Preaching to the converted

It could be crunch time for European convertible issuers as redemptions fall due with stocks at long-term lows. Others face the prospect of investors putting the bonds back to them. Yet again it's the telecoms companies in the thick of it all.

       
Corporates face convertibles crunch

CFOs WHO JOINED in the craze for issuing short-dated equity-linked bonds with aggressive terms may be regretting it today. In theory, convertibles are a great way to sell stock at a premium when current valuations make issuing straight equity unappealing. However, plummeting stock prices since the beginning of 2002 mean that many jumbo convertible bonds issued over the last couple of years are now trading a long way out of the money.

If the maturity date is far away then its finance director can simply sit back and congratulate himself for having secured cheap financing based on a previous, healthier share price. Not all are so lucky though. Lorraine Lodge, head of convertibles research at ING Barings, warns that “2003 is a bubble on the redemption schedule. There will be companies that won’t see their convertibles convert and will have to redeem them.”

What’s worse is that some firms are having to unexpectedly pull cash out of the hat because they’ve issued bonds with a put option, giving the opportunity to sell the paper back at a predetermined price on a specified date. These options were added as a sweetener for investors, in theory at no extra cost to the issuer. Assuming that the stock price rose beyond the put price – two years ago a fair assumption – the option would lie dormant.

Several equity-linked bankers are peddling their services to these potentially stricken issuers. Far better, they say, to solve the problem now and head off a liquidity crisis before any hint of one appears than to hold off until refinancing is more urgently needed, more expensive and more precarious.

Only a few European companies are in dire straits – yet. “There are quite a few puts next year but not as many as people think,” says Martin Haydock, head of convertibles research at UBS Warburg. If companies have cash to pay the debt there’s little cause to worry.

It’s the telecoms that are most at risk. They have been profligate issuers of convertibles since funding options began to dry up early last year. France Telecom is the most stretched, with almost e19 billion of equity-linked bonds outstanding. Most worrying is an exchangeable into Orange, sold alongside the IPO of the wireless operator in February 2001. It matures in February 2003 but if the share price stays roughly where it is today, at e4.80, no sane investor is going to choose to convert into shares – that option is set at e12.45.

Most large out-of-the-money telecom and media convertible bonds do not have put options. But Vivendi’s do, and it’s the name heading every convertible analyst’s hot list. Adding to its considerable woes, the French media conglomerate has a e1.8 billion exchangeable into Vivendi Environnement – one of five outstanding convertibles – with a put date of March 2003. As its share price has sunk, losing 75% of its value since the beginning of the year, it’s unlikely investors will resist the temptation to use the escape hatch.

Unpopular strategy

New Vivendi chief executive Jean-René Fourtou may try to bribe the market to hold on to some of the bonds in order to avoid a short-term liquidity crisis. “We would expect to see some renegotiation in Europe as has been done in the US,” says ING Barings’ Lodge (see box). This is unlikely to be a popular strategy, however. “Europe is more conservative and companies are more likely to turn to banks rather than the public markets,” adds Lodge.

       
Vivendi attempts to avoid a
liquidity crisis

For issuers without credit concerns, the favoured approach seems to be to sit tight. Continuing weak share prices and intense market volatility, combined with a natural aversion to structured trades, means there’s little impetus to issue immediately unless it is the only answer. “There’s a potential redemption deadline looming but most issuers are waiting for market equilibrium to be re-established. If markets stabilize, we’ll have a very busy autumn,” says Viswas Raghavan, co-head of equity capital and derivatives markets at JPMorgan. “Our advice is that issuers get ready to come to market at short notice.”

Graham Clark, managing director in equity linked capital markets at Merrill Lynch, says: “We think the convertible market is still open, provided securities are priced correctly, and we are recommending that some corporates refinance early. Interest rates have not risen as fast as people were expecting, volatility is back up and so it makes sense to issue.” The question is whether those issuers will choose to return to the convertibles market. “Are convertible issuers going to be once bitten twice shy?” asks UBS Warburg’s Haydock. CFOs who thought they could use exchangeables to offload stock at a premium have learnt this year that it offers no guarantee of success. There’s been a dearth of these deals this year. Of a total of e16.5 billion-worth of convertibles since January 2002 only e3 billion has been in exchangeable bonds – in previous years they comprised two-thirds of issuance.

Straight convertible issuers, though, have got a good deal – as long as they are more interested in cheap debt than having the bonds convert. As Euromoney went to press, France Telecom was completing the sale of e442 million of mandatory convertibles into ST Microelectronics, suggesting it is unscathed by its experience of equity-linked markets but wants to be sure it can offload its ST stake.

