Pressure for democracy gains ground

Businessmen are joining Kazakhstan's democracy movement as independent economic activity hits a ceiling.

       
Nursultan
Nazarbayev

Smoke signals of political trouble for Kazakhstan’s nascent democracy rose over the offices of daily newspaper Respublika this May after unknown assailants tossed Molotov cocktails through its windows.

No-one was caught but few doubt what was behind the act of vandalism: Respublika is one of Kazakhstan’s more liberal papers and had been outspoken in its criticism of the president and the corruption rife in the country.

Kazakhstan is booming for the first time in its decade-long history but the young republic’s economic success is stoking a fire under businessmen and politicians for political change.

“The presidential clan’s grip on the country has grown to the point where there is no independent economic activity and big business was starting to bang its head against the ceiling,” says Martha Olcott, a senior analyst at the Carnegie Endowment and author of Kazakhstan: Unfulfilled Promise. “These people need real economic and political reform if they are going to make more money.”

The country reached a crossroads in November when senior politicians – still in the administration – set up Democratic Choice of Kazakhstan, an alliance of various political and economic interests, to lobby the president to loosen his grip.

President Nursultan Nazarbayev responded by sacking the rebels and began a crackdown to shore up his power. The media have been harassed, a new law on political parties makes it almost impossible for new parties to register and increasingly vocal opposition leaders have been thrown into jail.

“It is often the case with long-standing leaders: people from his [Nazarbayev’s] intimate circle are gaining power and power is blatantly concentrated in the hands of the presidential family. It all smacks of Suharto’s Indonesia,” says a banker.

Nazarbayev’s daughter, Dariga, is believed to control the state media company, a son-in-law runs the national pipeline monopoly, another runs the Olympic committee, and those close to the president prosper.

“It is as if the ministers don’t count for anything any more,” says another local businessman. “The presidential circle are the only people with any real power.”

Prime minister Imanghali Tasmaghambetov admitted to parliament in April that $1 billion of public money – earned from the 1996 sale of a 20% stake in the vast Tengiz oilfield to Chevron – had been deposited in the president’s personal Swiss bank account.

National Bank of Kazakhstan (NBK) governor Grigory Marchenko follows the government line that this unorthodox transaction “was absolutely the right thing to do from the economic point of view” although he remains silent on the political and ethical aspects.

Marchenko says that $880 million of the money was later used to bail out the budget in the wake of Russia’s 1998 financial blowout. The remainder has been transferred to the National Fund of Kazakhstan, managed by the NBK.

Observers speculate that Nazarbayev is for the first time in serious political trouble, as the opposition has reached critical mass.

Democratic Choice is calling for more parliamentary power, reform of the judiciary, and elections for the oblast and regional administrators’ posts, which are currently appointed by the president.

“During the 1990s Nazarbayev was making progress – there was some decentralization, more power to the Duma and liberals were given a free hand with things like financial reform,” says Olcott. “Now he is backtracking and more senior people are getting frustrated. The recent economic success has been the trigger.”

The movement’s leaders have always said that they don’t oppose the president personally, just that they want to move Kazakhstan towards a more democratic system – as the president has repeatedly promised in the past. However, the movement’s first rally this spring provoked a rapid and harsh response from the state. Many of the most prominent of Democratic Choice’s leaders have been arrested and jailed.

By the end of March criminal investigations had been opened against three of the most prominent members. The first to go was former industry, energy&trade minister Mukhtar Abliyazov, who was arrested on March 27. The next day Ghalymzhan Zhaqiyanov, the former Pavlodar regional governor and one of the founding members of Democratic Choice, fled into the European embassies’ diplomatic compound to escape arrest.

A week of bargaining followed before Zhaqiyanov was handed over after French diplomats were promised that he would be held under house arrest in Almaty. Instead a military aircraft promptly flew him to Pavlodar in the far north of the country. He lost consciousness during a 12-hour interrogation session and was hospitalized. Kazakh authorities claim he has heart problems but his own doctor has been denied access.

At the start of July Abliyazov was sentenced to six years’ imprisonment and fined $3.6 million for abuse of office and corruption.

The third high-profile member of Democratic Choice, former prime minister Akezhan Kazhegeldin, who floats between Europe and the US in self-imposed exile, has been sentenced to six years’ imprisonment in absentia.

As his colleagues were being grabbed in Almaty, Kazhegeldin tried to rally the international community, without much luck. Following the September 11 attacks, the US has been reluctant to stir up what could be a hornet’s nest.

Allies become mildly upset

On the party’s internet site, www.forumkz.org, Kazhegeldin listed a three-point plan for forcing democratic change in Kazakhstan: a rejection of all cooperation with the present leadership, whose aim, he said, is to retain unlimited power for an unlimited period; mobilizing the population to pass a new constitution that transfers more power to parliament; and the creation of a “People’s Oil Front”, to stop the embezzlement by politicians of Kazakhstan’s oil wealth.

The movement scathingly points out that Kazhegeldin is the only high-level politician to have been charged with corruption in the newly minted republic’s 10-year history and the prosecutor’s office regularly ignores documentary evidence of corruption among serving government officials.

It adds that criminal charges were brought against the three men only immediately after they resigned, or were dismissed, from influential positions and declared their opposition to the ruling regime.

All this fuss has unsettled foreigners, who are trying to cosy up to Kazakhstan as an ally in the fight against terrorism in nearby Afghanistan. The Americans are concerned about instability in the region and are trying to build a major new oil pipeline connecting the Caspian with Turkey that will enable the US to tap the region’s huge oil resources.

US State Department spokesman Richard Boucher told a press briefing in Washington on 18 July that “we’re increasingly concerned” about recent developments in Kazakhstan, including the new “restrictive” law on political parties. He said harassment of opposition figures posed “a serious threat to the democratic process”, and that Washington would like to see the Kazakh authorities reverse the current “anti-democratic trend”.

The president is in no mood to suffer dissent and emboldened with both the economic upswing and the US presence he is feeling self-assured. Over the past year the government attitude to foreign investors has become distinctly more prickly.

“With petrodollars flooding in the sentiment is increasingly: why do we need foreign investment at all? Let’s do it ourselves,” says Andrew Rearick, an analyst with Golden Eagle services.

New investment laws are imposing increasingly stringent requirements on foreign companies: there is a quota for the number of expatriates that each company can bring to Kazakhstan and the requirements to source inputs locally are becoming ever tighter. Oil companies are largely exempt as the republic still needs their expertise and cash to develop new finds.

Olcott says: “It is not clear what will happen next. Democratic Choice is not unified and many members have gone back into government but there is a possibility that Nazarbayev will be forced out. Kazakhstan’s future is in the balance.”