|
Headline: Malaysia – If controls go, will confidence falter? Source: Euromoney Date: May 2000 Author: Gill Baker Malaysia seems to have recovered better from the Asian crisis than some other countries in the region, not least because of the currency control policies that were introduced. Confidence was shaken a little last month by the volatility in US markets, but the fundamentals still appear to be sound. Gill Baker reports “If you’re not positive, then you’re in the wrong business,” boomed veteran broker David Chua at the gaggle of nervous young traders as they waited for the lift in their Kuala Lumpur tower block. Fear of local carnage in the aftermath of Wall Street’s bloodbath in mid-April was in the air. In an echo of three years ago, one dared to reply with an over-used Chinese mantra: “There’s opportunity in crisis”. But after an exhausting Monday watching the Kuala Lumpur Stock Exchange plummet 6%, he didn’t sound convinced. Wall Street’s jitters could not have come at a worse time for Malaysia, and indeed the rest of Asia, as it begins to show the first tentative signs of recovery. As confidence returns, Kuala Lumpur’s bankers are in reflective mood, but some things do not quite add up. The country has one of the highest savings rates in the world, there is no immediate shortage of demand in the domestic capital markets, and there is even talk of overheating in the residential property market. So what happened? Has Malaysia really escaped the worst of the regional crisis, thanks to its bold currency control policies? Was there less of a problem there in the first place than was believed, or is it so much “smoke and mirrors”, as one commentator put it? Sound fundamentals “There was so much emotion involved. It has been a really V-shaped kind of experience. The financial crisis did not have a lot to do with the fundamentals,” insists ABN Amro Bank managing director Huibert Boumeester. Rasool Khan, managing director of Bank of Nova Scotia, is also bullish: “Business has picked up. It is evident at every level. The restaurants are getting occupied, hotels are increasing their rates, things have improved a lot,” he says. His explanation for the extraordinary V-shaped nature of the Malaysian economy was more fundamental: “Momentum builds up both ways. When they rebound people realize it has gone overboard, but that is not just here, it is all over the world. The ’97 correction in the Dow Jones was no different.” It is too early for Malaysians to be smug, and bankers are still choosing their words carefully, but the country’s problems do seem to show curious anomalies. Ironically, there is no shortage of demand in the domestic capital markets, although foreign direct investment is less ebullient, and local business has actually taken a shine to the government’s controversial exchange controls, so much so that there could be difficulties in removing or easing them. “The currency is undervalued, not overvalued, therefore that means we do not have the same problems usually associated with currency control such as a black market and all those kinds of things,” says Boumeester. “It makes Malaysia very competitive and we can see that in the strength of exports. But in the long term it is not a good thing to maintain and therefore you need to revert to a more flexible relationship over time. The measures were first more a measure to control the economy, now business in general is quite favourably disposed, and it makes their life much simpler. The business community is starting to develop a liking for it.”
Other analysts are less charitable. “Things are beginning to get a little bit better but we are not wonderfully out of the crisis,” says one. “The capital controls have helped. They have made business much easier to run because no-one has to worry about hedging, and they have made Malaysia artificially competitive. The trouble is, the country’s taxpayers and pensioners will be paying for it for the next The question now is how long the Malaysian business community’s comfort zone will be maintained once the economic need for the controls has eased. “The government has always said it will come out of this at some stage,” says Boumeester. “Over the last year it has been much more broadly accepted, it is just very difficult to come up with effective measures. The government over time probably always wants to release it, but there is no immediate need to go back,” he says. The timeframe for lifting, or at least easing, controls is unclear, especially given the US market’s dive. “When everything has returned fully to normal. If at the end of this year we have that same GDP we forecasted,” predicts Boumeester, whose analysts have put growth for the year at 6.5%, against the central bank’s forecast of 5.8%. Many now attribute Malaysia’s less dramatic downturn than that of its neighbours to the currency policies. “What added to the recovery was the exchange controls and currency peg, and central bank policies were very appropriate,” says Bank of Nova Scotia’s Khan. “The exchange controls prevented the flow of speculative money. There was no more money left so it did not prevent any more leaving the place but it assured people coming in they were going to have a stable currency and that added to the comfort.” Homing in on the monetary