Though some investors were wary – this is the first mandatory convertible sold in Europe for five years – bankers claim there’s still a healthy appetite for equity linked paper. Not least that’s because only a few outstanding convertibles feature any equity exposure. Also, they say, there’s a growing interest in capital-protected investments. “Investors are attracted to the defensive features of convertibles. They are more inclined to accept a lower yield and leave a 20% to 30% premium on the table but keep their principal investment,” says Raghavan at JPMorgan. Few asset classes afford that luxury.

Putting in the sweetener

Investors are getting nervous. It’s July 22, the last day they can register their intent to put Masco’s convertible bond back to the company. But they were hoping the triple-B-rated home improvements company might give them a bit of a sweetener to encourage them to hang on to the paper. So far, they’ve heard nothing.

It’s all part of the new convertibles game: how to get the most from a put option. The reason it’s so prevalent is the nature of much of last year’s issuance: the zero-zero convertible. Tyco’s $3.45 billion deal in November 2000 was the first. These deals offer no yield or coupon, have a high conversion premium and are targeted more at hedge fund investors that want to trade the equity volatility than at specialist convertible funds. Short-dated put options, usually of one year but sometimes two, offer an escape route.

It’s free money for at least twelve months. Corporates snapped them up last year – nearly 30 deals with a total face value of $17.5 billion had or have put options in 2002. As the economy declined, access to credit shrank and share prices plummeted, the chance that some of these deals would be put increased, as did the possibility that enforced puts could propel some companies into liquidity crises.

Calpine looked the most at risk. It issued a $1 billion zero-zero in April 2001 but had been hurt by the Enron scandal. By December, an April put was widely expected, with the company hard pressed to find the cash. With Deutsche Bank’s help, Calpine managed to issue a more regular convertible just before Christmas for $1.2 billion, and used the proceeds to pay out when investors put the zero-zero.

Comcast, however, followed a different route when its one-year put came due last December. Its stock was way down, making a put more valuable to investors than holding the paper. But Comcast was bidding on AT&T’s cable assets and didn’t want to pay out cash. Instead it offered any investors who didn’t exercise the put a one-off cash coupon and an extra put date for December 2002. It worked. Investors had already tendered to put back about 50% of the deal; after being offered the sweetener that dropped to 6% of the bonds, and $1.18 billion is still outstanding.

Since then, several companies have followed suit, offering a cash incentive, a new put date, or both. In May Neuberger Bergman offered a small cash incentive to stop investors putting its $150 million bond back, and Cendant, whose paper had a face value of $1 billion, had only $9 million put back after offering to pay interest.

Others weren’t so lucky. Cox Communications had puts on two separate bonds in mid-February. The firm tried a cash payment as an inducement but investors put back $455 million of the first bond (almost all of it) and $329 million of the second one (of a possible $771 million face value). Stilwell Financial also failed to convince investors to stay in when its put came due at the end of April. “They offered 3% annual interest rates for two years,” says Jeff Seidel, head of global convertibles research at CSFB. “It didn’t seem to entice, and $821 million was put back.”

The key to convincing investors is to be able to offer them something of value. “Some folks have been trying to thread the needle just a little bit too close,” says one head of convertibles origination. “You can’t just add on a penny or two and hope it works. If the value proposition of the sweetener isn’t clear, investors will probably rather have the cash. Issuers need to be willing to leave something on the table.”

Playing the waiting game

That’s where the game comes in. Investors can submit their bonds for the put, but can also cancel at the last minute. Likewise the issuer is able to check how many bonds have been put and then decide whether to offer a sweetener. “It incentivizes the investors to put in the hope of getting a sweetener,” says Seidel. “And a clever company can wait until the last minute to offer it.” That’s what happened with Masco’s put, and also with Baxter’s at the start of June. The game works best when the stock is hovering around the inflexion point , the point at which it’s not clear whether to put or not to put is better.

Some issuers simply have no choice but to accept the put. Calpine is one example, Solectron another. The latter had over $5 billion of puts lined up until the end of 2004, and had to work out how to refinance them. It’s taken the proactive route this year, issuing high-yield debt and using loans, cash and a $1.1 billion mandatory convertible to retire its puttable converts. Thus far this year the company has had a face value of $1.16 billion put back, has repurchased $2.14 billion in one offering, and just last month completed a $1.5 billion tender offer.

Between August and the end of the year, bonds with a face value of just under $6 billion have puts coming due. The biggest is for Medtronics, which has over $2 billion outstanding. Eaton Vance’s $200 million could well be put in mid-August, and the reputted Comcast, which started the trend, comes around again in December. Jeremy Howard, head of convertibles research at Deutsche Bank, believes that to avoid the put, Comcast’s stock would need to rise to $46.50, which is more than double where it is now and is a price it’s been nowhere near since May last year.

Antony Currie