Asset management: UBS gets a facelift

Two years ago the asset management division of UBS was facing an uncertain future. With figureheads Gary Brinson and Tony Dye gone it was time for new faces to take the lead. As value investing has come back into favour, performance has turned around and now UBS has done the logical thing, uniting the operation under one banner. Where next for UBS Global Asset Management?

One of the least surprising announcements of recent times has been UBS’s decision to bring its asset management division under one name.

The arrival of UBS Global Asset Management, which becomes official next month, heralds the end of two of the biggest investment names on either side of the Atlantic: Brinson in North America and Phillips&Drew in the UK.

Given the regard in which both brands are held in their respective markets (even taking into account the problems of the mid to late 1990s), it is not a decision UBS has taken lightly. Brinson has been a powerhouse name in investing since the 1980s when Gary Brinson led a management buyout of First Chicago and gave the business his own name. P&D, for its part is one of longest-standing City institutions. Spun out from the old stockbroking firm, PDFM rose to become the pre-eminent investment house in London, sewing up a huge percentage of the pension fund market.

Although both brands suffered from their conviction that markets were overvalued in the mid-1990s, clients were loath to sack them because of their long-term track record and their managers’ faith in their views. In the end for some, however, the pain became too hard to bear.

However those clients are starting to come back. As Paul Yates, the head of the UK region for UBS, points out: “We are looking at old clients because we genuinely left them on good terms. They didn’t feel what we were doing was wrong, they just thought performance was too difficult to bear.”

Now if they do sign up with the firm again they will do so to the UBS global operation rather than P&D. However, Jeff Diermeier, managing director and chief investment officer, says the name change does not affect the way the business is run.

“We’ve really been operating for the last several years as one entity but from a branding standpoint we had a couple of different faces,” he says. “So this simplifies things, while it also reinforces the relationship with UBS which is very important to us as well.”

Certainly it was on the cards once new chief executive John Fraser took over following Peter Wuffli’s promotion to president of UBS group, of which more later. Fraser stated that a universal brand was necessary to complete the integration of the business, which includes the original UBS Asset Management in Zurich as well as investment centres in Australia and Japan. “It would be silly of us not to continue our coming together as a global firm and to try to do it without having one brand,” said Fraser.

However Diermeier says there was a need to be sensitive to clients’ concerns and not rush things through. “A lot of clients go back a long time and there’s no question that if we had done something like this two years ago it would have been more of an issue,” he says. “There’s no change in investment philosophy or style and people are comfortable with that but you never want to take a client’s opinion for granted.”

If all the messages coming out of the UBS camp today are positive, that’s quite a change from 2000. The group admitted that year that it had lost £13 billion of assets under management in just the first quarter. There were high-profile client defections in the shape of Calpers, which took $1 billion from Brinson, and the Strathclyde pension fund in the UK, which removed £750 million from P&D.

Wuffli had difficult decisions to make and it was surely not coincidental that Tony Dye and Gary Brinson both moved on that year.

However, industry observers say it was not absolutely cut and dried that they would leave, though the timing seemed quite opportune. “I wouldn’t necessarily say that they both had to leave,” says a leading investment consultant in London. “Gary Brinson was probably looking for an opportunity to retire anyway. He had made all the money he wanted to make, and probably a lot more besides. So I took it on face value when he said he wanted to spend his time investing for charity.”

He does add that the integration of the businesses was probably easier without these strong characters, particularly Dye in London. “The more strong opinions there are in the room, the less likely you are to be able to sort things out,” says the consultant.

Forces for change
However, with Dye and Brinson gone, it was up to others to take the lead. One of the prime forces for change was Tom Madsen, managing director and head of equities, who arrived from JP Morgan Investment Management.

As one former P&D source says of his arrival: “He didn’t mince his words when he came in. He started shaking the place up right from day one and wasn’t afraid to do some pretty straight talking.” Madsen brought an outsider’s fresh approach. “He doesn’t really fit the mould. He’s in your face whereas others at Brinson and P&D are not really like that,” a P&D source said back in 2000.

However, Madsen was not a complete stranger to senior figures in the firm. He and Diermeier have long been friends. “Even before the combination was determined, we had been talking to Tom about coming in to the equity role,” says Diermeier. “Knowing, in discussion with Gary Brinson, that I would be moving into the chief investment officer role not far off in the future, with the idea that Tom would be head of the equity operation.”

Bringing in an outsider was important, says Diermeier. “We wanted to bring in someone from outside the firm who would bring it together where the stresses would be greatest.”

Madsen says he was certain of his role and responsibilities, which made his job easier. “When I joined it was crystal clear what my mandate was and how I would do it. There was no mystery. I had conversations with Jeff, with Peter Wuffli, with Gary Brinson.”

If Madsen was the catalyst for change, Diermeier provides the link between the new-look UBS and the old operation in that he was a close colleague of Brinson and still keeps in close contact with his former boss. He says of him: “He’s very relaxed. He’s looking after his foundation and he’s getting his golf handicap down.”

Dye meanwhile has plunged back into the hurly-burly of running a business, launching a hedge fund called Dye Asset Management.

