At first glance, every broker that demonstrated its programme trading product appeared to be a contender. All had a complete suite of pre-trade, intra-trade, and post-trade analytic tools, and all the products also appeared to be closely matched in their flexibility.
Despite these similarities, Morgan Stanley wins because it is strong across all areas that Euromoney examined. These included analytics tools across the trading cycle, the quality of algorithmic engines, and the flexibility afforded to users in connectivity. It also covered the ability to specify settlement instructions and to tap alternative liquidity sources, the flexibility of front ends, and client feedback. It isn’t the strongest in every area but it is always one of the strongest.
Morgan Stanley’s pre-trade analytics suite is not the nicest to use but is one of the more sophisticated. The theoretical model used to predict market impact cost is calibrated with real measurements from millions of Morgan Stanley’s own trades that are mapped against contextual historical tick data. This quality of information behind the model is a real strength on its own but additionally the pre trade analytics model considers the “shape” of market impact cost, which changes with speed of execution and with the changing composition of the portfolio as trading is done. Many other models do not come from such an extensive database and give simpler one-number answers to market impact cost predictions.
Morgan Stanley’s real-time intra-trade monitor has the nice touch of allowing users to view the progress of their trade as a heatmap. Its algorithms are among the more sophisticated and customizable and are widely used by clients.
Its platform has also proven itself to be robust and able to handle huge volumes, a fact that is clearly visible by the bank’s share of NYSE programme trading volumes, which is consistently the highest by far.
The bank has also developed a number of front-end graphical user interfaces to cater for different types of users. Its Excel-based program, Trade Excel, has been upgraded and re-branded as Passport Excel and it now also offers a Windows-based system, Passport, as well as web-based versions. This presents users with more options than any other broker.
Lehman’s pre-trade analytics suite is arguably more sophisticated and nicer to use and ITG’s post-trade analytics suite, TCA, is particularly good. They both impress across the categories but Morgan Stanley’s offering in its entirety still has the edge.
PK