Ennio Doris: Mediolanum runs political risks

While Italy’s conventional banks struggle to achieve scale and market share at home and abroad, Ennio Doris continues to steer his Mediolanum organization to greater prominence. Its asset-gathering strategy seems to have paid off. Keeping his sleeping partner, prime minister Silvio Berlusconi, on his side remains one of his biggest headaches.

       
Ennio Doris

Ennio Doris, chief executive of Banca Mediolanum, is by no means a shy and retiring type. For instance, the 61-year-old has starred in his own bank’s television advertisements, filmed on locations ranging from Cornwall to South Africa, selling his company as “the bank built around you”.

Doris says his personal passion is to “take an axe to the petrified forest”, the phrase used by former Italian prime minister Giuliano Amato nearly 10 years ago to describe Italy’s inefficient and antiquated banking sector.

With Italian banks such as Unicredito Italiano, Istituto San Paolo Imi and Banca di Roma struggling to grow and produce strong returns at the same time, Mediolanum has been expanding by 30% a year for the past couple of years and expects to grow by double digits over the next 10.

“We see our funds under management growing by an average of more than 20% a year while our network should grow by at least 10% a year. Of course we will not grow at the 30% and 20% rate of the last two years as those years were marked by a veritable boom [in financial services],” says Doris.

In his offices located in the centre of Milano 3, the Milanese suburb developed by Doris’s business partner, media tycoon and Italy’s prime minister Silvio Berlusconi, Doris says he is especially proud of closing the year with net funds under management rising by 6% to a record e3.4 billion ($3 billion) while assets under management rose by 20% to e21.4 billion.

He even makes the claim, which other fund management groups might challenge, that Mediolanum “is the only Italian and non-Italian institution that can boast an increase in funds under management not only in the fourth quarter but for September”.

In 2001, Mediolanum’s total gross premium rose by 4% to e1.6 billion while mutual funds and managed accounts fell by only 5% to e3.1 billion. At the same time the sales network rose by 8% at end December to 5,585 global financial advisers.

Mediolanum says primary account holders in the period rose by 15% to 714,000 and the company was able to acquire 94,800 new clients during the course of the year.

Doris, whose business celebrates its 20th anniversary this month, decided to launch the firm after working as a financial planner with Fideuram and a stint as a door-to-door salesman. “Two decades ago there were clear and distinct walls between the banking, insurance and fund management sectors. I wanted to smash those walls down by being able to offer clients all the products that they need,” he says.

He feels one of the keys to Mediolanum’s success has been its ability to customize services to clients’ needs and use any tool available to reach and simplify the life of a customer. “A customer can either come to a branch, or use a telephone, television or the internet and if they still do not want to, or cannot, use any of these instruments we will come to them,” says Doris.

Having decided to create a multi-channel financial services company, and with roughly $50,000 in personal savings, Doris knew he needed a strong partner. After reading a lengthy interview and profile of a young Milanese real estate entrepreneur called Silvio Berlusconi he knew he’d found the right person to do business with.

“In the interview Berlusconi said young people with entrepreneurial ideas should not go to Gianni Agnelli or Carlo De Benedetti as these men would not receive them but he would,” Doris recalls.

With the interview in hand, Doris said he had a chance meeting with Berlusconi a month later in Portofino. Knowing that Berlusconi needed fresh funds to finance his nascent television projects, Doris suggested that the financial services company he planned to create would also sell and promote his real estate interests.

Shortly after this encounter, Doris and Berlusconi became equal partners in what was then known as Programma Italia. The equal partnership remains to this day even if Doris and Berlusconi have lowered their respective stakes to 35% each.

       
Doris: wants to replicate Mediolanum all around Europe

Some even argue that Berlusconi might have never become the wealthiest man in Italy without the positive cashflow from Doris’s venture, which has posted ever-increasing profits since its inception.

Doris likes to describe Berlusconi, who holds his stake in Mediolanum through privately held Fininvest group, as a sleeping partner who is content with the value that Mediolanum continues to create each year.

However, increasing pressure on Berlusconi to resolve conflict-of-interest questions related to his role as prime minister, especially as the government begins pushing through pension and tax incentive reforms, is making the sleeping partner a little less sleepy.

Last year, Doris, who has right of first refusal on Berlusconi’s 35% stake, noisily rejected plans by Fininvest to merge Mediolanum into Assicurazioni Generali.

“Fininvest can look at the affair [the merger with Generali] with a different point of view to mine as Fininvest is a family holding and therefore if a 35% stake becomes 5% of something bigger that’s fine for them,” he says. “On a political level it would solve a conflict of interest but from my point of view this is my company, I created it and I want to continue running it and having fun.”

