AS SOUTH AFRICA enters its second post-apartheid decade, the possibility that it will become a high-growth dynamic economy remains in doubt. Without an economic growth rate that soaks up labour surpluses, the republic cannot overcome massive unemployment and the sort of poverty rates that lower confidence among investors about the political future.
The ANC government is on a high – it won the bid to host the football World Cup in 2010, celebrates 10 years of democracy this year, and was re-elected with 70% of the vote in the April general election. A further boost to government confidence is the strength of the rand, which has appreciated by 50% over the past 30 months.
In response to worries that government delivery is not fast enough and that its push for ownership and participation in the economy to reflect racial demographics is also tardy, the ANC is becoming increasingly activist. The worry is that it might view macroeconomic stability as sacrosanct but not take the same view of all free market precepts.
Even on the most optimistic projections, South Africa’s economy will still be relatively modest even if it proves to be the engine of regional growth. By 2050 Goldman Sachs forecasts that it will only be 20% the size of Russia’s.
Goldman points to the Aids epidemic as a damper on population and growth rates. On a 10-year outlook, Goldman found that South Africa would deliver 5% average annual growth “if the right policies were in place” and 3.5% over the next 50 years.
Lagging the labour market Even this may be optimistic, though. The economic growth and job-creation record since 1994 has not been propitious. Average annual growth since 1994 of 2.7% is much better than in the previous decade but is well short of the 6% required to absorb new labour market entrants.
Last year growth was 1.9% and in the budget presented in February the treasury said it expected growth of 2.9% this year and 4% in 2006. Local economists have begun to shave the projection, in part because of the effect on exports of the strong rand.
Investment over the past decade has been sluggish, and during the 1990s was lower than in the 1980s. Net investment has declined from an average of 14.6% of GDP during the 1970s to 2.3% in the early 1990s. Average annual growth in the capital stock has slumped from 5% in the 1970s to 1.3% since 1994.
Because of growing capital intensity of economic activities, even high levels of investment might offer largely jobless growth. The unemployment rate has continued to grow since 1994 and is between 30% and 40% depending on the definition used.
Some economists stress rigid labour markets point to skills shortages as the main cause of this. The government insists that stricter labour laws introduced since the end of apartheid making it harder to fire workers are not the cause of high unemployment. But the IMF has repeatedly pointed to the labour laws as a significant cause, and much of the business community takes a similar view.
What the labour laws have certainly done is close down the chances of South Africa’s becoming a labour-intensive manufacturing base that could compete head on with Asia. Taiwanese clothing factories serving the regional market have located in neighbouring Lesotho rather than South Africa because of lower wages and more business friendly labour laws.
One result of the persistently high level of unemployment is that there have been no substantial inroads into poverty. On top of that, the HIV/Aids epidemic has already greatly exacerbated the difficulties of improving living conditions, and according to actuaries South Africa has some way to go before it feels the full demographic impact. Based on extrapolation from the annual surveys at antenatal clinics, around 20% of adults between the ages of 15 and 49 are HIV positive.
After considerable resistance, the government eventually agreed to the use of anti-retroviral therapies a few months before the elections in April. The roll-out is in its early stages and it will be some time before there is any indication of the impact.
One clear area of success for the government in the past 10 years has been in the provision of housing, electricity, and water. The number of houses built is impressive but mounting concerns are being voiced by housing policy experts about their quality. The move to formal housing is also putting pressure on family budgets because of the burden of water and electricity charges.
Defying what would have been catastrophic conflict and the successful pursuit of Washington Consensus economic policies are necessary but not sufficient conditions for building confidence, delivering services and creating a winning economy.
“The last 10 years were fairly easy for economic policy,” says Goolam Ballim, group economist at Standard Bank. “It is easy to improve fiscal balances when you are the party that delivers freedom and hope.” He continues: “For me South Africans are preoccupied with looking at the foundations. We should ensure the house has a roof.”
There is little doubt that the ANC has indeed laid the foundations of macroeconomic stability. By contrast, the apartheid regime government did not practise fiscal restraint. In the 1992/93 tax year the fiscal deficit was 7.3% of GDP. As a result of restrained spending and improved tax collection, the deficit had been reduced to 1.1% of GDP by 2002/03.
Mainly reflecting a trend towards a marginally more expansive fiscal policy driven by infrastructure spending and social uplift, the Treasury’s latest forecast for the 2003/04 budget deficit is 2.6% of GDP.
Since the adoption of a three-year rolling medium-term expenditure framework in 1998 there have been few surprises in the budget numbers, except a deficit number that is usually lower than expected.
The other dimension of macroeconomic stability has been monetary policy. Since 2000 the Reserve Bank of South Africa, the central bank, has used an inflation target that is set by the government. The rand crisis of 2001 was an important reason it missed its earlier targets but for each of the past 10 months it has met its 3% to 6% CPIX inflation target. Bank watchers believe the central bank will keep rates where they are this year.
Trade liberalization As part of its stabilization, South Africa has also made strides toward embracing globalization through trade liberalization and an easing of exchange controls. Soon after it came to power in 1994 the ANC agreed to import-tariff reductions to levels lower than required by agreement.
The clothing, textiles, and footwear industries were particularly hard hit. Economists have yet to make a final determination on whether the country has benefited from globalization. Some sectors, such as the motor industry, have benefited substantially from better links to global supply networks.