policy of the central bank, Bank Negara, and the government’s fiscal policies, Khan says: “The monetary policy was very appropriate. It was the right formula. Unfortunately for the IMF it was not their formula.” So how did Malaysia manage to come up with an apparent solution, one that had appeared to elude the combined economic talents of the entire IMF? “It was a carefully thought out set of processes and policies,” says Khan. “I know from personal sources that a team of people, including the prime minister, was involved in considering the options of exchange control for over nine months before it was implemented. It was not something that was off the cuff. They thought through all the angles and they implemented it. The IMF is committed to a free-trade scenario and exchange controls work against the grain, so even if they did come up with it, it was not going to be an acceptable position.” This is not to say that Malaysia is not a supporter of free trade. “Malaysia is very very open,” says Khan. “They understand that free trade is important for global growth and it is creating more opportunities than problems, and they are committed, but where you have a scenario like we had in 1997 you cannot think of free trade, you have to think of stability first. The ringgit was hitting 4.20 to the dollar before the 3.80 peg was imposed. At that time the general feeling was that the ringgit could go to 7.50. That was the mood, every Malay was talking about what it would do to their money. It was bad. Sentiment can drive things a long way.” One banker gives an example of a wealthy elderly customer who withdrew M$1 million at the height of the crisis to move to offshore Singapore markets via a money changer at M$4.20 to the US dollar. She then changed her mind and returned the money as the rate was pegged at M$3.80. She had a narrow escape from losing a large sum. From this sort of experience follows the pressure from business for retention of exchange controls.
“I would see it as premature to lift this exchange control now. In the last two days the US is beginning to look extremely shaky and if the US does not achieve a safe landing every economy is going to get affected. There is no need to risk something that has proved itself,” says Bank of Nova Scotia’s Khan. “I do not know exactly when the peg should be lifted. With the correction that is ongoing in the US the US dollar is going to get weaker anyway. What it does to other currencies we will have to wait and see. With what is happening now there will be more countries interested in getting on to the peg than off it,” he adds. But he admits: “The peg is not sustainable. How long it is going to be maintained is the government’s call, but I think it should be sooner than later. The peg undervalues the ringgit A subsidiary of a US company will be unlikely to be declaring any dividends until the peg is lifted, and it will also defer payments outside, while trying to speed up payments into the country, thus causing a lead-lag effect, Khan explains. But prime minister Mahathir Mohamad was quoted in the New Straits Times as saying that foreign fund managers calling for a downward review of the peg “did not know what they were talking about”. That view is echoed by an analyst, who says: “There is huge pressure on the government not to lift controls or change the peg. At prime minister level there is still an obsession with the notion that foreigners are able to damage the economy. In his term of power there is really no question of capital controls or the peg being lifted.” There is the possibility, though, that controls might become more flexible. The official line from Bank Negara is: “The purpose for fixing the exchange rate is to provide an environment of stable domestic financial markets to facilitate economic recovery. It is therefore not the intention to adjust the rate frequently. Currently, there are no compelling reasons to warrant an adjustment of the peg. “The medium-term outlook suggests that domestic inflation would remain subdued and the threat of misalignment remains small. Nevertheless, [the central bank] will monitor developments on both the external and internal front, that may have implications for the ringgit’s exchange rate and will respond accordingly in a highly transparent manner to ensure that the ringgit is at an appropriate rate.” “The first objective for government exchange rates was to provide space for government to fix the economy,” says HLG Securities chief economist Lee Heng Guie. He reckons the peg undervalued the ringgit by around 10% to 15% and that this could cause distortions over the longer term, especially in terms of asset inflation and excess liquidity. However, he says: “The central bank is aware of this and so far they have been doing a good job. The fixed exchange rate is consistent with the fundamentals of the economy.” Lee continues: “We feel the ringgit peg will stay for this year and is likely to be re-pegged next year – the level is anybody’s guess, but I think the authorities would not want it to be too strong – maybe 3.50 would be a good level.” Bank of Nova Scotia’s Khan says: “The objection to exchange controls and currency pegs is not so much the fact that it is Malaysia or something others have not done. I think it is opposition to world