Industry insiders say that Berlusconi had hoped a Generali merger would not only solve his conflict-of-interest problems but at the same time improve the often strained relationship between Fininvest and Mediobanca.

If Berlusconi decided to sell his stake, Doris says he would not hesitate for a moment to exercise his refusal options and might even have a foreign partner take up a part of Fininvest’s 35% stake.

Doris says he has an embarrassment of riches in his choice of potential foreign partners but remains coy about identifying any possible suitor. When asked which foreign groups have already made advances, he limits himself to saying: “If you point a finger at any of the top five financial services groups you will not go far wrong.”

While remaining open to a foreign partner, Doris says that he has had fun running Mediolanum for the past 10 years. “And I want to keep having the same fun for the next 10 years,” he adds.

Doris says his ambition is to make Mediolanum the leading global savings consultant in Europe within five years by recreating the Mediolanum model in all major European countries, including the most interesting eastern European markets.

The firm has already begun its European expansion by making small acquisitions such as Fibanc in Spain, Bankhaus August Lenz&Co in Germany and Gamax Holding in Austria last year and plans to make similar acquisitions this year in France, with future plans for Belgium, the Netherlands and Poland.

“We purposely aim at very small acquisitions because we want to recreate our model that does not exist anywhere else and you have to change mentality and approach and you cannot do that if the company is large,” Doris says.

He calculates that it will take a year and a half of work by Mediolanum to transform each acquisition into a free-standing Mediolanum entity as the company uses its own resources to train people in its own way rather than contend with corporate and cultural clashes.

One of his overriding ambitions today is to exploit Italy’s and Europe’s pension markets as reforms and tax incentives for long-term savings are beginning to be set in place in Germany, France and Italy. For Doris believes, as with much of the industry, that Europe’s ageing population will have no choice but to take care of its retirement in mutual funds and other instruments rather than rely on depleting government coffers.

Italy’s state pension scheme is already running a deficit of e40 billion. “At the moment without pension reforms the government would have to raise the tax rate to 56% from 42% to fund the system as it stands now,” says Doris. “The situation is so bad that if there’s not a real push for an integrated pension scheme, it will be a real disaster.”

While Italy’s labour unions continue to protest against the government pension reform proposals that would give individual employees greater freedom in how they invest their superannuation and private savings, mainstream parties recognize they have no choice other than to approve wide-ranging reforms.

Even former prime minister and chairman of the Democratic Left party Massimo D’Alema pointed out that if Italians do not start investing in supplementary pension schemes the country “will have a generation of impoverished pensioners”.

Last year, Mediolanum was able to sell 700,000 long-term insurance products aimed at pensioners. According to BM banking analyst Federico Salerno, Mediolanum is the company best positioned to exploit Italy’s nascent private pension fund market and unlike almost all of its competitors, except for Bayerische Vita, Mediolanum this year has already been successful in selling private pension products.

One of Mediolanum’s most ambitious projects at the moment is the creation of the Esperia private banking venture with Mediobanca. Esperia, more fondly known as MM, or the two Ms, wants to compete head to head with Goldman Sachs, Merrill Lynch and Credit Suisse for Italy’s extreme rich, those with more than e2.5 million in net worth.

“We looked around all the different private banking groups but we found that Mediobanca had the best name recognition and reputation of any group,” Doris says.

The venture is seen by industry analysts as Mediobanca’s first step to modernizing its operations towards individuals while the project increases the depth of Mediolanum’s retail clientele, which currently ranges from small investors to the relatively affluent middle class.

Doris, who also happens to be a Mediobanca board member, declines to give any indication as to whether Mediolanum and Mediobanca plan to increase their collaboration in other areas, especially considering the banks’ 2% cross shareholding.

Banking analysts in Milan contend that Doris has become somewhat marginalized in the battle between Banca di Roma’s Cesare Geronzi and Unicredito head Alessandro Profumo for control of Mediobanca and that Mediolanum’s position as a Mediobanca partner could be threatened if one or the other banks succeeded in taking it over.

Doris hints that he would not be too displeased if current Lazard vice-chairman Gerardo Bragiotti returned to run Mediobanca, from which he was ousted only a few years back.

Bankers in London say that Bragiotti does not relish the prospect of working under Lazard’s new American boss Bruce Wasserstein and Mediolanum itself recently entered into an offshore venture with Compagnie Monegasque de Banque, the secretive Monte Carlo outfit run by Bragiotti’s father Enrico, the former head of Banca Commerciale Italiana who was forced to flee Italy during the Clean Hands corruption probe in the early 1990s.

“We have always had a good relationship with Gerardo Bragiotti from the time he successfully brought us on the market in the mid-1990s,” says Doris.