acronym for new Turkish lira. The IMF was so pleased with progress that in December it extended a stand-by accord for an extra three years and advanced $10 billion in credit, arguing that it would probably be the last time that Turkey would need such help.
An economy that shrunk by some 12% in 2001 amid a profound banking crisis grew in 2005 at an estimated 9.5%. The rating agencies have responded. Standard & Poor’s and Fitch Ratings have recently upgraded the sovereign from B+ to BB-, one notch below investment grade.
As well as fostering relations with Europe, Turkey has maintained its ties with other neighbours. It has good economic relations with Israel, despite being critical of Israeli policy towards Palestine, and has negotiated a free trade accord with Syria while settling a 60-year-old border dispute.
A state visit to Iran by Erdogan helped improve troubled relations, and among the rewards was a contract which, subject to the approval of an Iranian parliamentary commission, will make Turkey’s cellphone operator Turkcell the first private operator in the country. Iran exports liquefied natural gas to Turkey and more mutual trade and investment is expected.
Turkey has also broadened relations with Russia. Russian president Vladimir Putin made the first state visit in more than 30 years by a Russian leader in December, concluding some $2.5 billion in deals. That package includes a plan to extend a gas pipeline already reaching Turkey’s northern Black Sea city of Samsun on to the Mediterranean port of Ceyhan. This will include a plant to liquefy natural gas and store it for shipping. In January, Erdogan travelled to Moscow, accompanied by 600 businessmen and some 80 journalists.
The January visit led to a proposal to extend the gas pipeline project beyond Ceyhan to Israel as a combination peace and commerce initiative. The Turks and Russians also launched discussions on joint construction of Turkey’s first nuclear power facility as well as conventional stations.
“From Russia to Greece to Iran to Syria, not to mention Europe, Turkey is increasingly normalizing and deepening its economic relations with its neighbours,” says Haluk Burumcekci, chief economist for Disbank. “These are all good developments in their own right, but when coupled with what is happening on the European front it suggests that we will increasingly play a bridge role to the region for Europe while we integrate with Europe ourselves.”
Burumcekci and others predict that the most tangible result of the EU accession process and Turkey’s growing bridge role will be further consolidation and foreign investment in the banking sector, already the subject of the most foreign interest. Banking the most suited of any sector for foreign acquisition. Today, less than 5% of Turkey’s banking is in foreign hands while the EU average is 24%. Among recent new members, membership has quickly led to bank acquisitions and the average foreign share among the banks of new EU members in eastern Europe is above 70%. Burumcekci and others caution that Turkey’s economy differs in many fundamental ways from the post-Soviet economies of eastern Europe, making such comparisons imprecise. But even if foreign entry is likely to be less dramatic in Turkey, it is regarded as inevitable and is already under way.
A big fish that got away
Turkey’s biggest banking deal in 2004 was the one that failed: a planned acquisition by Italy’s Banca Intesa of a controlling interest in Garanti Bankasi, Turkey’s third-biggest bank. The much-heralded deal unravelled last summer and Garanti’s parent, Dogus Group, is playing down the prospects of another suitor showing up soon. However, since then France’s BNP-Paribas has concluded a $250 million deal to acquire a controlling interest in mid-size Turk Economy Bank (TEB).
The only other bank with a concrete deal under way is Sekerbank, which is owned by pension funds and sugar beet cooperatives. These announced talks in December with Dutch bank Rabobank, which is said to be interested in a majority stake. Among mid-size banks, Disbank, whose management has said it is seeking a foreign strategic partnership, is said to be likely to announce a deal soon. Other names mentioned as foreign targets include Finansbank and Alternatif Bank. The list of suitors includes French banks Crédit Agricole and Société Générale and, again, Banca Intesa.
A buyer might also be found to rescue troubled bank Yapi Kredi in the form of Koc Financial Services, a 50-50 partnership between conglomerate Koc and Italian banking group UniCredito. Yapi Kredi’s parent, the heavily indebted Cukurova Group, is operating under a form of receivership according to which it must pay more than $100 million to the bank by the end of this month to maintain its interest.
Yapi Kredi’s market capitalization in January was $2.5 billion. The Koc-UniCredito proposal is for a controlling 45% share in Yapi Kredi held by Cukurova, a deal that would be welcomed by bankers weary of on-again off-again plans for Turkey’s fourth-largest private bank.
