Garbi makes his wishes clear

Nearly six months ago, the MTS bond markets were offered a shortlist of clearing houses. It should be a simple choice between the London Clearing House and Clearnet but the process is dragging on. The cause of this delay may be that Gianluca Garbi, CEO of EuroMTS, is trying to force decisions in Clearnet’s favour.

       
Gianluca Garbi: ‘My mission is to
do the best for the market’

“This is a very personal issue for Garbi,” whispers one market observer, who does not wish to be named. “EuroMTS is his personal fiefdom. The idea of sharing power with a clearing house is one that he just couldn’t stomach.”

This is not the sort of language normally associated with clearing – the essential but unglamorous plumbing that makes liquid markets work. But it has recently become a more exciting issue. Put simply, bonds that trade in a cleared environment trade better. So when the successful electronic bond trading platform EuroMTS announced that it was going to introduce clearing for its national markets, brokers welcomed the news.

Few could have predicted that this simple choice would become contentious. Now the debate seems to be pitting big bank against small, or even, if you believe the hype, Europe against the US. Gianluca Garbi, CEO of EuroMTS, says that it could transform the European clearing industry, bringing the consolidation that the market has waited for.

The key to that, for him, is that Clearnet must win the mandates for the national MTS markets that are yet to decide. By implication, the London Clearing House must lose.

“If you listen to others, they will say that this is my personal agenda,” says Garbi – correctly as it happens. “Some shareholders don’t like me to speak in this way. But I am independent from any bank or group of banks. My mission is to do the best for the market.”

The competition for MTS clearing mandates began in the middle of last year, when Garbi bowed to broker pressure and agreed to open up the markets to clearing. The board of each MTS market – MTS Germany, MTS France and so on – was able to choose a clearing house. Several potential clearing houses were shortlisted: London Clearing House (LCH), Clearnet of France, Eurex of Germany and Italy’s Cassa di Compensazione (Cassa). That list was cut further to the first two.

Each of the national boards, which consist of representatives from member banks, plus one seat for Garbi, was free to select the best options for them, in cash bonds and in repo. This choice largely revolves around which central counterparty (CCP) covers the largest number of member banks in each market, because to join as a new member costs from around e250,000 to about e1 million, depending on the CCP.

CCPs, brokers, and MTS are all united in wanting to avoid fragmentation. The utopia of a single pan-European, pan-product clearing house may be some way off but moving towards it must be positive.

But the choices so far have disappointed that hope. MTS France cash bonds went to Clearnet. MTS Germany went to LCH, which had already covered that market’s repo for some time. And despite the wish to avoid fragmentation, Italy has plumped for a joint venture between Clearnet and Cassa, the latter of which is inexperienced in fixed income, as it is Italy’s equities clearing house. Of the remaining markets, Spain and Finland are newly created, so they are yet to face this issue. Portugal is yet to decide for cash or repo. Belgium and the Netherlands both use LCH for repo but they have not selected a cash CCP.

This is not exactly a picture of harmony and unity.

Garbi has reservations about the whole idea of introducing clearing. Although he considers himself to be a pioneer in the field, having introduced repo clearing on MTS Germany through LCH some time ago, he still feels that for cash bonds the service has limitations. “The advantages exist only for some players – the largest banks,” he says. “They are the UK-based institutions – those that use UK balance sheet law that allows netting. For others, it is an additional cost.”

Furthermore, he says that the anonymity that CCP clearing brings is most pronounced in those markets where brokers are likely to trade with the same other brokers repeatedly. For the more fragmented MTS markets, the benefits are more marginal.

In any case, market participants pushed for clearing, and the MTS markets are going to implement it. In that decision process, Garbi makes no secret of his preference for Clearnet. “Those that use the markets control them,” he says. “We can’t impose anything on them. But we can impose our views, and I certainly don’t refrain from that.”

The influence that banks have over the clearing houses is at the crux of this for Garbi. “LCH is too much on the side of the American banks,” he says. “True pan-European representation is missing. When I see on some boards American banks are voting for LCH, I don’t think they are voting because they really want that direction but because they have a vested interest.”

Garbi may have a point. The bulge-bracket firms dominate most markets but they account for only around 20% of the volume that goes through MTS markets. His analysis is slightly harsh, though. LCH is indeed run by and for its bank members – a fact that it is proud of. It accepts that while it has over 100 members, only a small number of them can be on the board. But the board selection process is a free vote, and it just so happens that the bulge-bracket London-based banks are more active at seeking board positions and influence within LCH than the smaller continental European banks, most of which keep their senior executives outside London.

Choices of clearing houses in cash and repo for each MTS market
MTS market Cash Repo
Belgium Undecided LCH
Finland Undecided Undecided
France Clearnet Clearnet
Germany LCH LCH
Italy Cassa/Clearnet Undecided
Netherlands Undecided LCH
Portugal Undecided Undecided
Spain Undecided Undecided
Japan No immediate plans to introduce clearing.
EuroCreditMTS No immediate plans to introduce clearing. Would be likely to follow Germany’s choices.
 
Source: EuroMTS

For Garbi, Italy’s cash bonds clearing decision is a perfect illustration of why LCH is unsuitable. Italy eventually chose a joint venture between Cassa and Clearnet – an arrangement that is yet to be approved by market participants but that is likely to go live in the third quarter this year. MTS is involved in setting up the joint venture but will not have any involvement in the day-to-day running of the clearing arrangement.

