Too much too soon?

With asset prices beaten down, private-equity firms see big opportunities to buy now. But are they calling the bottom of the market too soon?

The spokesman at private-equity firm Thomas H Lee says he’s very sorry, but all the general partners are too busy to talk to Euromoney. After not having done a deal for 18 months, they’re now working on two at the same time. Meanwhile, Stephen Schwarzman, CEO and co-founder of the Blackstone Group, speaking from his holiday home in France, is spending less time than he’d hoped by the pool this year because of lengthy telephone negotiations on an impending deal.

       
Stephen
Schwarzman

After a period of near starvation, private-equity firms are coming back to the markets with voracious appetites. Kohlberg Kravis Roberts, Texas Pacific Group or Clayton Dubilier Rice – all have recently completed their first acquisitions for well over a year.

Sitting on the sidelines has been frustrating for them. “Every time we held an investor conference we were saying valuations are just too high,” says William Price, one of three founding partners at Texas Pacific, of his firm’s 18 month-long dry spell.

But now general partners are practically drooling at the wealth of tasty targets seemingly within their grasp. “With the capital markets in the type of disarray we find today, we think there’s going to be a terrific need for private equity to help companies raise money through the sale of divisions,” says Schwarzman, whose firm closed a $6.5 billion fund in July. “This is a pretty unique moment to have a pool of capital.”

Current flavours of the month include dull but safe general industrials – think Jefferson Smurfit, the Irish paper and packaging company, which is being bought by Madison Dearborn for e3.6 billion or Legrand, the French plug and switch maker that Schneider sold to KKR for e5.1 billion. They’re also keen on food and retail firms. Texas Pacific Group led a consortium that, along with Bain Capital Partners, snapped up Burger King for $2.2 billion and UK firm CVC bought car parts retailer Halfords for e674 million in July.

Directory businesses, with their steady cashflow, continue to be particularly popular, as the battle for control of QuestDex, the telephone directory business of near-bankrupt Qwest Communications, shows. Also gaining favour is the financial services sector – insurers, which tend to look like bargains in the wake of a large claim event, but also banks and asset managers.

Once reviled technology companies are currently seeing some interest too. Among funds now taking a second look at the sector is Warburg Pincus, which managed to avoid too much damage the first time around. “We’re spending a lot of time in the technology space, particularly in the communications infrastructure area,” says Charles Kaye, a co-president at the firm. He feels that significant opportunities are to be found in the network management area, particularly as many investors are still bearish. “Everyone has decided that anything to do with the ‘t’ word is somehow terrible,” he says.

Salem Shuchman, a general partner at Apax Partners in New York, agrees that the coming months look set to be a purple patch for private equity. “We think it is possible to find great deals today because the public markets are not open so IPOs aren’t an option, corporate buyers are absent and, from an economic standpoint, it’s far better to buy at this end of the cycle than the other.”

It’s true that in theory today is a great time to be an acquirer with a bulging bank account. Some of the most prolific deal makers of recent years – General Electric, Tyco, Intel, Vivendi – have neither the stock price nor the inclination to sign on the dotted line. Not only have they stopped buying but – under pressure to reduce debt and boost their share price – they’ve started selling instead.

Forced sellers

With trade buyers thin on the ground, the field is wide open for financial buyers. Just over a year ago they didn’t even get a look in when a public company of any size was up for grabs because strategic buyers, with their potential for synergies, could afford to offer more cash. “We are seeing rare opportunities to buy premium assets,” says Kevin Reynolds at Bridgepoint Capital. “Some major corporates need the cash so much that they are prepared to sell the crown jewels.”

       
Charles Kaye

At the same time, debt financing is much more freely available than it was last year. That’s particularly true in Europe, where the high-yield and leveraged-loan markets were less affected by Enron and WorldCom and remain open for business.

But the real trigger for the recent spurt of spending has been the fundamental change in corporate attitudes. “Companies are being forced to ask ‘what is a core business?’ at a time when private-equity firms have a lot of money,” says Jay Allen, head of the European financial sponsors group at Bank of America. And the past few months have seen them welcome approaches from private-equity groups with open arms.

In July, for example, KKR reached an agreement with German conglomerate Siemens to buy seven non-core businesses from it in one fell swoop, for a total consideration of e1.7 billion. The disparate collection of assets included Mannesmann Plastics, Siemens Ceramics and Siemens Metering. Though some of these companies may well have fetched a higher price had they been sold individually, a number were not profitable. By lumping them together, a Siemens spokesman says it sold KKR “a basically profitable package”. In return, Siemens got a quick, clean solution that allowed it to get back to running its core businesses.

Similarly Michel Bon, CEO of France Telecom, must have breathed a sigh of relief when CDC Ixis and Charterhouse Development Capital took over the indebted telecom’s majority stake in broadcasting division Télédiffusion de France. The private-equity consortium paid e1.9 billion for TDF in July.