bodies such as the IMF. The IMF’s formula is drastically different. It is totally opposite to a low interest rate environment and intervention on exchange rates, but those are the two things that cause the problems. Maybe that is not the right approach. Maybe it has worked in one or two countries, but it is not a universal formula. There was a stage in the financial crisis when we ran the risk of at least 30% of businesses bankrupt with the high interest rates. For Malaysia, double-digit interest rates would mean 10% to 11%, and paying 22% would be unthinkable, and would not have been supportable by the business activities. It would have been a disaster.” With the government’s attitude towards business, the peg is unlikely to be lifted in the foreseeable future. “The Malaysian prime minister has a notion that the government is an equity stakeholder in every company in this country,” says Khan. “Every year the company makes profit and pays tax, and therefore the government is very careful to have business-friendly policies.” ABN Amro’s Boumeester says: “Over time foreign direct investment will be critical for Malaysia, but for now there is a lot of capacity available.” He adds that the positive current account balance makes foreign inflows less important for the time being. “Malaysia is still quite attractive,” he insists. “If you want an absolute low-cost environment Malaysia is not as attractive, as there are other countries where wages are much lower, but it has good infrastructure that is really pretty solid and there is a big advantage in that everyone speaks English, it is a fairly open country and efficiency is probably higher.” ABN Amro is seeing its investment banking business pick up, with foreign companies taking minority stakes in Malaysian companies. “It is nowhere near the levels of Thailand or Korea, but we are also seeing Malaysian companies going out and acquiring overseas companies,” says Boumeester, citing Star Cruises’ acquisition of NCL of Norway. Boumeester has espoused an expansion strategy for ABN Amro. “A lot of people became very withdrawn during the crisis, but we decided that was not the right stance,” he says. “They know, mentally and physically, that after the downturn follows growth, but they do not react that way. We see this as an opportunity. We have gone in and invested, changed, restructured, made a better job of it and got our customer relationships to a deeper level.” ABN Amro now ranks in the top five in Malaysia in terms of treasury, against 22nd three years ago. It claims a 10% share of the secondary fixed-income market and is going for growth in its structured finance business. In 1998 there were still a few deals, 1999 saw little activity on the offshore market, but by the end of the year the market showed signs of reactivation, buoyed by the bank’s arrangement of the US$600 million acquisition facility for Star Cruises. ABN Amro’s strategy was developed in the mid-1990s, says Boumeester. “The plan was hatched before the crisis. Sometimes the crisis accelerated things, when we realized we could not make it without some acquisitions,” he says. ABN’s oft-stated goal is to be among the top three foreign banks in Malaysia by 2002, which means it needs to be in the top five by the end of this year “in every shape or form of defining it”. The trick will be focusing on customer service, products and delivery mechanisms. The issue for ABN and other foreign banks in Asia is their role and position in relation to the local players. It has been a contentious matter across Asia, with many countries, including Thailand and Malaysia, imposing restrictions on foreign ownership of domestic banks and limiting the number of branches allowed by international players. Malaysia has stuck by a 30% ceiling on foreign bank ownership, but the global-versus-local debate is less straightforward than that, and Boumeester admits that there are still plenty of advantages to being a foreign bank, even in Malaysia. “In terms of branding, it is probably a help. The perception is usually that we have higher-quality products. What does not help us is that there are still a number of franchise issues.” For example, the country’s 13 foreign banks have so far been prevented from providing internet banking services. “But the government is moving towards gradual opening up,” says Boumeester, who believes international banks will eventually still have the upper hand because of their scale and ability to harness critical mass. “You cannot come up with scale in a local geographical basis,” he says. “There are going to be niche banks and regional banks, but banks that are trying to continue to be universal banks on a local scale are not really going to work.” Local domestic banks are being organized into 10 core groups, and have been given until the end of the year to work out mergers. “The central bank is receptive to what is going on around the world in terms of what is opening up,” says Bank of Novia Scotia’s Khan. “In its view six to 10 [domestic] banks will be adequate for Malaysia’s needs. They also subscribe to free competition and they think the foreign banks have specific expertise to add in terms of products and technical skills. In one-and-half years, when they open up there will be more entrants and the contribution will