The partnership approach makes sense. It means, for example, that where Morgan Stanley uses Clearstream and Sanpaolo IMI uses Cassa, they will enjoy reciprocal membership when they trade with each other. As Italy’s banks are so scattered, and few are large enough to warrant joining an international CCP, this saves them the cost of joining while making the market more efficient.

Garbi says: “Clearnet is the only one who wanted to do it in cooperation with other players. LCH was not prepared to enter into partnership with Cassa. Their view is that because all the American banks support LCH, it should get the business without negotiations with partners.”

LCH is not impressed. Arun Aggarwal, its managing director of business management, says: “No, that is not true. [Partnerships are] something we have worked on in another marketplace in equities. There are no barriers to this at all.” He adds that he is willing to consider further partnerships in fixed income, on MTS and other markets.

Understandably, LCH is taking the whole matter to heart. “[Choosing Clearnet] is not the best solution for the market,” says Aggarwal. “The business case is easy to see. LCH has the repo market sewn up – 95% of cleared repo in the four markets served – namely Germany, Belgium, Holland and Austria – goes through LCH.”

It is a difficult decision for the banks. Both Clearnet and LCH are marketing themselves well. LCH is backed by the big players: Clearnet benefits from greater representation of smaller European banks.

Garbi’s influence is not always obvious. Simon Gaston, global head of fixed income operations at UBS Warburg in London, says: “I hadn’t picked up on such a promotion,” although he is not personally involved in the boards’ decisions. “I don’t know why he would do that. There isn’t any obvious reason other than that from a eurozone perspective Clearnet is probably more user-friendly than LCH because of the regulatory framework it operates within.”

Gaston and other market observers agree that there is little to separate the two, and that it is fair and valid for Garbi to have an opinion and to make that opinion clear.

Clearnet, meanwhile, is obviously not averse to the extra help that it is receiving from MTS. And it has its own advantages. It is proud of the alliance is has formed in Italy, and it already has a track record across Europe. Its CEO, Patrice Renault, says: “Our international user committee has a huge UK presence. We are totally international and we take care of UK interests. Regulators and [national] treasuries are keen to see the advantages of Clearnet. Our location in the eurozone is better.”

       
Patrice Renault

But LCH is still smarting from Garbi’s involvement. “The market belongs to its members,” says Aggarwal. “They provide the flow of transactions. Yes, MTS has done a great job of facilitating that, but they are a channel.” In other words, leave the decisions to the members. Garbi may have just one vote on each board, against 15 or 16 others but his promotion of Clearnet does seem to be extending beyond that.

Perhaps, after the hard work that Garbi has put into creating MTS and making it a rare electronic success story over the past three years, he is wary of outside control of his platform’s day-to-day running. This is understandable. He has built from scratch an operation that now deals benchmark securities from 13 government and agency borrowers. The latest MTS newsletter in March said that it traded e1.25 trillion in 2001, compared with e850 billion in the previous year. It set a new daily record volume of e10.2 billion in March this year. The platform has at least 59 market participants. By comparison, the highly successful TradeWeb Europe attracted e215 billion in euro sovereign trading volume in 2001.

A man of influence

In short, Garbi has become a man who is difficult to ignore. LCH’s Aggarwal says: “Garbi has a lot more influence than he is using openly. He is strongly giving ultimatums that it will be anybody but Clearnet over his dead body. One of the criteria that appears to have been applied in the process is the influence that MTS has over the clearing house. It has formed views based on the level of influence and control it has over the clearing activities.”

Exactly what form this influence takes or would take is unclear. Garbi insists that he has not negotiated board positions with either of the main CCP rivals. “I am not looking for a board seat [on Clearnet]. I have enough board seats on all the MTS markets.” The only board position that he was offered was one on Cassa, as part of the three-way partnership that was established to provide clearing in Italy. Garbi thanked Cassa for the offer but declined, because he did not want to appear biased.

Renault at Clearnet says that it has not considered a board position for Garbi but does not rule it out in future. Garbi says: “I have no personal vested interest. The only interest I have is to make sure that the structure has enough views from the banks in the market.”

That structure involves creating a single European CCP. Garbi feels, rightly or wrongly, that he has a role to play in making that happen. “I strongly believe that LCH and Clearnet should merge,” he says. “But it should be a merger of equals. LCH has more business, and that is blocking merger talks. All the other markets have to go to Clearnet to increase its volumes. LCH is not happy with that. It wants to kill the competition but it won’t be able to.”

Garbi says that in order to create unanimity the chairmen of each of the countries’ boards that are yet to select a CCP might force those banks that are members of both LCH and Clearnet to abstain. This would almost certainly tip the balance in Clearnet’s favour.

Realistically, though, this issue is unlikely to be one that brings about a merger. That would depend on national and EU regulators, as well as on the views of the market. And that’s only if the CCPs themselves agree to push the issue, which they have been discussing on and off for at least two years. LCH says it would be just one factor among many that go into the decision. Renault says: “We are still open to consider it but we are still in competition.”

The worst outcome for Garbi would be that he opens himself up to competition from other electronic networks – say if LCH’s bulge bracket backers decided to push volume through TradeWeb or Brokertec.

Garbi is aware of this possibility. He says: “They could use a separate platform. Fine. Let’s see what happens. You can define that as a cartel, and that’s not new in banking. But as far as I can see, the cash market is in MTS.”

Even if Clearnet scoops the remaining cash markets and continues its steady pan-European growth, LCH will fight to see another day.

“We have other things to do,” says Aggarwal. “There are big chunks of the bond market that are not yet touched. The corporate bond market in Europe is huge, and clearing is increasingly attractive. We have only scratched the surface.”