Japan’s securitization boom keeps specialist lawyers busy

US and UK law firms are collaborating and competing with domestic peers to reap the benefits of the Japanese securitization boom.

Japanese securitization volume has continued to grow rapidly as restructuring of the financial and corporate sectors has assumed ever greater urgency.

This is good news for the few Tokyo-based law firms that have established track records in the speciality. Securitization, and structured finance in general, has been one of the few guaranteed fee-earners in recent months, driven by collateralized debt obligation (CDO) issuance (balance sheet and synthetic) and residential mortgage-backed and commercial mortgage-backed securitizations (RMBS and CMBS). The issuance of more traditional asset types will, according to Fitch Ratings, most probably remain steady, or enjoy modest growth. Additional activity for this year is predicted from the Japanese banks which, seeking to manage their risk exposure, are expected to launch synthetic CDO transactions.

Clifford Chance, one of the leading securitization/structured finance law firms in Tokyo, has been advising on major deals including acting for Morgan Stanley on the first securitization-backed acquisition financing in Japan by Aiful Corporation of Life Co earlier this year (including a US offering of the underlying receivables), and advising Commerzbank Securities as arranger of a securitization of consumer finance receivables originated by Sanwa Finance.

Christopher Lewis, structured finance partner with US firm Orrick Herrington&Sutcliffe, says: “The whole structured finance market has definitely been continuing to grow in line with our expectations. However, one of the developments that I did not foresee – and nor did many of the international bankers out here – was the speed of development of the domestic securitization market. Of course, the major foreign institutions still continue to be heavily involved, but there has been a marked growth in domestic issuance.”

Until recently, the Japanese securitization market was largely the preserve of the major commercial and investment banks, with the largest insurance companies as the principal investors. More recently, however, smaller regional banks and credit unions have been making significant investments.

The possibility of plugging into a rich and fast-growing source of domestic work is one of the real attractions for foreign law firms in the Japanese market. It meshes with the spate of joint ventures set up between foreign law firms and Japanese counterparts. Since this approach was first approved, at least 21 such ventures have been set up, including more than 10 in 2001 alone. Clifford Chance and Orrick are among the firms to have tied up these deals (with, respectively, Tanaka Akita&Nakagawa and Sho Kokusai Law Office).

Several local players have also established impressive reputations. Frontrunners include Mori Sogo, Nagashima Ohno&Tsunematsu, Nishimura&Partners, Atsumi&Usui and Mitsui, Yasuda, Wani&Maeda. Amendments to the law, including the investment trust law, have enabled rapid growth in the domestic ABS market. Japanese synthetic structures are gaining in popularity, and last year the first synthetic CDO with purely Japanese reference entities was issued. At the same time, the first two J-REITs (Japan real estate investment trusts) were launched.

Where cross-border structured finance deals are concerned, law firms in Tokyo typically need to be able to field US law capability, and this favours the larger international and US law firms in town. US law capability is also important in the fast-growing consumer finance loan securitization sector, where some US techniques are being imported. In 2001, according to estimates from Fitch, total public issues in this sector reached ¥600 billion, up from less than ¥200 billion the previous year.

Orrick is well placed to take advantage of these trends. Already, reports Lewis, the firm has been busy advising ING Barings which has itself been active on consumer loan deals making use of master trust structures via techniques imported from the US. Lewis reports important developments in this sector – in particular, listed, investment-grade consumer finance companies are increasingly prepared to view securitization as an acceptable means of diversifying funding sources. “Japanese consumer loan receivables are an asset class ripe for securitization,” he says. “The industry is growing and is being forced to diversify its funding sources, while the high level of profitability means that it is able to bear the considerable front-end cost of establishing securitization programmes.”

Another significant new development in 2001 was the use of securitization as an exit strategy for a bankrupt company. This was the Life deal where Clifford Chance advised Morgan Stanley. In May 2000, Life, one of Japan’s largest instalment sales companies, filed for protection under the corporate reorganization law. Last October, it successfully securitized a large share of its assets including trust beneficial certificates worth ¥245 billion. This included a Regulation S/Rule 144A listed rated securitization by Life Funding Company of the underlying consumer receivables. On the proceeds of the deal, Life was able to exit the rehabilitation process.

All the top-rank international securitization firms in Tokyo can already draw on US law resources, and beefing these up may become a priority. For example, late last year Linklaters’ Tokyo office hired its second US securitization partner. Mark Hunsaker left Sullivan&Cromwell’s Tokyo office, where he had been based since 1997, to join Linklaters. It is not just US law expertise that matters – as deal flow escalates many of the major firms are drafting in reinforcements.

Allen&Overy recently sent out securitization partner David Shearer from London to bolster the firm’s Asian structured real estate finance capability. Simmons&Simmons, another rated securitization firm (with a joint venture in place with TMI Associates), has relocated its Japanese asset-backed practice from Hong Kong to Tokyo, moving new partner Paul Browne and two assistants to Japan.