be in new technology, new products and delivery systems.” Foreign bank branch restrictions are becoming less of an issue globally, says Khan, as electronic delivery channels come on stream. “It is going to be a brand new world,” and there will be a place for the foreign banks, he says. Bank of Nova Scotia has a single branch in Malaysia. During the crisis its non-performing loans hit their worst point at just 1.5%. This year it has arranged two syndicated loans: a M$250 million facility for a subsidiary of the Boustead Group, and a U$100 million facility for a textile company that is close to completion. The bank also has ambitions to get into the public debt issuance business, for which a local rating is required. NPL mysteries Malaysian banks’ non-performing loans have been considerably lower than those elsewhere in the region. However, the banking situation is far from transparent. Some M$34 billion of bad loans have been taken over by the Danaharta agency and banks have different ways of classifying and accounting for the non-performing loans on their books. Figures are often quoted as net NPLs rather than gross, and the definitions of “non-performing” are not always consistent. Danaharta has acquired loans from the system at an average discount of 56% but has restructured or sold half of those, at an average recovery rate of 80%. “There is a little bit of smoke and mirrors,” says one bank analyst while noting that the system seems strong at 12.8% capital adequacy as of the end of February, well above the 8% minimum requirement. ABN, for example, which reports net non-performing loans at 2%, started a net writing-back position last year, after two years of provisioning, and it expected a net write-back again this year. It expected that cycle to be more delayed in the case of some of Malaysia’s other banks. So far the government has restructured M$14 billion of debt involving 19 cases. A further 26 cases are outstanding. Another of Malaysia’s great anomalies, and one of the reasons it appears to have weathered the crisis better than others, is its high savings rates, at around 40%. A compulsory 22% contribution to the state employee provident fund helps bolster the figures. The Malaysian economy may be improving but it is still some way off pre-crisis levels – analysts reckons there may be another 30% to go, and that there will need to be a year of stable growth before things are fully restored. The worry now is the impact of a slowdown in the US. “I do not think that Malaysia is an isolated economy,” says one analyst. “It is very open. It lives on trade, therefore if there are moves in the US there will be an impact.” Malaysia is treading a tightrope between liberalization, for example in its banking sector, and control. “There is no magic formula. We have quite an active central bank which is quite forward looking in some respects such as e-commerce.” Residential property prices have started to recover from their record lows of early last year. Already there is fear of overheating in the middle to lower-end housing market, fuelled by aggressive bank mortgage lending on the back of low interest rates. Bank Negara is estimating inflation at 3.2% for this year and ABN is putting it at 3%. The commercial property overhang could take another three years to clear, although the problem is not so much in downtown Kuala Lumpur, where good buildings are pretty full, as in the out-of-town locations where speculative commercial and resort developments have been built. Ridiculously low rates Liquidity is building up, though, causing a potential disincentive to save and encouraging banks to lend more aggressively. Competition for residential mortgage business is the most obvious manifestation, with “ridiculously low” and often fixed rates being offered. The Malaysian repayment mortgage system means that banks will lend on the basis of total repayment requirements of up to one-third of income. Thus as interest rates have fallen, the proportion of principal repayments, and therefore capital that can be lent, has increased, often to double that of pre-crisis times. The country now has an extremely low interest rate environment, with three-month interbank rates at around 3%. With such interest rates, the lower-end residential property market is booming, and a car can be bought for a down payment of around M$1,000. Could all this lead to a recurrence of the financial problems of the past three years? Mark Bullough, managing director Pesaka Jardine Fleming, puts the cause of the crisis down to overcapacity – “too much of everything, particularly bank lending”. The stock market index has gone from lows of 250 points to more than 1000 in 18 months. “That has added fuel to consumer spending,” he says. There is really nowhere to put your money. You cannot take it out and you only get 3% in the bank,” says a broker. “I have not seen much of the new investment taking place,” says Khan, “and the reason for that is that there is still some spare capacity in the economy after the downturn, and it may be another six to nine months before the capacity gets to its normal level before people start thinking about putting new money in. But it is the right time to start expanding your manufacturing capacity.” Pesaka Jardine Fleming’s Bullough says: “There are