But despite the departure of the two stalwarts, Diermeier says the firm is still well stocked with investment brains. “When you have an organization with 460 investment professionals, we really haven’t changed that much in terms of the intellectual quality of the organization,” he says.

He is particularly happy about the fact that the firm has avoided any significant walkout of staff as a result of the changes. “There was speculation last year that a lot of the old Brinson alumni would be moving on because of the belief that the end of the payments that emanated from the Swiss Bank Corporation purchase of Brinson would somehow cause people to say ‘well that whole era’s over, we’re leaving’,” says Diermeier. “Considering that almost half the staff were expected to walk out of the door the personnel turnover has been extremely light.”

The recent turnround in performance has helped to maintain morale, he says, adding that he believes the firm has a unique global investment platform that keeps staff interested in working there.

Sector-focused research
Madsen says that in creating a global platform although sticking to the investment philosophy has been critical he has introduced some significant changes. He introduced the idea of analysts managing money and also reorganized the research team along global and sectoral rather than regional lines. 

More and more we felt it was important, in terms of how much a stock price moves to consider what a company does as opposed to where it is based,” says Madsen. “So when we measure analysts, their performance for the year is a combination of how they do in their local portfolios and the global portfolios together.”

But if every investment firm makes a claim to be global, Madsen is certain of his team’s right to the boast. “Everybody says they’re global but I would say that you can have a global measurement and a global reward system for analysts,” he says. That’s a proof statement that you really are global.”

Diermeier adds that the business has a good record of pioneering in global investing as his old firm of First Chicago, before it became Brinson following the management buyout, and Madsen’s old house of JP Morgan were the first two US houses to start up in London.

On top of that UBS has set up common systems across its various offices. These include a proprietary risk system that was developed in Chicago but has since been rolled out to the other offices. There is also a portfolio management tool, called Summit, that enables managers to compare portfolios, for example the global equity portfolio with the global research portfolio. A web-based system called Pedestal was introduced for disseminating research recommendations.

“We wanted to impress on people how important research is and so we’ve put it on a pedestal,” says Diermeier. “Sometimes you have to do corny things to get a point across.” The system is designed to encourage the exchange of research information. If a US analyst is going to a meeting with one of their companies, an analyst in Tokyo can put forward a question they would like answered.

“It’s a live tool,” says Madsen. “You can screen it for any updated opinions on any particular stock.” This proved helpful in the wake of the September 11 attacks, he says. “For instance the Swiss and Germans really hit their reinsurance stocks much more than the Americans did, for whatever reasons, given that they were all insuring the same things. And so what we did was we sold the US and we bought the Swiss and Germans.”

Madsen adds that simply looking at the European stocks or the US in isolation would not have enabled them to do that.

“Maybe we beat this global term to death but our chief investment officer is in Chicago, the CEO is in Zurich, we have this big office here in London, the head of equities is in London,” says Madsen. “From that standpoint we’re pretty global.”

This is being reflected in the upturn in performance, say the UBS head. “Portfolio performance has been really quite extraordinary, more than we would ever have reasoned,” says Diermeier. “In 2001 we had the second best year in the history of our firm since its origination. Almost all of our funds are beyond their prior high-water marks.”

However, they have yet to impress all parties. One influential consultant in London says things have to be set in the context of the market changes over the past two years, with value stocks coming back into fashion “The changes coincided when their style of management came back into favour,” he says. “Value stocks started outperforming from March 2000 and it is hard to disentangle what is going on there underneath that.”

Indeed Fraser himself has conceded that the collapse of the market with the bursting of the technology bubble helped the firm’s value approach to investing. But he has been keen to stress that UBS has outperformed other value managers in this period. This is a point that both Diermeier and Madsen also underline.

Madsen also says that it is unfair to categorize UBS as simply a value investor. “If it wasn’t for a process of marketing and people understanding what we’re doing, we wouldn’t care what they call the stocks in our portfolio: growth stocks, value stocks, left stocks, right stocks,” he says. “If in our analysis they look cheap, on a price/intrinsic value basis, it really doesn’t matter to us, as long as they give our clients extra returns.”

Fraser who?


John Fraser might not have been the first name that market players would have thought of in trying to spot a successor to Peter Wuffli as head of asset management for UBS. 

Fraser himself freely admitted that he was the continuity candidate to run asset management, having previously, as COO of asset management, been in charge of developing the Asia-Pacific operations.

But Diermeier, who describes Fraser as no-nonsense and straightforward, says he has the support of all his investment professionals.

Wuffli moved upstairs in December to replace outgoing bank president Luqman Arnold, following his ousting by Marcel Ospel. Indeed Wuffli himself was something of a surprise choice to the outside world but his promotion will give his former asset management colleagues access to an ear at the very highest level of the group.

“Obviously it will be positive for us to have Peter as president of the group executive board,” says Diermeier. “So that works very nicely and the ability for us to have good relationships with other parts of UBS can only be enhanced by Peter’s presence in that role.”

