Market Axess bonds with Trading Edge

In the internet bond trading arena the present number of competing platforms is unsustainable. The consolidation process started last month with the coming together of Market Axess and Trading Edge.

       
Rick McVey

One thing is certain in the internet bond trading arena: the present number of competing platforms is unsustainable. The consolidation process started last month with the coming together of Market Axess and Trading Edge.

Rick McVey, chief executive officer of Market Axess, believes that the deal will create one of the strongest platforms in the game. “The two businesses together will create a tremendous market solution,” he says.

He continues: “The theme throughout our business model is aggregation of dealer capabilities across products and across functions. Our secondary-inventory-application projects to the client bonds that any of our dealers are involved in and price levels where they would buy or sell those bonds. What typically happens today is that the client gets this information from one dealer at a time, by fax, phone, e-mail, whatever. We aggregate this information electronically for our users and this greatly improves the product and price-discovery process.”

The marriage of Market Axess and Trading Edge combines two differing approaches to bond trading. The Market Axess platform is a disclosed counterparty model, whereas Trading Edge offers anonymous trading. On Market Axess, buyers can easily see the dealer involved and the price being offered. Where more than one dealer is providing a price for a bond, the issue is marked with an asterisk.

The buyer clicks on the issues to see which dealers are offering the bond and the prices each is offering.

McVey says: “When you get into really liquid active bonds, what you often find is six, seven or eight dealers putting competitive prices out. In the credit areas you’re dealing with a market that is so fragmented that it is difficult to find which dealers are involved in what bond and it can be almost impossible to find competitive prices. With our platform, buyers can do in a couple of seconds what would have typically taken them 30 minutes by phone.” Easy price comparison is an undoubted boon for the buy side. “What we’re adding to the process is efficiency. Rather than going to one dealer at a time, users have access to comprehensive research on one platform.”

Market Axess prices are indicative and are updated three or four times a day. This may be seen as a weakness of the enquiry-based system. In buying Trading Edge, Market Axess will be offering users the choice between indicative, enquiry-based dealing and real-time, anonymous trading. Ken Austin, senior vice-president at Trading Edge, explains: “The Trading Edge system is fully live and executable. There are no indicative prices. If you see a bid you can hit that price at the click of a button. Our goal is to recreate the broker-dealer sales call electronically, anonymously and, above all, efficiently.”

To execute on the Market Axess platform, the user clicks on the issue required. The dealers – more than one can be approached simultaneously – respond with a current best price. The user then has a time limit in which to to accept the price or make a counter-bid. The user is also able to specify a time frame in which the dealer can respond with a price.

On Trading Edge, buyers respond to a real-time price, accepting the price immediately or engaging in a similar offer procedure. Trading Edge stands between the two anonymous parties as a counterparty. In addition to the on-line system, Trading Edge also offers a telephone desk through which parties are able to conduct particularly tricky negotiations while retaining anonymity.

Competitors wonder how the two systems can possibly work together, but Austin believes that the new entity will offer “the best of both worlds” to users. At times, the sensitivity of an issue may make anonymity preferable, whereas at others, disclosure of identity may well help speed up price negotiation.

To begin with, the two systems will be linked but not fully integrated. Later, a simple tab menu will enable clients to swap between the two platforms and specify which products they are looking for. Austin says: “We at Trading Edge are very excited by the merger. The new site will provide a base point for all trades.

More users and dealers will hopefully be attracted to this central location for all their trades.”

McVey points out that client feedback on the deal has been universally positive. “Clients are attracted to both the disclosed, multi-dealer model and the anonymous model and they like seeing the development of a central trading platform that will work across those trading styles and many different products,” he says. “What the buy side is fearful of is fragmentation of electronic trading platforms where they have to go someplace different for each product and trading style.

Clients like the aggregation of dealers and clients on our system. We will be live on six different products soon, and traders will be able to get used to one standard trading protocol and one clearing and settlement party.”