South Africa is a contradictory country. Its economy is the size of Poland’s or Thailand’s. It has income disparities similar to Brazil’s. In population and wage rates, it’s Argentina. But it spends three times more of GDP on public education than China and twice as much as the average of all emerging markets.
Infrastructure is first world. Medical care is still innovative and superb, although the best care is in the private sector. Internet cafés abound. The water from the taps is pure and tastes better than the bottled imports.
Corporate South Africa hums like a smooth turbine and operates to get results for shareholders, not the sons and daughters of cronies and tycoons. Labour productivity gains are double those of the US and unit labour costs are steady. The economy is three to four times more internationalized than Argentina’s or Brazil’s despite embargoes up to 1994.
There’s low external and government debt and no banking problems or cancerous economic corruption. There’s a rock-solid, democratic government and an efficient, independent central bank with clear inflation targets.
But Johannesburg is the crime capital of the world. Most of the people I met had suffered violent crime and many wanted to leave South Africa. It has one of the worst brain drains of young, elite talent. The government does little to stop uncontrolled immigration from the north that is a threat to a better skill-set for the labour force and appears to tolerate both cancers: crime and the exodus of the skilled. These are the two nastiest sides of the ethnic politic. It’s vital that both are eliminated.
It is not too late. In Jo’burg and in the bureaucracy of Pretoria, many young people are committed to staying. In particular, the young and bright Afrikaner graduates who once opted to become bureaucrats are now devoting their creativity to the private sector. The thirst for talent in South Africa’s corporate economy and bureaucracy means that there are great jobs for those with skills. That is South Africa’s great advantage over other emerging markets.
The universities are up there with the best and are thoroughly integrated. I visited Witswatersrand. It’s an ethnic melting pot with facilities that make my old university look like a slum. If the government wants this economic infrastructure to spread its benefits into the far reaches of society, it had better go colour blind and meritocracy mad.
My take is that the country is at the trough of bad perceptions on crime, disease and economic performance. The equity market is priced on expectations of a low 3% to 3.5% growth rate forever. But I reckon South Africa can make a lot of money for foreign investors, because these perceptions are wrong in the short and long term.
In the short term, strong domestic demand and confidence could take growth well above 4% this year. The budget will boost the net incomes of the lower-paid by 3% to 5% by reducing tax creep and introducing a tax credit for those in new jobs. Capital expenditure is already recovering, boosted by strong cashflows and IT expenditure catch-up.
Also, capital inflows will be significant this year, unlike last year, because of accelerated privatizations.
The biggest risk to this short-term scenario is that external accounts cannot bear the strain of faster domestic demand growth. But these days, corporations are much more efficient and market-responsive. Also, there has been a 25% real depreciation of the rand.
This has made exports massively competitive. A cheap rand will offset the impact of slower global growth on exports and a much greater proportion of exports are now price-sensitive manufactures. I reckon that will make the external accounts a non-issue.
|
View graph. |
||||||
Beyond the short term, there is a huge potential for investors. The broad macroeconomic balances in fiscal and monetary policy and a good banking system are all in place and there is no prospect of anyone political messing with these. There is also no Latin American or Asian-style corruption.
That locks in 3.5% growth. But South Africa could easily achieve 6%. What government needs to do is to privatize its massive state-owned assets. That would free resources for targeting the poor, including the sick, Aids orphans and the unskilled. If half of these extra resources were used for this, the rest could be used to reduce debt, so cutting the 20% of state expenditure that goes on debt costs. Again, this would free government spending to do more for infrastructure, education, crime and healthcare.
Public-sector downsizing would also dramatically raise productivity, as that of privatized assets rose to match the 6% growth already being achieved by the private sector.
It would also attract FDI to privatized assets, as well as to those being unbundled by a restructuring private sector that suffers from a dearth of foreign investors. In turn, this would raise domestic confidence in the private sector.
Violent crime remains the major macro impediment. It is hard to accept that South Africa’s lawlessness is the inevitable result of poverty. Brazil has a similar GDP per capita and the same lousy income distribution.
But crime is three times higher than in Brazil. Far too many people today believe that the ANC is soft on crime. It needs to prove it isn’t.
Aids is an awesome and awful problem. But the cruel reality is that its economic impact will be much smaller than that of crime. Aids will only undo the economy if it undermines consumer demand or productive potential; or if it blows out the budget. Of course, the economy, as measured by total GDP, will be smaller with Aids than without it, by some 20%. But ironically, productivity and per capita incomes would be higher and so would the productive potential of the economy because the ratio of skilled to unskilled workers would improve dramatically (from 18% to 26% in the next 15 years).
Over the next five years, Aids deaths may lower annual consumption growth by about 0.3 percentage points. But growth will suffer only minimally as the vast pool of unskilled survivors can be brought into the labour force to replace Aids victims. Indeed, the total productivity of the dying can be replaced with just a two point rise in the ratio of productive investment to GDP – a gain that is well within reach. If that happened, average GDP growth could be nearer 6% than 3%.
The timing couldn’t be better if South Africa can boost GDP growth to a sustainable 6%. Many Asian emerging markets are sinking below the radar screen of foreign investors, thanks to political mismanagement. So South Africa’s star will be rising as those of competitors wane.