Safeguards for a success story

Juan Ramón Quintás, Chairman of the Spanish Savings Banks Confederation (CECA), talks to Euromoney's Jules Stewart about the effects of the new finance law on the cajas

What is the government aiming to achieve with the new legislation on the cajas? Spain’s cajas have been around for nearly 170 years but it wasn’t until 1977 that they were allowed to compete on an even footing with commercial banks. In the past 25 years they have been steadily gaining market share, while at the same time their presence in the market has prevented the country’s financial system from becoming a monopoly under the two big banks, SCH and BBVA, that dominate the financial services market.

The new law represents a major step forward in making the cajas more market oriented and competitive. One of the most significant initiatives is to limit the presence of public officials on the boards of the cajas. The last law that was introduced on the cajas in 1985 made it possible for political representatives to sit on the boards, but in many cases they accounted for 50% or more of the board members. The new law sets a 50% limit, directly or indirectly, and this safeguards the cajas’ status as private foundations. Moreover, board members cannot be removed by local governments, and they are limited to serving a maximum of two four-year terms of office.

What is the significance of the non-voting shares? One of the reasons for the demise of savings banks in other countries was their inability to comply with more stringent capital requirements. The clearest example of this problem is the case of Italy’s savings banks, which have all but disappeared for lack of sufficient capital to meet these requirements. This is not the case in Spain, where the cajas are achieving 13% growth this year against a backdrop of a stagnant economy. But there could arise a situation in which the cajas might have to raise more capital. In this case, the cuotas participativas, which rank as tier 1 capital, will be a useful capital markets instrument to help avoid future problems.

These shares will be linked to the profitability of each issuing caja, although it is unlikely that they will be in the market in the immediate future. It is still cheaper for the cajas to issue preference shares. But experience shows that while the cajas are slow to launch new initiatives, they quickly gain momentum once the process has been put into motion.

There has been some criticism of these shares precisely because they don’t carry voting rights. This criticism is understandable from a market perspective. These are not the same type of instrument as shares in a bank or a utility. However, this can be offset by a higher yield. In reality, it is not much different from a small shareholder of any bank, who has no voice in how his company is managed. We expect the cuotas participativas to yield a higher premium than ordinary bank shares. Shareholders looking for yield will find them to be an interesting investment prospect. On the other hand, we have set a limit: no investor can hold more than 5% of a caja’s shares. The cuotas participativas will allow us to tap the capital markets while protecting our unique structure as private foundations.

The cajas will be allowed to retain their immunity from takeover, while they are allowed to acquire banks. Is this really a level playing field? This is an erroneous interpretation of the law. It depends how you define the term “acquire”. It generally refers to a company’s assets and staff. Banks can take over a caja’s retail network. All it requires is a vote by the members. But it cannot acquire the brand, because a caja is a foundation that does not pay dividends out of profits.

Why is there so much resistance to privatization? We see ourselves as private-sector institutions. But however you choose to define us, the fact is that we are the greatest success story in the history of Spain’s financial services industry. On that basis, there is little rationale for changing the system. Structural changes are normally introduced for a reason. Public-sector companies are privatized because they are inefficient institutions, or in some cases to eliminate corruption. One can hardly accuse the cajas of inefficiency, and in their entire history there has never been a case of corruption and no member of any management team has ever faced criminal charges.

We continue to gain market share, no caja has ever gone bankrupt, their depositor base is bigger than the banks’ and in the past 25 years their combined assets have grown from e15 billion to more than e500 billion . Frankly, I don’t see any need to change this system.

How far advanced is the project set up lines of credit between European savings banks. ? We are looking at this project as a possible cushion against the possibility of future liquidity risks. The cajas today are not facing any liquidity problems. On the contrary, our net position in the inter-bank market has always been positive. But in this business it is important to look five years down the road. We are therefore discussing the possibility of setting up a reciprocal system of stand-by lines of credit with other European savings banks. This could be done at a minimal cost and it would provide us with a cushion against future market volatility and avoid the risk of any savings bank collapsing for lack of liquidity. As of now, the project is still in the discussion stage with other European savings bank associations, primarily with Germany.