In another discussion of potential foreign partners, last month the head of the state agency controlling Turkey’s two main state banks, Halkbank and Ziraat, announced meetings with potential buyers of Halkbank, one domestic and one foreign. However, most bankers dismissed that announcement as a political cover for the government’s foot-dragging in privatization efforts.
Not all bank merger prospects involve foreigners. Akbank, owned by the Sabanci conglomerate and currently the biggest private bank, is said to be keen to acquire in order to expand growth in credit cards and retail banking and as a hedge against expected foreign competition.
The textile and automotive sectors are also expected to see new foreign interest and tie-ups. An early move came in January when Korea’s Hyundai Motor announced that it was seeking to increase its 50% share of local Hyundai Assan to 70%. The deal would involve a payment of $41.7 million for the additional shares plus new capital investment in Turkey of $500 million. Ali Kibar, the chairman of Hyundai Assan, says the deal is still being negotiated but will involve decisions on new models, production volumes and export markets. Turkey’s auto sector broke production and export records in 2004 and it is expected that fuller integration with the EU will turn it into a major export base.
The potential for the retail sector was highlighted by news last month that US retailer Wal-Mart is negotiating with the Koc Group for a deal with Koc’s Migros supermarket chain. Koc chairman Rahmi Koc confirmed the negotiations and said Wal-Mart’s interest in Russia underlay the potential deal. Migros already has 24 stores operating in Russia under its Ramstore brand.
FDI is still sluggish but is expected to exceed $2.5 billion in 2005, compared with $1.7 billion in 2004. But dramatic growth in inflows could be around the corner, predicts Abdurrahman Ariman, the former head of Turkey’s association of foreign investors (YASED).
International advocacy
“Having got a date [to begin EU accession negotiations) it completes the picture of what we’ve been struggling for for years,” says Ariman. “There is political stability, the economy is stable and growing and the investment environment is dramatically improved, in large part because of what it took to get a date to begin negotiations to join the EU. This is what foreign investors have been demanding. Now we have all of it. Or at least most of it.”
One missing element, says Ariman, is regional development agencies to promote assets and locations, aid foreign investors and lobby on behalf of Turkey internationally. “Every country has an advocate for foreign investors but we don’t have a team on the field,” he says. Legislation will shortly be passed to create six such agencies around Turkey that could begin work within six months.
Foreigners largely steered clear of Turkish privatizations in 2004, but the privatization administration nonetheless picked up the pace with strong interest from domestic investors. Two passenger ships, a cotton mill, manganese and iron ore mines, a tractor factory, a regional gas distribution company and a cotton mill were sold off. This brought in $1.2 billion, compared with $171 million in 2003. The one privatization that did attract foreign interest was the novel public offering of a 23% share in flag carrier Turkish Airlines. This netted $200 million from 29,385 investors. Some 65% of buyers were foreigners, including 105 institutional investors, according to the privatization administration.
In 2005, state telecommunications provider Turk Telecom might be among the big ticket items. Although domestic long-distance and international markets have been opened to private competitors, this company retains a monopoly on local calls and serves 20 million fixed-line phones. In January, firms seeking qualification to bid for 55% of Turk Telecom included Spain’s Telefónica, Telecom Italia, Belgium’s Belgacom, Germany’s Deutsche Telekom, Saudi Telecom and the Islamic finance house Kuwait Turk, Dubai Islamic Bank, the Malaysian GSM operator Maxix Communications and a company owned by Lebanon’s former prime minister, Rafif El-Hariri.
Domestic interests seeking to enter the bidding include most of the new start-ups in Turkey’s fledgling domestic competition: Oger Telekom, Eser Telecom, Koc Holding, Sabanci Holding, the Oyak Group, the Calik Group and Turktell. The three GSM operators, Turkcell, Avea and Telsim, were banned from participation by the competition authority but Telsim itself, part of the collapsed Uzan family empire now in public receivership, is itself slated to be privatized this year. Attempts in the past decade to sell the politically sensitive telecoms provider have failed. If the proposed 55% block sale fails again, transport and telecoms minister Binali Yildirim has said Turk Telekom will be sold through a public offering akin to the successful – and popular – share offering in Turkish Airlines.
Attention is also focused on protections for domestic makers of generic drugs, long a target of pharmaceuticals multinationals, and soon to be history. And many expect the end of this anti-competitive protection to trigger massive delayed investment.