Indeed while UBSGAM has an external challenge to develop the business in the highly competitive fund management world, it also has an internal challenge to raise its own status. At the moment it comes some way behind the private-client business in terms of assets under management. This is something that Diermeier and Madsen acknowledge as one of their aims, though they point out that internal relationships are very strong.

While the repercussions of September 11 shook already jittery global markets up, there has been another, possibly more significant event for investment houses to deal with: the collapse of Enron and the revelations of book-cooking in US corporates.

Diermeier says it was almost inevitable that the market would produce a story like this. “The combination of an elongated bull market, the use of options and other types of incentive compensation for senior management, the addition of academic work that showed there was an opportunity to pick stocks on the basis of earnings surprise all came together,” says Diermeier. “It created an environment where investors were encouraging and giving great incentives to senior management to always try to beat the numbers, even if by a penny, so as to avoid the dreaded shortfall.”

He adds that fund managers must take some of the blame. “So all of these things came together and unfortunately I’m disappointed in my own profession for being part of the problem, although I think here we tried to deal with it a little better.”

Diermeier says things have to change. “It’s foolish to force companies, or for the companies to allow themselves to end up with promises that they can’t deliver on,” he says. “For a while we had many companies come through here and they were all going to grow at 15%. That 15% became the number of the day. It didn’t make any difference how strong the intrinsic growth rate would be but somehow the promises got to a point where they were unsustainable and that is not appropriate behaviour on the part of the leadership of corporations.”

The onus will be on corporate management to be more realistic in their ambitions. “It is not the job of the leadership of corporations to maximize their share price at each and every moment. Their job is to try to maximize it over a long period of time that is truly reflective of the earning power of the company.”

UBS has been able to avoid serious mistakes through its rigorous approach to valuing stocks, says Diermeier. “Our focus is on what cashflow the company can generate, look through a lot of these accounting issues and try to come from a more simplistic standpoint to what is their cash generation ability, what is their ability to compete, what can they eventually give back to shareholders on a longer-term basis,” he says. “As a result of that we would naturally steer away from companies that we thought were engaging in more aggressive accounting. So we had a natural advantage and that has helped us here.”

However, the firm is taking a strong line on its future dealings with companies. “We’ve talked to our people about this and we want them to make sure they tell the industry that this should not be about over-exaggerated promises or any encouragement to use accounting-type techniques to make numbers when that is not reflective of reality or the truth of what is going on in an organization.”

Diermeier says it will not be easy to clear things up. “It’s a really difficult problem and it’s had a long time to gestate. As a result it’s not going to be a simple problem that’s going to go away with just a couple of companies,” he says. “It will be with us for a while.”

He says UBS expected something like this could happen, although maybe not on the scale of Enron. “With the bubble unwinding, we thought that this would be part of the process,” says Diermeier. “The bubble helped to generate some those expectations. The notion that certain things being off balance sheet that looked to be more speculation as opposed to hedges is not something that we would have anticipated.”

“It’s really important the accounting profession go back to accounting theory in terms of what their main purpose is, as opposed to checking a bunch of boxes and thinking the job’s done.”

So compared with the model of two years ago, the investment operation at UBS of today feels itself to be in the rudest of health. Not least it feels it has been able to avoid the pitfalls of mergers encountered by some of its competitors.”If you look at it objectively the mergers we had worked out pretty well, whereas with some other financial firms, they haven’t,” says Madsen.

London chief Yates is also very positive about how the changes have been carried out. “Many consultants are surprised by how quickly we put things into place,” he says, adding that this is translating into new business opportunities. “The number of presentations and RFPs has ticked up through the year. I want us to be on shortlists, to give us a chance. We are very hungry for business and we have capacity.”

A hard struggle

Not everyone is yet convinced. Not least some of the investment consultants who act as gatekeepers for nearly all institutional money management mandates. “They do still have plenty of good people left in the business but it won’t be easy for them to reclaim the position they had,” says one London consultant.

“They still concentrate on value equities although they seem to be starting to launch other products as well now,” he adds. “They are trying to become a diversified multi-product firm. That is fair enough because most of their money is still in value equities and having been through that performance cycle once they don’t want to get into another one.”

This will be the challenge for the firm. It must fully cast of the shadow of its performance slump in the 1990s and offloading the two investment chiefs, Brinson and Dye, who were most closely associated with that, is not the simple solution to that problem.

However under Fraser UBS is investing heavily in expansion into Asia, particularly China.

Fraser has spoken of the need for long-term investment and this started with the signing of a joint venture deal with Guotai Securities in Shanghai. China will continue to grow in significance if Japan continues to disappoint with its laggardliness in creating opportunity for outside investment houses.

Diermeier is upbeat about his unified investment team, calling it the best he has ever been associated with. “Our ambition is to be the best investment manager in the world, with the best performance,” he adds. “And performance is a function of several things. It’s returns relative to the active risk that you’re taking but it’s not just numbers, it involves client service.”

As the market continues to argue over who is the top investment house, UBS says this cannot simply be measured by assets under management but by overall quality. Certainly if Madsen’s determination can be translated into results it will be there challenging for the top. As he says, with a fierce look in his eyes: “We’re not shooting for second place.”