|
Gref: wants “fewer words and more |
THE OLIGARCHS GRABBED Russia’s industrial jewels in the mid-1990s and almost made billions overnight by exporting natural resources. But following two years of strong growth they are starting to lose out to a new breed of mini-garchs who are running small regional companies that cater to consumers and provide the sorts of goods and services that the Soviet production machine simply ignored.
An example is Kalina, which started life as a typical Soviet operation nestled away in the Urals mountains. It is now an up-and-coming cosmetics firm. Set up during World War II as the Jewel of the Urals – the name of its main factory – to produce soap for soldiers, it was reorganized in the 1960s to produce perfumes and cosmetics.
Kalina became famous in Soviet times for its Troinoi brand of eau de cologne – a favourite tipple for desperate alcoholics during Mikhail Gorbachev’s anti-drinking drive in the 1980s. But over the past four years the company has grown fast, from a small regional player into a serious domestic competitor to multinationals such as Procter & Gamble and Unilever.
Timur Goryaev, the company’s CEO and majority shareholder, is typical of the new breed of mini-garch. Young, self-taught and energetic, he has learnt on the job. Kalina’s sales grew from $84 million in 1999 to $130 million at the end of 2002.
|
View graph. |
||||||
The company has big ambitions; it has already issued two rouble-denominated bonds to fund expansion and paid them back without difficulty. However, foreign investors wanting to tap into the success of Russia’s new companies will find it difficult. Even Kalina, one of the best known of the breed, only plans an international public offering at the earliest next year.
As Russia’s recovery becomes increasingly obvious, the traditional blue chips have already reached a new equilibrium. The handful of oligarchs and their oil and metal companies still dominate the stock market. On the back of recent strong growth the top 12 shares on the RTS (Russian Trading System) index shot up last year, making the market the world’s third-best performer. As the recovery story is now well known the market has only managed a more modest 5.7% rise this year.
The big companies are still growing strongly but the sprightliest are those at the bottom of the economy that cater directly to consumers and are driven by a retail boom and rapidly rising incomes.
New sectors surge ahead
Russia passed a milestone early in 2002 when both the oligarchs’ companies and the new sectors overtook the rest of the economy in productivity growth. By the start of this year the mini-garchs’ companies had started growing faster than those of the oligarchs for the first time.
The fast growth of Russia’s two bread-and-butter sectors is however being held back by the Soviet-era industry that dominates the middle of the economy, constituting an unappetizing filling for what has been dubbed the Soviet sandwich.
The ascendancy of the new companies “is a very significant step for Russia”, says Christof Ruehl, the World Bank’s chief economist for Russia. “It shows how Russia’s economy is shifting towards the production of non-tradeables [such as services]. We are in the weird position where the usual scale of economies has been turned on its head: kiosks are more productive, on a per capita basis, than the big oil companies.”
The two bread-and-butter layers of the economy will ensure that Russia puts in at least the government’s advertised 4.3% growth this year. But some analysts are beginning to argue that because kiosks and the companies in Russia’s newly minted service sector are so badly measured by Goskomstat (the state committee for statistics) Russian growth could end this year much faster than official predictions.
Hidden GDP growth
Economists have been puzzling over a sharp measured fall in investment last year, which many attributed to a change in the tax code. On the ground, businesses seemed to be flourishing. Al Breach, chief economist at Brunswick UBS Warburg, says the missing piece of the puzzle showed up in February.
|
View graph. |
||||||
“Stripping out [the effect of changes to the tax code] all the components of domestic demand were growing very robustly in 2002, just like they had started to in 2001,” Breach says. “This means that in 2001 actual GDP rose by over 5% – our best guess is some 5.2% to 5.5% – rather than the reported 4.3%. In other words, 2002 was the fourth consecutive year of 5%-plus GDP growth, and actually saw a small acceleration compared with [the official results for] 2001,” says Breach. “This year we predict 6.5% growth, not the 4.3% the government believes it can achieve.”
Nevertheless, companies in the middle of the economy are in decline and Russia’s spectacular performance since 1998 is rapidly making life more difficult for them.
