Targeting a troubled sector

After several phases of consolidation, Portuguese banks are facing up to a recession that might provide incentive for acquisitions by foreign banks.

Portugal’s leading banks may soon find themselves fighting a battle for profitability on two fronts. Not only are they suffering from an economic slowdown that has now become a full-blown recession; in addition Lisbon is rife with rumours of an impending assault on the market by one or more major European competitors. The speculation comes in permutations to suit all tastes, but the most widely accepted version points to the Spanish banks.

From a price perspective, this would certainly be the right time to move in on Portuguese banks. For instance, Banco Comercial Português (BCP), the country’s leading private-sector bank, has underperformed the European bank index by 60% since January 1999. As BCP’s chairman and chief executive Jorge Jardim Gonçalves points out [see Focus lies abroad, this issue], banking profitability is heavily dependent on economic trends at home and abroad, and most analysts see little scope for a turnround before next year at the earliest. BCP’s chief strategist, Miguel Namorado Rosa, says benefits to the services sector may filter through in the first half of 2004 from the European football championship being hosted across Portugal. “On a macro level, the public-sector deficit should fall to about 2.4% to 2.6% of GDP this year from 2.7% in 2002.” And there’s always somebody who’s even worse off. He says: “Portugal is not in the same situation as Germany, which is coping with a 3% deficit.”

Portugal’s GDP has contracted for three successive quarters and forecasters have little idea whether the third quarter of this year will bring a further decline or a stabilizing trend. The 2% contraction registered in the first quarter was worse than expected and points to a year-end decline of as much as 1%. There are no signs of a rebound in exports, raising fears of a rise in unemployment and a cutback in industrial spending, with bankruptcies on the upswing. Real wages are contracting, many companies are experiencing balance sheet pain and tax revenue is falling sharply. Consumer confidence is hovering at its lowest level since statistics were first compiled in the mid-1980s. In all, it is not a very encouraging framework for boosting bank profitability.

As a eurozone country, Portugal cannot influence exchange rates to engineer its way out of recession. However, as Manuel Pinho, a member of the executive board at Banco Espírito Santo (BES), notes, there’s a glimmer because this downturn is not as severe as the 1992-93 recession. “The environment is pretty bleak and it’s best to take things one quarter at a time,” he says. “We don’t see any signs of a recovery at this stage, but this recession looks softer than last time around. Credit quality is holding up better, we have maintained costs under control and there is still scope for increasing margins.”

BCP’s Namorado Rosa believes that in overall terms the banking sector has shown an ability to adjust to lower net interest margins. “Cross-selling has been successful, the banks are now strongly capitalized, they have been reducing their headcount and promoting cheaper distribution channels such as internet banking,” he says. “The bad and doubtful debt ratio stands at about 2% and is well covered by provisions, and net interest margins are more or less in line with those of other European banks.”

Moreover, Banco de Portugal has traditionally taken a tougher line than most European central banks on capital requirements. Anticipating the recession’s impact on credit quality, early this year it introduced more stringent rules for credit provisioning, and in particular tougher requirements for specific loan-loss reserves.

“The changes have been well timed, as Portuguese banks are facing an increasingly harsh operating environment that will inevitably heighten delinquencies,” says Elena Iparraguirre, analyst at Standard & Poor’s. The US credit rating agency now views Portuguese banks’ coverage as comfortable, although this coverage results primarily from the accumulation of mandatory general loan-loss reserves during a phase of rapid lending expansion. This category of reserves has grown to constitute about half of the banks’ total loan-loss reserves. “Specific credit provisions, however, still lag behind economic reality, a situation that the new regulation will, to some extent, improve,” says Iparraguirre.

Despite worries about declining profitability, the Portuguese market continues to attract the attention of foreign banks. Indeed, this could be one of its prime attractions, since the market is betting on an upturn in the medium term. Last year ABN Amro surprised the market by taking a 5% stake in BCP, a move that sources close to the Dutch bank were quick to point out does not represent a long-term investment. “It was a strange move for ABN Amro,” says a banker in Lisbon. “They tend to be pretty aggressive players. Perhaps like other foreign investors they took a more positive view when the centre-right government came into power last year. This finally put an end to concerns about measures the socialists wanted to enact, such as a capital gains tax on foreign subsidiaries and relaxation of the banking secrecy laws.”

