Investors turn cool on the rating game

The Enron saga showed vividly how credit rating agencies can be key players in the endgame facing a stricken corporation. That's a disquieting role for the agencies, which present themselves as mere observers. But downgrades, by setting off forced selling, can push troubled companies over the edge. How did investors come to rely so heavily on ratings and what do they intend to do about it?

In the melee that surrounds the sinking of Enron, accusations continue to fly. Much of the criticism is aimed at a management team that seemed to see proper financial disclosure as an optional extra. But investors are also critical of the lack of early warning signals from the credit rating agencies. They are easy targets. True, Enron is – or was – a company whose dealings were of baffling complexity. But if anyone could have seen through the fog it was surely the agencies with their supposed hotline to the boardroom of each rated issuer.

Access intelligence that drives action

To unlock this research, enter your email to log in or enquire about access