still some question marks. The presentation of the recovery has been very well managed and people’s confidence is coming back, and that brings about reality. Everyone is feeling pretty good. There’s no panic. The smarter investors are filling their boots with the stocks that foreigners will buy first, who believed the stock market was slightly artificially low at the low 900s, while Malaysia’s so-called technology stocks are less to do with dot com companies and more to do with traditional technology hardware manufacturers. I am the greatest cynic in town, and the good news is that general confidence is back. Generally, many parts of the economy, which are not necessarily part of the stock market, are doing better. If you talk to banks, especially foreign ones, they will tell you things are beginning to pick up.” So where will Malaysia be in another five to ten years’ time? The government is pressing ahead with its multimedia super corridor project, Mahathir Mohamad’s vision for a hi-tech centre on the outskirts of Kuala Lumpur, but the country needs to become a value-added manufacturer in order to compete globally, reckon many, including the government. One foreign analyst who visited the super corridor recently remarked that many of the workers arrived for work in the locally produced Proton cars, and wondered how competitive such an environment could be, given such costs. Opinions are divided on the country’s future. “I do not think it will be a disaster. I think they can manage their affairs quite well, but they are going to have a ball and chain round their ankles for the next 10 years,” says a banker. He describes the Malaysian economy as a pyramid, and poses the question: “At what layer in the pyramid can you inject reform without the whole thing falling over. Wherever you inject change it collapses, so everything above is reliant on the status above it. The priority here is status quo and nothing is going to affect that. “If all of this goes according to plan,” he continues, “it will be part of Asean, pottering along but with its relative economic strength and success diminished versus its Asian competitors, although it is slightly dependent on how much of a mess everyone else makes. When they went into the crisis Malaysia was well ahead of everyone else, but they have certainly failed to capitalize on the opportunity to play catch-up with Singapore. They could have been a regional hub – the infrastructure and language was there but not the will and the vision.” The sustainability of the recovery is a crucial issue, hence the focus on new ways for Malaysia to grow. The latest is the government’s concept of the K-economy – K standing for knowledge and focusing on value-added IT and service-based industry. Meanwhile, a financial sector master plan is due out by the end of the year and that is expected to place emphasis on consolidation of the domestic banking sector. Ten anchor banks have been identified following last year’s industry objections to the original attempt to restrict numbers to six core banking groups. Full merger of all banks into 10 groups is now due by the end of the year. Consolidation is also expected in the brokerage and insurance sectors. Downside risk Malaysia still faces downside risk, however, not least from external pressures. More than 22% of the country’s exports are to the US, leaving the country exposed if the US takes a hard landing. Political and economic issues are closely intertwined and political stability is a very important factor, says a local bank spokesman. The government has tried to kick start the economy by spending on infrastructure, but the consumer population of the country is still quite small, “and there does not seem to be an awful lot of spending going on,” says a commentator. “It all looks jolly good so long as the wheels don’t fall off,” he adds, referring to the boom in electronics exports, which have helped fuel the recovery. “Things are a hell of a lot better than they were a year ago. The risk has reduced, but it cannot be fortress Malaysia for ever.” HLG Securities is forecasting economic growth for the year of 6.8%, against the official estimate of 5.8%, and Jardine Fleming is reckoning on growth of 6% for this year. “We feel the recovery will carry on further with rising domestic demand, underpinned by further export expansion. The key driver will come from consumerism,” says HLG Securities’ Lee. He detects pent-up consumer demand, an improved job market, and more disposable income, fuelled by a recent 1% cut in income tax. The low interest environment and ample liquidity add to the picture, he says. Excess capacity in the commercial and speculative high-end residential and resort property market is still a concern, however, and inflation could be 3% for this year. “But any rise in interest rates will be very gradual,” he adds. “The world is becoming much smaller, and everything has an effect on everything else,” says Bank of Nova Scotia’s Khan. “Malaysia is not a maverick in this. It took a series of steps they felt would preserve stability in times of turmoil. When the times of turmoil are over these steps are no longer needed and the government will move towards removing them if it proves to be a hindrance to progress. The question is, is the turbulence over?” |