To break down the apartheid era fortress economy the government has pursued a policy of gradual exchange control liberalization. It says it expects that all controls will be eliminated. The financial rand – part of a dual currency system under which foreign investors bought into a pool of currency – was eliminated. The focus of exchange control liberalization has since been on domestic entities.
One reward of Washington Consensus policies has been an investment-grade credit rating. Standard & Poor’s gives South Africa an A on local currency long-term debt with a stable outlook and on foreign currency denominated debt it has a BBB with a stable outlook. Moody’s gives South Africa a Baa2 on foreign currency debt.
However, investment-grade ratings did little to keep the rand from a free fall in late 2001. That year the rand lost nearly 60% of its value against the US dollar. It has since recovered its pre-crisis value but to the detriment of growth and exports.
The consensus among economists is for a slight rand weakening over the year ahead. However, with the closing out of the central bank’s oversold position in the forward foreign exchange markets, a view is taking hold that a new period of stability might lie ahead.
Rand volatility as well as the country’s notoriously high crime rate and small market size have been key factors in deterring inward investment. South Africa has experienced a sizeable inflow of foreign direct investment since 1994 but much of this has financed mergers and acquisitions rather than going into new greenfield job-creating projects.
Inward direct investment has almost been matched by outward investment as South African companies have rushed to take up opportunities offshore. Gold miner Anglo American, SA Breweries (now SAB-Miller) and Investec have transferred their listings from Johannesburg to London.
Auto industry successes One of the largest investors in the country is Canadian miner Placer-Dome. German car manufacturers have also been sizeable investors and have greatly expanded local production, much of which is destined for export. The investment in the car industry has gained a stimulus from the Motor Industry Development Programme. But there is doubt over the future of the programme because of protests from competitors that it breaches World Trade Organization rules.
Also helping the industry is the US Africa Growth and Opportunity Act which gives tariff-free access to selected goods made using South African parts.
There is a sense of frustration among government policymakers that the country has not been rewarded for its prudent policies with investment, jobs, and growth. But had there not been economic stability, the economy might well have done far worse than it has.
Frustrated that investment has not been forthcoming, the government is increasingly resorting to pacts with the private sector on agreed targets and is now intent on using state enterprises to play a larger role in kick-starting the economy.
The question that many in business are now asking is whether the government will increasingly take a far more dirigiste approach.
There is a consensus among business and government that black economic empowerment is a political and economic necessity but there are mounting concerns about the way it is being implemented (see Ways to get the BEEs buzzing). Sweet deals for ownership stakes in some of the country’s largest companies tend to go to a small group of well-connected prominent individuals. This risks a perpetuation of the inequalities of the past, albeit not on racial lines. And the empowerment charters for the mining, financial services, information technology and other industries, which commit firms to a minimum level of black ownership within a certain period, will not necessarily change that.
The government’s new growth strategy lays a heavy stress on massive investments to be undertaken by such state-owned enterprises as transport parastatal Transnet and electricity supply utility Eskom.
The use of state-owned enterprises as vehicles to push investment and growth must raise questions about the privatization programme. Telkom, the state-owned landline telecommunications monopoly, has been privatized but Eskom and Transnet remain as state entities, although largely commercial in their management.
So far there has been no clear statement given on plans for their future, although the government insists its privatization programme is on track.
To boost employment and play a part in poverty relief, the government will be launching an expanded public works programme. Another part of the new growth programme will be to ensure that 5% of funds held by institutional investors are placed in the real economy. In addition, the government is to carry out a study of how to give small businesses a boost.
Despite the government’s mixed record on delivery, the South African electorate has demonstrated patience. There is no party that can come close to competing with the ANC’s liberation struggle credentials and its gift of dignity after apartheid.
Lawrence Schlemmer, a political analyst who heads the Helen Suzman Foundation, expects the continuation of a stable one-party dominant system for at least the next 15 to 20 years. Business, he says, essentially favours this dispensation, which offers predictability and allows the striking of deals, although few expect exceptional growth rates to result.
The benefits of stability There are optimists who believe South Africa is now well positioned, having established macroeconomic stability. “Not a China, but far better than 3% growth,” predicts Rudolf Gouws, chief economist at Rand Merchant Bank.
He argues that the country had first to undo 20 years of irresponsible fiscal and monetary policy and protection of industry before it could achieve higher performance. The balance of payments constraint that used to cut economic upswings short has been eased in two ways. First, through the better macroeconomic balance that flowed from a sharp reduction in the government’s budget deficits. Second, through the access to foreign financial markets after 1994 that followed on the disappearance of financial sanctions. The skills constraint is important but not sufficiently binding to be a hindrance to growth, he argues. Part of the reason for the moderate growth rates is the disappointing level of foreign direct investment in new ventures because South Africa is not in a high growth region.
The South African government, says Nico Czypionka, an independent economist and commentator, has a social vision for transformation to achieve far greater black economic power and participation but it lacks one for boosting economic performance and growth.
Czypionka argues that government should work backwards to establish what is necessary to achieve a 5% to 6% growth rate. He despairs at the absence of entrepreneurial flair, with the heavy domination of the economy by large corporations. To stimulate investment, incentives are urgently required, he says.
South Africa is not a place where businesses feel they have to have a presence, like China, he says. “We will just bubble along, as opposed to forging ahead,” Czypionka believes.