Roland Nash, head of research at Renaissance Capital, says: “The increasing cost base and decreasing price competitiveness of Russian manufacturers is inevitable. Wage growth at 20% plus per annum, the rebalancing of energy tariffs and real appreciation of the rouble will inevitably undermine price competitiveness. In the middle of the Soviet sandwich is the dubious processed pink salami of industry struggling with its Soviet-era legacy: automobiles, aeronautics, heavy machinery, defence, textiles, etc. Unable to obtain capital and with market-challenged management, they ramped up production behind the protective barrier of an artificially cheap rouble, and are now cutting output as their competitiveness is squeezed.”
Manufacturers’ costs rose by 35% last year and are taking an increasingly obvious toll on the unreformed companies. For example, while oil companies put in 9% growth last year, most of the other sectors’ growth rates fell. Heavy machinery output grew 2%, textiles output fell 1% despite double-digit growth in sales, and tractor output fell 60% despite record harvests. Growth in light industry – up 20% between 1999 and 2000 – fell by 3.5% last year.
“The old industries geared toward domestic demand are starting to feel the pressure and are dragging the economy down,” says the World Bank’s Ruehl. “Current growth is driven by sectors whose competitiveness has not been significantly affected by the appreciation of the real exchange rate and increased production costs. The role of the dramatic cost increases in wages, domestic energy prices and the real exchange rate since the 1998 crisis [and its impact on domestic industries where the advantage of underutilized capacity existed] appears to have evaporated.”
This slowdown has the government worried, since the middle of the economy is where most people are employed. German Gref, the minister for economic development & trade, has already warned that unemployment is expected to rise to 6.3 million (4.5% of the population) at the end of this year from 5.1 million (3.5%) at the end of 2002.
Riding high on the success of his first economy blueprint for Russia’s recovery, issued in November 2001, in February Gref issued a new plan to meet these challenges, half of which was dedicated to “diversification”, the new buzzword in the corridors of power. Seeming increasingly confident about Russia’s prospects, Gref told an extended cabinet meeting in March that Asian-tiger-style growth of 7% to 8% a year was possible, starting in 2007, provided “there are fewer words and more action”.
Gref said: “To achieve this sort of growth, Russia needs to reform and diversify its economy and achieve sustainable growth. This will be extremely difficult, but within the realms of possibility.”
In the meantime small and medium-size enterprises are set to become the driver of economic growth. A recent study showed that though the number of SMEs had increased by 80,000 to 880,000 over the 18 months up to the middle of last year, their share of GDP increased from 4% to 8.4%.
Worried about Russia’s overdependence on oil, president Vladimir Putin singled out the SMEs for help at the end of 2000 as the easiest and fastest way to provide jobs and income for the Russian people. Taxes on them were slashed or eliminated and regulations were simplified in the Kremlin’s first ever attempt to do something about bureaucratic corruption. As a result smaller companies have boomed.
“The number of SMEs still remains small when compared with the population and other countries but small business growth is double that of the rest of the economy in the first half of last year, so they are closing the gap rapidly,” says Peter Westin, chief economist at Aton in Moscow.
SMEs’ swelling contribution
SMEs in industry have been growing even faster, at three times the rate of the rest of the economy. Westin expects SMEs to double their contribution to the economy again over the next five years. Economists estimate that every percentage point SMEs add to their share of GDP adds about 0.1 points to overall GDP growth, so these companies are expected to add 1.6 points to overall growth in the next five years.
“Competition became a bigger problem for smaller companies than bureaucracy for the first time [in 2001],” said Andrei Dvorkovich, deputy economic development and trade minister, at the start of this year. “Bureaucrats are starting to change their attitudes. Controlling organizations are starting to understand that they can live a different way, that they can follow the spirit of the law and not just the letter.”
All this progress is due to reforms pushed through by the Kremlin at the start of 2002 – SMEs were given a tax break, the regulations governing their activity loosened and a tide of inspectors arriving at companies expecting to be bribed was curbed.
A recent study by Cefir (Russia’s centre for economic and financial research) found that before the reforms 80% of enterprises had to apply for permits or licences, 75% of which have no standing in law. After a deregulation package was pushed through, the number of applications for what were effectively illegal licences fell by a third.