According to bankers, a significant minority of firms are now becoming sufficiently disillusioned with the public markets to consider selling themselves in their entirety to a financial buyer. The US Sarbanes-Oxley Act, and in particular its requirement that directors certify the veracity of their financial statements, can only help strengthen this inclination. “Over the last three or four weeks, the level of reverse enquiries from CEOs and CFOs has increased hugely,” says the head of financial sponsors at a US investment bank. “They just don’t need the aggravation of being a public company any more.”

Despite having to walk the tightrope of a public due-diligence process, private-equity firms are keen to put their cash to work on these deals. “The best opportunities currently are derived from the public markets and from public companies selling off divisions,” says Chris Finn, managing director at the Carlyle Group in London. “We are working on a couple of transactions that were possible public to privates a year ago but for the fact that shareholders felt the price was not sufficient. Today the argument that private equity is the right way to go is much more compelling.”

Needless to say, investors are keen to see general partners start to do the job they are being so handsomely paid for and invest some money. “We have $1.5 billion invested in private equity. We would have liked that to be larger but many GPs are not drawing down the funds,” says Sheryl Schwartz, managing director of private-equity funds at the New York-based teachers’ retirement fund TIAA-Cref.

       
Salem Shuchman

That’s largely because, throughout 2001, most general partners were too busy picking through the wreckage of their portfolios, deciding what had to be written off and what could be salvaged, to even contemplate buying anything else. This was particularly true for US funds, whose gullibility during the internet bubble produced far more embarrassing losses than those seen in Europe.

Hints of the carnage can be gleaned from results of the bank-owned funds which, unlike the private funds, mark their portfolios to market and have to declare losses. CSFB wrote off $750 million of a $3 billion fund recently while JP Morgan Partners squandered around a billion of a $9 billion portfolio. UBS Capital, the private-equity arm of the swiss bank, reported a Sfr519 million ($347 million) loss for the second quarter of 2002 alone.

It hasn’t helped that the usual exits for private-equity investments are now well and truly blocked. Any theoretical gains cannot converted to actual profits – the IPO market is a lost cause and trade buyers are otherwise occupied. As a result, a few have headed for the emergency exit instead. BC Partners recently sold textile rental company Groupe Elis to Paribas Affaires Industrielles for e1.5 billion for example. “There is still a lot of potential in a company like Elis, I’m very optimistic about its development,” says Amaury Daniel de Seze, CEO of PAI. But secondary buyouts tend to smack of desperation.

Despite their track record of losses and few realizations, though, many funds are sitting on enormous cash piles – the result of a tidal wave of investment into private equity over the past three or four years. “There’s a huge amount of equity capital waiting to be spent and that overhang is not going away,” says Shuchman at Apax.

But is now really the right time for private-equity firms to be out there spending? There’s a real risk that what look like attractively priced assets today could turn out to be hugely overpriced in a year’s time.

Strictly speaking, valuations aren’t significantly down since the beginning of the year. In fact they’re up and down, by 3% or 4% from day to day and sometimes within the same trading session. The bottom of the market could be another 18 months away and not – as the recent flurry of buying might suggest – within easy reach.

Veterans claim that history will repeat itself and this cycle will be no different to previous ones. “Our view is that, having seen this movie before, it’s in the darkest days that the most interesting opportunities can become available,” says Kaye at Warburg Pincus.

“Historically, when buy-out investments are made coming out of a recession, the returns are dramatically higher than at other times in the economic cycle,” responds Blackstone’s Schwarzman. But historically, there has not been so much capital in private-equity funds as there is today – around $125 billion according to one estimate.

Buying opportunities remain scarce in comparison and so any assets put under the hammer are fiercely contested. As Euromoney went to press, there were six groups still in the running to buy the cable television business of Deutsche Telekom and five consortia went through to the second round of bidding for the vitamins and fine chemicals division of Roche.

Some funds have grown so exasperated with the lack of potential targets that they’re handing money back to dismayed limited partners. “Our goal is to have 7% of assets invested in private equity but we’ve never reached that target because we always get money returned to us,” says Chris Wagner, head of alternative assets at the Los Angeles County Employees Retirement Association (LACERA).

Other private-equity funds have responded to the capital glut by concentrating on the largest targets. A premier league of funds has now developed, whose general partners seem to have a hand hovering constantly over the chequebook. Among this group are KKR, Texas Pacific, Clayton Dubilier Rice, Blackstone, Thomas H Lee, Madison Dearborn and Carlyle.

