Best bank – Bank of America
Best debt house – Citigroup
Best M&A house – Goldman Sachs
Best equity house – Morgan Stanley
Bank of America wins the best US bank award for the second year running. It has maintained the solid track record that has characterized almost all its businesses since 2000. This has helped turn it around from the merger-mania mess it was in at the end of the 1990s. It boasts a formidable treasury services operation, the largest retail franchise in the US, deep relationships with corporates of all sizes, and a number-two ranked syndicated loans business.
Its investment banking arm, Banc of America Securities, has largely maintained the gains made in previous years even as the amount of business fell in the past year. It has been a major underwriter of convertibles in the US, is a top-five underwriter of corporate debt, and had a good year in asset-backed securities underwriting.
BoA is one of the most profitable companies in the US, has a loyal following among institutional investors, and is a proactive risk manager: as just one example, last year it employed an innovative use of credit derivatives to hedge some of its exposure to unsecured credit-card debt.
The best debt house award this year goes to Citigroup. Lehman Brothers and Morgan Stanley both mount strong challenges in the corporate debt markets but Citi’s main competitor across all of bonds, loans, asset-backed securities and short-term debt is JPMorgan. The latter is still top in the US syndicated loans market this year, although its market share has declined, and probably by design. And it is also a strong performer in asset-backed issuance and commercial paper. Citi is not so strong in CP, but its asset-backed division, even stripping out self-issuance, is also powerful.
What makes Citi stand ahead of JPMorgan, though, is its position as the country’s number one bond house. It holds the top spot in investment-grade underwriting, and depending on the time period chosen is usually first, second or third in high-yield bonds. In high-grade bonds its new-issue business outstrips the competition in breadth, depth and size of deals. It also has an enviable fixed-income trading platform and maintains its reputation as one of the best in the secondary market.
There’s little doubt about the winner of best M&A house. In the 12 months since May 2002 Goldman Sachs has worked on 113 deals, more than double the tally of Bear Stearns, its nearest competitor, with a value of $147 billion compared with Bear Stearns’ $82 billion. That equates to a market share of more than 35%, which is 15% more than its nearest rival.
In the past 12 months it has acted as adviser to Household on its sale to HSBC, to Pharmacia on its sale to Pfizer, TRW on its sale to Northrop Grumman and Rational’s sale to IBM.
The equity markets have also been a challenge. The IPO market has been virtually irrelevant in judging a bank’s prowess, and the lack of business there has exposed the cost and infrastructure problems most banks have in equity capital markets. It’s also making most of them desperate for any business at all, leading at times to terrible execution of both secondary offerings of common stock and of convertible bonds.
The lack of primary business has also hit secondary trading volumes, although a combination of corporate malfeasance, distrust of corporate earnings and forecasts, and investor vacillation in the run-up to the invasion of Iraq took their toll as well.
What has been important for winning the equities award this year, therefore, is the ability to demonstrate a vaguely profitable platform, leadership in new issues and trading, research that’s not been completely stymied by New York attorney general Eliot Spitzer’s investigation, and a good platform to offer the only really active investor group, hedge funds.
None of the contenders fit all categories, but Morgan Stanley comes closest. It is, along with Goldman Sachs, the leading prime brokerage house and has some of the best, longest-standing relationships. It now trades more than 90% of cash and options electronically, on a platform it started building nine years ago. Because of that and because it refused to pay up for a market maker in 2000 as Merrill Lynch and Goldman Sachs both did, Morgan Stanley has not had to curtail stocks or options it trades, nor reduced headcount as much. In fact, in the past 24 months it has tripled the number of stocks it trades while most other houses have cut back.
In options trading, it has taken on the options book at the Pacific Exchange from TD Securities, which got in over its head with a poor acquisition last year. Morgan Stanley, on the other hand, claims its electronic trading technology allows it to take on those operations and make money on them.
It’s also one of the first firms to integrate its Nasdaq and New York Stock Exchange trading desks, so all stocks are now traded by sector rather than by exchange.
In capital raising the firm has had a good record in secondary offerings, but it is in convertibles where it stands out. Having been but a bit player for nearly two years, Morgan Stanley is the top underwriter of the past 12 months.
Its franchise reaches across high-grade and high-yield names, small to large issuers, and it has worked on most of the largest deals of the past 12 months, including the Tyco convertible in January and the Wells Fargo deal in April, the two largest deals of the year. And commendably, for a firm that has reappeared so suddenly, it doesn’t appear to have underwritten some of the less spectacular, potentially loss-making deals, such as Yahoo!, Delta or Nextel.