“These reforms may be slow in coming and difficult to implement but they have started to have an impact,” says the World Bank’s Ruehl.
The Cefir study also found that progress was uneven, with most growth in non-productive sectors – such areas as wholesaling, retailing and catering, which comprise 50% of small businesses – and is concentrated in the most progressive dozen regions. Moscow and St Petersburg are well ahead: SMEs account for half the enterprises in St Petersburg, a third of those in the Moscow region and a quarter in Moscow city, where mayor Yuri Luzhkov keeps tight control over the bureaucracy.
In March the Kremlin pushed through a second round of administrative changes that should further reduce regional bureaucrats’ scope to extract bribes.
“It is necessary to delineate powers and stop deceiving the public,” Putin said at the time. “[It is necessary] to say who is responsible for what, and what sources they should use to fill their coffers and fulfil these responsibilities. And if there is something we cannot fulfil, we must openly and honestly say so… There is only one thing people cannot forgive – lying.”
Russia is only at the start of the game. In the more advanced countries of central and eastern Europe, SMEs have been important sources of growth, accounting for half of GDP and employing 90% of the employed population, compared with 10% in Russia.
How do investors tap into all this new dynamism? Not easily – foreign investment is almost exclusively focused on the top slice of the Soviet sandwich (with the exception of the two leading mobile phone companies) where there are plenty of large and relatively well-capitalized companies.
But for foreign investors the overwhelming share-picking criterion is management quality. Corporate governance among the big oil companies has radically improved in the past few years but only local investors feel comfortable buying stocks of small and untested upstarts – if they are traded at all.
Russia was the third best performing stock market in the world last year, but analysts say the days of triple-figure gains are over; returns will fall, but the markets will be a lot more predictable from now on.
The oligarchs’ blue chips at top of the economy already dominated the RTS in 2000 and thanks to the growing enthusiasm for Russian equities have increased their share further. The top three natural resource extractors by themselves have gone from accounting for half of the RTS to three-quarters over the past two years.
Among the companies that constitute the bottom slice of the sandwich, only a few are traded. Only three tapping directly into consumer spending are listed: dairy producer Will-Bill-Dann, brewer Sun Interbrew and GUM, Russia’s biggest department store.
Services are better represented but are exclusively telecoms: the two leading mobile producers VimpelCom and Mobile TeleSystems (MTS), plus a few of the seven new super-regional fixed line operators.
“It is very difficult to get access to any part of the Russian economy other than the export-oriented extraction industries,” says Eric Kraus, head of strategy at Russian investment bank Sovlink. “Investors want to diversify but there is virtually no access to the consumer sector and only limited access to services, other than the phone companies. The top of the economy is still showing upside but the real gains are the vastly undervalued assets in the middle, such as chemical producers, metal works and the like. Many of these are not listed: others are being bought by the oligarchs.”
Kraus says Russia is crying out for listings, but only two companies have floated on the RTS in the past four years – media firm RosBusinessConsulting and pharmacy chain 36.6, which sold 20% of its shares for $14.4 million in January.”36.6 came out so rich that they couldn’t place their shares and it had to try a second time at a lower price,” says James Fenkner, head of strategy at Troika Dialog. “The IPO was good as it shows the economy is going in the right direction, but it is still almost impossible for institutional investors to tap into this part of the economy. Wimm-Bill-Dann has a market capitalization of $3 billion and is priced in relation to its emerging market peers but it is alone – 36.6 is a speck of dust by comparison.”
It could be years before a large number of the dynamic companies come to market but, according to market research company IRG, there are already a few hundred that could debut sooner. At the start of April IRG released its list of “Hot 100” consumer-oriented companies that could float sooner. Kalina’s rouble bonds lifted its profile but IRG says dozens of companies have five times its $130 million 2002 sales.
“There is a very broad expansion of Russian business at the consumer level that is being fuelled by the consumer boom,” says IRG chairman Greg Thain. “They are already growing by 20% to 30% a year. Taken together with the advent of consumer credit, the beginnings of working commercial banking sector and ongoing reform they will be the main driver in Russia’s recovery.
“We already have strong growth, even in this gloomy global context. So what will happen when there is an upturn in the rest of the world?”