Economies of scale

Clearly, there are advantages to thinking big when buying opportunities are so scarce since it allows more capital to be put to work in a shorter time. There may be other benefits too. “Larger companies are generally the same amount of work to buy, they make more money and are usually considered to be better run and less risky,” says Terry Hughes, head of the European financial sponsors group at Goldman Sachs. “You can also attract better people to run them and it’s easier to exit through the IPO market,” he adds.

       

View graph.

It’s hard not to be sceptical about the type of returns these mega-buyouts will generate though. That’s largely because any deal likely to fetch over e500 million is meticulously choreographed by investment bankers who provide all potential bidders with the same information about the company, thereby drastically reducing any chance of exploiting a proprietary angle. In other words – he who pays, wins.

Some recent deals have been done at eyebrow-raising multiples. The KKR Wendel consortium paid an estimated 8.6 times EBITDA to take over Legrand for instance. “People are cutting margins very fine to the extent that there’s no room for error and we’re going to see some bad decisions getting made,” says a GP at a firm known for taking a particularly prudent approach.

And its telling that some of the most successful funds have so far avoided the mega buy-outs. “If I had to put my money with just one private-equity firm it would be Warburg Pincus,” says a senior M&A banker based in New York. “Those guys are really smart”.

Its philosophy is to keep investments sizes relatively small and invest in tandem with corporate partners – despite having closed a $5.3 billion fund earlier this year. “Our view of the very large buy-out space is that it’s gotten to be very competitive and it can feel at times like you’re simply bidding your rate of return,” says Kaye.

Not all investors are enamoured of size either. “We stay away from the mega funds,” says Daniel Cahill, who is responsible for private-market investments at State Street Global Advisors. “We see more value in the mid market because valuations are more reasonable, there is not so much involvement from investment banks and not so much debt in the deals. You’re looking at multiples of four or five times EBITDA, not seven and up”

Limited partners who invest in more than one big buy-out fund now face the added frustration of seeing firms drive up each others’ prices in the absence of available targets. “We knew that if we invested in Texas Pacific, Thomas H Lee and Blackstone that they would compete against each other,” says LACERA’s Wagner. “But we didn’t think that deals would turn out to be in such short supply.”

The fact that deals are indeed so thin on the ground shows that many sellers are not ready to throw in the towel just yet. It would be comforting to think that the worst is over and that the decline in asset values is close to an end. “The fact that private-equity firms are finding the public markets attractive at these levels could be an indication that we’ve reached some kind of bottom,” says David Thwaite, European equity strategist at BNP Paribas.

But Khuram Chaudhry, European equity strategist at Merrill Lynch says the fact that private-equity investors are piling in is not necessarily a good sign. “There’s been a lot of talk about particular areas of the market bottoming and private investors are a lot more sophisticated than they used to be, but I can’t help but be slightly nervous,” he says. “The areas that are being dredged up, such as technology, still have a lot of question marks over them.”

General partners at private-equity firms are being decidedly guarded about making that call. “I don’t think the bottom is that precise but we’re definitely in the range of being at the bottom,” says Tom Hicks, at Hicks, Muse, Tate&Furst.

Others say there’s no point in even pretending to be able to beat the cycle. “We don’t have to buy something absolutely at the bottom,” says Price at Texas Pacific. “What we need to do is work out if an industry is generally on a rising trend or generally on a declining trend,”

“Trying to call the bottom is a fool’s errand,” says Carl Ferenbach, managing director at Berkshire Partners, a Boston-based buy-out firm. “If you think you’ve bought a good business then hopefully you’re going to be happy in any environment.”

There certainly doesn’t yet seem to be a strong belief among general partners that the market has capitulated. Rather, what’s motivating the current spending spree is the fact that private-equity firms have cash on tap and capacious debt markets at their disposal at a time when limited partners want them to spend and corporates are proffering juicy targets.

Are these good enough reasons to be buying? Probably not. Despite the protestations to the contrary, the most successful private-equity investments have been those made at the right point in the cycle. For all their talk of finding angles and adding value, most funds run an extremely tight ship and don’t have the resources to drastically alter the companies they buy. “Legrand is a high quality, well run company. We have some ideas for areas we would like to improve but we’re not going to be making major changes,” says Ned Gilhuly, managing director Europe for KKR of his recent purchase.

“I don’t want to bite the hand that feeds me but there’s really nothing clever about private equity,” says the head of financial sponsors at an international investment bank. “It’s simply a leveraged bet on a rising market.”

So if it turns out that general partners have jumped the gun by making big investments too soon, losses may be on the way. But then, by now they should be used to that.

Reserve players take to the field

Bill Price at Texas Pacific recalls a conversation he once had with a colleague at another private-equity firm. “He said he wanted to be the Tyco of the financial markets.” recounts Price. “I told him: ‘You have to remember financial buyers are just niche players in the overall M&A markets.'”