But other businesses, particularly in agriculture and food processing, which employ a third of the workforce, face a traumatic shakeout: 98% of milk production, for example, does not meet European hygiene standards; livestock production’s productivity is less than 10% of the EU average and survives only through a ban on imports that will be an early target when negotiations begin in October on the timetable to complete economic integration. A large part of the harmonization funds, currently about $2 billion a year but likely to rise to at least $10 billion in 2007, will target agriculture.
Even with massive aid, such traditional industries, which also include small manufacturers, retailers and service providers, are seen as especially vulnerable to the strains of EU compliance and to competition. Cakmak’s Union of Chambers of Commerce and Industry is leading seminars over the next few months to drive home the point that Turkey now faces no-holds-barred competition. “The modern sectors of the economy will adjust and compete, but such practices as holding high stock levels as a hedge against inflation are ingrained among many small and medium-size enterprises and this must change and change quickly,” Cakmak says.
Sacrifice and change
The shock of change will also affect consumers, says Esra Hatipoglu, a professor of international relations at Marmara University’s European Institute. Over the next decade, taxis will have to install windows separating driver and passenger, school buses will need to be equipped with seat belts, some 200,000 elevators will need to be equipped with safety doors and popular brands of food mixers might disappear from store shelves since they fail to meet EU decibel standards. One highly controversial estimate by the EU of the cost of Turkey’s compliance with European garbage collection, recycling and storage standards puts the tab at e60 billion over the next decade – a sum equal to Turkey’s foreign debt. “The public has yet to realize the sacrifice and change this is going to involve,” says Hatipoglu. “There’s an expectation that things will just change on their own but Turks are going to have to change the way they live.”
An additional worry is the rapidly rising current account deficit, which was nearly $11 billion at the end of 2004 or 4.9% of GDP. This has been the key predictor of economic crises and it is expected to grow further in 2005. Few expect the current account to be as problematic as in the past since Turkey has the growth and means to finance it. But parallel to the bright economic news is the fact that Turkish savings held at home and abroad – estimated to be between $60 billion and $100 billion – are rapidly being converted from dollars and other foreign currencies to new Turkish lira. Coupled with the dollar’s general decline, the YTL is now a favoured currency among Turks. In January, the dollar was trading at between YTL1.3 and YTL1.4, up about 20% from a year earlier.
“That puts pressure on the already overvalued Turkish lira to become even more so, which will make investments in Turkish instruments attractive, but it does add to worries about the current account,” says Metin Ar, CEO of Garanti Securities.
As with the worries about vulnerable small and medium-size enterprises and other points of weakness, the entire EU project for Turkey is not without risk and full membership is by no means guaranteed. External shocks, energy prices, the war in Iraq and the unresolved matter of Cyprus remain on everyone’s minds. As does the fact that Europe’s public, particularly in Austria, France and Germany, are cool about the idea of an EU that includes poor, populous and Muslim Turkey and are growing more so.
In fact, the signing of Turkey’s candidate status itself was not without tense moments. At one point on the long-awaited day in Brussels, Erdogan, who nearly scuttled EU hopes earlier in the year over EU-demanded legal reforms including on a ban on adultery, announced that he was calling off talks and going home.
This time the sticking point was not adultery but Cyprus. Europe’s leaders, led by the holder of the rotating EU presidency, Dutch prime minister Jan Peter Balkanende, were aghast when Erdogan refused to sign a communiqué including Turkey’s recognition of the Greek-run Republic of Cyprus, which entered the EU last year. A launch of formal negotiations with a state refusing to recognize one of the existing 25 members was a diplomatic non-starter. Astute diplomats quickly cobbled together a compromise pact whereby Turkey agreed to “finalize the adaptations which are necessary” by the October 3 start of negotiations. The compromise was enough to keep the Brussels mechanisms working but Cyprus remains a touchy challenge that will need to be fully resolved by October.
And while Turks have celebrated, not all in Europe concur. Europe’s business leaders generally remain supportive of Turkey’s candidacy. But mindful of public polls showing broad apathy to Turkey among voters, increasing numbers of populist politicians have been calling for referendums before its entry – which would almost certainly leave Turkey outside looking in. Among those of this mind are German conservative leader Edmund Stoiber, who expects to be leading his country in 2006, and French finance minister Nicolas Sarkozy, who is lining himself up to succeed president Jacques Chirac in 2007. Shortly after the Turks celebrated their new status in Brussels, Sarkozy reaffirmed that he would try to block Turkish accession. “Turkey is not a part of Europe,” he asserted. “If Turkey was European, we’d know it.”