Although nobody is expecting ABN Amro to launch a takeover bid for BCP or any of the other major Portuguese banks, there appears to be no shortage of foreign predators waiting in the wings, mainly from across the border. This was highlighted recently when Spain’s Banco Popular paid e520 million for BNC, a small retail bank specializing in mortgage lending.

Foreign banks have learnt the hard way that in a small and in many ways an insider market such as Portugal, going it alone can prove to be a recipe for disaster. Chase tried to make a go of it and failed, while Citibank and Deutsche Bank have downsized their operations. Lloyds TSB and Crédit Lyonnais sold their operations to Spain’s Banco Bilbao Vizcaya Argentaria (BBVA), and its latest figures show the Spanish giant still struggling to achieve an acceptable level of profitability.

Takeover rumours Perhaps for that very reason BBVA now finds itself the focus of Portuguese takeover rumours. The Spanish bank’s chairman, Francisco González, unintentionally turned up the heat during a recent visit to Lisbon for talks with central bankers and other government officials. BBVA sources have tried to dismiss as unfounded the press speculation about the Spanish bank testing the water with an eye on expanding its retail network through acquisition.

“BBVA is not happy with its local operations,” says a Portuguese banker. “They have repositioned themselves in Latin America, they are now looking at eurozone banks and Portugal is a natural outlet for them, particularly since their arch-rival, Santander Central Hispano (SCH), has built up a successful business here.”

Santander had been in Portugal since 1993 through its investment banking arm, and three years ago it took a decisive step forward by buying Banco Totta e Açores (BTA) and its mortgage lending subsidiary Crédito Predial Português (CPP), a move that touched off a political outcry. Grupo Totta is now the controlling shareholder of all SCH’s operations in Portugal and has become the country’s fourth-largest private-sector bank. Focusing mainly on its core business of retail banking and bancassurance, Totta managed to hold its net income steady at e60.3 million in the first quarter, although income from investment banking through Banco Santander de Negócios fell by 25.4% in the same period. This was mainly the result of a large non-recurrent operation, the sale of shares in Euronext Lisboa, without which net income in both businesses would have recorded substantial gains.

The last round of consolidation in the Portuguese banking market involved BCP acquiring the family-owned Banco Mello and Banco Pinto & Sotto Mayor (BPSM), one of the Champalimaud family banks. Meanwhile, the family-dominated Banco Espírito Santo came close to negotiating a merger with Banco Português de Investimento (BPI), a group with no family shareholding. In the end the BES-BPI deal collapsed, officially because both sides realized the merger lacked the “special chemistry” needed to make it work – a euphemism interpreted by the market to mean that the two management teams failed to agree terms for power sharing. “The failure of the possible merger with BPI has been fully digested,” says Pinho. “We are focusing on organic growth and selected investments in some overseas markets. Moreover, we have downsized our corporate loan portfolio and diversified our business more towards the retail side. In all, we are cautiously optimistic about the second half of the year. The benefits of cost controls and a prudent lending policy are filtering through, even in this difficult environment.”

Given the Espírito Santo family’s tight control over its bank, BPI is the only takeover target of any significance left in the Portuguese market. The government has dug in its heels against pressure to privatize the giant state savings bank Caixa Geral. And BCP’s stable shareholding plus support from the central bank would render it comfortably immune from any hostile approach.

BPI, according to analyst Philip Smith at Fitch Ratings, has experienced some deterioration in its bad-debt portfolio, but he also notes that the bank’s asset quality is still better than that of other major Portuguese banking groups. Most analysts agree that it is well run and as such would make a tempting acquisition for a foreign bank looking to gain a substantial foothold in the market.

“Despite environment difficulties common to all Portuguese banks, we like BPI’s policies,” says analyst José Luis de Mora at Merrill Lynch. “It has extremely selective lending practices, with a 26% fall in wholesale lending and a focus on mortgages.” He also cites better credit quality trends than rivals, more bearable pension fund liabilities and good cost trends. “In addition, we believe BPI’s valuation is reasonable and it remains a takeover target,” he says.