Lately, though, it seems private-equity players have been spending more time centre field than on the sidelines. While leveraged buy-outs play a fairly limited role in the US, in Europe this year transactions involving a financial buyer accounted for 13% of all M&A deals, compared with just under 9% for 2001 and 4% for 2000 (see chart on page 84).

The feeding frenzy began in January, when US firm Platinum Equity, which specializes in technology investments, paid e1.5 billion for the European distribution and services operations of French telecom company Alcatel. Then in February a joint bid from CDC Ixis and Charterhouse Development Capital enabled France Telecom to offload its majority stake in Télédiffusion de France for e2 billion.

A steady flow of deals followed, including two for e1.3 billion in May: Cinven’s purchase of National Car Parks and the buy-out of ConAgra Foods Meats Company by an investor group led by Hicks, Muse Tate&Furst.

June and July were particularly busy months, with bids by financial sponsors accounting for 22% of total M&A volume in Europe.

Among the big deals was Clayton Dubilier&Rice’s e946 million take-private of Brake Bros, which supplies chilled and frozen food, as well as an offer, worth e3.4 billion, for Jefferson Smurfitt by Madison Dearborn.

Kohlberg Kravis Roberts dug deep into its pockets in June to bid e5.1 billion for Legrand, an electrical installations firm that Schneider was obliged to sell for anti-trust reasons, in conjunction with Wendel Investissement. A month later, it took seven non-core businesses off Siemens’ hands for a total of e1.7 billion.

Also in July Swedish private-equity firm EQT snapped up Bayer’s fragrance and flavour division, Haarmann&Reimer, for e1.7 billion. CVC bought the high-tension electricity network of Iberdrola for e578 million and Halfords for e674 million. Meanwhile Permira, formerly Schroder Ventures, splashed out an identical sum on Italian yacht builder Ferretti.

Texas Pacific bought Burger King for $2.2 billion from Diageo but is apparently still hungry. Its pending deals include a e1.8 billion offer for troubled state-owned Bankgesellschaft Berlin as well as a e543 million bid for 38% of US Airways.

PIPE dreamers forget past nightmares

Never ones to miss a trick, bankers are busy dreaming up new ways for private-equity firms to spend some of their hoards of cash. Or, rather, they’re resurrecting the old ones.

In the light of a shortage of eligible targets relative to the amount of money available for private transactions, they’re predicting a resurgence in private investments in public equities, or PIPEs. “PIPEs have to grow in the absence of the public markets,” says Harold Bogle, head of the financial sponsors group at CSFB.

But PIPEs have pretty much the worst reputation in the business. During 2000 and 2001, when $80 billion was raised in the private placement market, vast quantities of internet and telecom stock were sold to financial sponsors. Because market valuations were so high, they willingly bought the convertibles, which seemed to represent a chance to get their hands on shares at a bargain price.

Big lending banks were the most persistent purveyors, using PIPEs to rid their balance sheets of large loans to technology companies, which then went bankrupt. One of the biggest losers in this game was Hicks Muse Tate&Furst, which is said to have lost $1 billion on PIPE investments alone.

Private convertibles offer protection

None of this dampens bankers’ current enthusiasm however. “We think this is the dawn of a new era for private equity where you will see a significant amount of activity both in traditional leveraged buyouts and PIPEs,” says Allan Jones, global head of the financial sponsors group at Morgan Stanley. He says sponsors are drawing a distinction between old-style tech and telecom PIPEs and new and potentially very profitable deals in traditional industry sectors.

Bankers are particularly bullish about private convertibles, which account for 44% of the $28 billion-worth of deals done so far this year according to Placement Tracker, a US organization that compiles data on PIPEs.

Private convertibles are a great solution, apparently, for corporates that are dithering over asset disposals. If a CEO is worried about selling low and leaving too much value on the table, he can do a deal with a financial sponsor instead, which enables him to raise some cash by monetizing a stake in the company while holding on to some of the upside potential.

For private-equity funds, a convertible offers protection in situations that might otherwise be too risky to contemplate. Texas Pacific bought a $350 million exchangeable stake in Oxford Health Plans, a US provider of health insurance in 1998 for this reason. William Price, founding partner at TPG, explains. “Oxford was a scary enough turnaround that we wanted some protection,” he says. “We felt we deserved a preferred position given the risk and size of our cheque.”

Limited partners are justifiably wary of these types of transactions, however. They aren’t keen on paying a 5% management fee and a 20% carry to see funds invest in securities that the investors could buy in the public markets themselves.

In response, general partners say that they’ll only consider private convertibles in very specific circumstances, such as a turnround or an acquisition and that they insist on playing a significant role in the company’s life. “We want to be an active and welcome voice on all important policy decisions in keeping with our role as a major investor,” says Carl Ferenbach at Berkshire Partners. “Liquid should flow both ways in a PIPE.”

With alternative financing options so limited, corporates have little option today but to agree.