Complex cross-shareholdings BPI remains conspicuously on the block, particularly since the recent sale by Sonae of its BPI stake to Spanish savings bank La Caixa and Brazil’s Banco Itaú. The bank’s major shareholders are La Caixa and Itaú, each with a 16% stake. Germany’s Allianz has 8.9%, Santander controls 5.2%, BCP 3.9%, and the state savings bank Caixa Geral 3.1%, with the rest in the hands of various industrial groups. BPI’s 10% share of the Portuguese retail market would provide a bank such as BBVA with sufficient critical mass to put it in the same league as its competitors, notably Santander. “It would be a complex deal but it’s certainly within the realm of reality,” says a banker. “One problem is the complex network of cross-shareholdings among the banks. While La Caixa owns 16% of BPI, it also has an 8% stake in Spain’s Banco Sabadell, which in turn has a cross-shareholding with BCP. The links pose a potential conflict of interest. However, a move by BBVA could be good news for the market since they would be in a position to bust the cartel the banks have set up to protect their lucrative mortgage loan business.”

González’s most recent public comments did not do much to allay speculation. He said the European bank consolidation process would “return with a vengeance”. Spanish banks will be in the forefront of this “inevitable”process, because of the lack of opportunities for domestic expansion and worsening economic conditions.

“Portugal might be viewed as a useful offset for BBVA,” says Fitch’s Smith. “There is scope for them to increase their business in Portugal, and looking at what Santander has achieved with Totta it wouldn’t surprise me if they made a move. But there is very little likelihood of a hostile bid.”

Another outcome put forward by some analysts would entail BBVA acquiring one of BCP’s retail branch networks, such as Atlântico, Sotto Mayor or Novo Rede. “This way BBVA would boost its market share from 1% to 5%, which is not the 10% quantum leap they would like to have, but a sufficient platform from which to build the business,” says an analyst.

BPI’s head of group risk, Rui Martins dos Santos, says that in spite of all the speculation since the bust-up with BES, the bank has managed to remain independent and prosper. “It is always easy to sell the idea of a takeover despite the fact that in all these years nothing has happened,” he says. “For us, it’s business as usual. We have a very well defined and focused strategy. We are not involved in any major activities outside Portugal and we are concentrating on organic growth, increasing our efficiency levels and producing simple products for our customers.”

Closer integration of the two Iberian banking systems seems almost inevitable, given recent trends. Spanish banks have been the more aggressive players, but some Portuguese institutions have also expanded in the Spanish market. The boutique investment bank Banco Finantia, for instance, acquired the Spanish broker Inverbolsa two years ago and the bank’s chief executive Antônio Guerreiro is seeking more opportunities across the border. “We are focusing on growing in areas where we are already present,” he says. “We could consider more acquisitions in Spain in asset management or an add-on to our car-financing business. We have allocated almost 20% of our human resources in Spain and we would like to step up the pace of growth in that market.”

BBVA may not be the only predator lurking outside BPI’s door. Barcelona-based savings bank La Caixa is cited as another potential bidder. The rationale for a move by Spain’s third-largest financial institution is the same that led SCH and BBVA into Portugal: the need for geographical diversification away from a mature domestic market. La Caixa is already one of BPI’s core shareholders and market sources say there is an agreement with Banco Itaú for first refusal on any major sale of BPI shares by either party.

The most recent name among possible BPI suitors is Barclays, which has 46 branches in Portugal. Analysts say that because of the returns required by head office, it would make sense either to slash that number by half or take a major step forward by buying significant market share. Barclays’ recent £803 million acquisition of Spain’s Banco Zaragozano catapulted the UK bank into sixth position in Spain and chief executive Matthew Barrett has made no secret of his plans to expand further in key European markets. Barrett stated that he wants to “develop, broaden and deepen” Barclays’ presence in western Europe, particularly in Spain, Portugal and France. Barclays is not commenting on market speculation, but a spokesman says the bank “will not discount any opportunity”.